SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

A few posts in the forum made me think about relationships and suitablility. In the current track, everybody hates Sanchi. If people are against Jagya-Sanchi match, they think Sanchi is not suitable for Jagya. People are angry with Shekhars because they seem to bow down to Sanchi's zid. Perhaps even Anandi thought that Jagya does not need a wife like Sanchi, and not Sanchi does not need a husband like Jagya.

Creatives like to highlight the charecter of good person by showing simultaneously a bad antagonist. Sanchi is to Ganga what Gauri was to Anandi. To me, it is the ghisa-pita thing and does not give anybody to think about relationships.
Sanchi belongs to modern well-to-do family, she is educated and unmarried. Still she is considered unfit to marry Jagya (who married twice, and had so many shortcomings of charecters (drunken brawls, cheating, misrepresentation of facts in court, two court cases still pending agaist him etc.) because Sanchi is selfish, egoistic, bratty, nasty, immature, does not repect elders etc.
I think here CVs failed, for such track has already been in BV (Anandi-Jagya-Gauri). Imagine what if Sanchi's nature was like Shiv/Anandi/Ganga? A young, beautiful, unmarried girl from a well-to-do family falling in love with Jagya (perhaps without knowing that he is her bhabhi's ex) or may be in situations that is shown in current track (no one not even Anandi treats Jagya as Anandi's ex. CVs have made complete khichdi of relationships with Badi Haveli as Anandi's maika)? What if there was no Ganga (people like Jagya Ganga jodi, so they will oppose Jagya Sanchi anyway)?
If Sanchi's nature was like Anandi/Shiv and she fell in love with Jagya (of course if she had Anandi's nature, she would not annouce that she loves Jagya - but by her behaviour (like in case of Ganga), it was clear to other charecters that she wants to marry Jagya), what should have been the reaction of other charecters?

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

6.1k

Users

16

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

angelic8219 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
If sanchi's nature was like shiv/anandi/ganga you would think she thought it through carefully, you can even have a proper conversation about it, at the end of it you would think she has come to a mature decision knowing everything and taking on everyone's point of view into account. Also she would be ready for rejection and not pin all her hopes on it happening the way she thinks.

Sanchi is infact not fit to be in any marriage whether its to jagya or not, she's just not ready for it shes too immature to know what makes a relationship tick. she's not thought it through properly, sometimes it feels like shes competing against ganga, she has nothing in common with jagya hence shes fakng her own identity, she hardly knows him and takes everyone's advice with a pinch of salt. I would also say that Ganga and jagya are not ready for another marriage, Ganga has just come out of an abusive one and jagya needs space
monamie111 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: SPuja

A few posts in the forum made me think about relationships and suitablility. In the current track, everybody hates Sanchi. If people are against Jagya-Sanchi match, they think Sanchi is not suitable for Jagya. People are angry with Shekhars because they seem to bow down to Sanchi's zid. Perhaps even Anandi thought that Jagya does not need a wife like Sanchi, and not Sanchi does not need a husband like Jagya.

Creatives like to highlight the charecter of good person by showing simultaneously a bad antagonist. Sanchi is to Ganga what Gauri was to Anandi. To me, it is the ghisa-pita thing and does not give anybody to think about relationships.
i agree with u..this is the same ghisa pita thing CVs r showing...
Sanchi belongs to modern well-to-do family, she is educated and unmarried. Still she is considered unfit to marry Jagya (who married twice, and had so many shortcomings of charecters (drunken brawls, cheating, misrepresentation of facts in court, two court cases still pending agaist him etc.) because Sanchi is selfish, egoistic, bratty, nasty, immature, does not repect elders etc.
when jaggya cheated anandi or insulted his parents or asked for property's share or drank & misbehave with gauri...no one supported him in this forum! yes, people used to support gauri but i can't remember if anyone here supported that jaggya! at present people r liking him bcoz he is a changed person now...he has realized his mistakes & came back to his family...but at present can we consider saanchi as a good eprson?...i think saanchi is not a good match for any matured, calm person! she doesn't care for anybody..she can ruin any1's life in future!...jaggya has faced lto of trouble in his life..now when he is trying to reedem why to make his life hell again with a gal like saanchi?...let him reedem na...
I think here CVs failed, for such track has already been in BV (Anandi-Jagya-Gauri). Imagine what if Sanchi's nature was like Shiv/Anandi/Ganga? A young, beautiful, unmarried girl from a well-to-do family falling in love with Jagya (perhaps without knowing that he is her bhabhi's ex) or may be in situations that is shown in current track (no one not even Anandi treats Jagya as Anandi's ex. CVs have made complete khichdi of relationships with Badi Haveli as Anandi's maika)? What if there was no Ganga (people like Jagya Ganga jodi, so they will oppose Jagya Sanchi anyway)?
not sure about others but...i am not opposing jaggya-sanchi marriage bcoz i want jaggya-ganga marriage...i think if jaggya-ganga marriahe will not take place then also i will cope with it...but i don want SaJa marriage bcoz firstly, i don like saanchi at all..secondly, i don want anandi's life to be more complicated...& third reason, i don think saanchi loves jaggya..does she? 😕...
If Sanchi's nature was like Anandi/Shiv and she fell in love with Jagya (of course if she had Anandi's nature, she would not annouce that she loves Jagya - but by her behaviour (like in case of Ganga), it was clear to other charecters that she wants to marry Jagya), what should have been the reaction of other charecters?
this is really a good question...yes, that would be nice to see..what could have been the other character's reactions? 😉...i think still shekhar family's reaction would have been the same as their main corncern is jaggya has two failed marriage!..anandi's reaction could have been changed in this case...

tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
mona well said!!👏
Edited by tiny15 - 12 years ago
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
@tiny, I agree that no one wants Sanchi Jagya marriage, but the reason is Sanchi's nature only.
Personally, I do not think that we can appreciate good person only when we see a bad person. I think, creatives add such things just for drama and also for dragging.
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
if saanchi's character would have been like anandi and shiv she would not have fallen for jagya at the first place...even if she would have fallen then she would have acted maturely about it and not just blurt out her feelings and act like a despo
amiamrita thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Does Sanchi even have the understanding of marriage, or for that matter any relationship? It seems like a whimsical decision of a teenager, not of someone who has actually given a good thought over the matter
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: libsrocks

if saanchi's character would have been like anandi and shiv she would not have fallen for jagya at the first place...even if she would have fallen then she would have acted maturely about it and not just blurt out her feelings and act like a despo

She would have acted maturely, if her nature was better, but falling in love is not in one's hand, she could still have fallen in love with Jagya (at present Sanchi does not love J, we all know). But if Shiv's sister was like Anandi/Shiv, whether other charecters/people still think that Sanchi should not marry Jagya, and if so, the reasons.
753037 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Actually Puja the goal of the directors is to marry J to another child marriage victim(which is a good idea as per the original concept of the serial-Balika Vadhu). They can't show him falling in love with Ganga as his character would be butchered. So they had to make it an arranged marriage kind of thing with all the family members pushing him into it. At the same time it should also not look like J married Ganga due to lack of any other choice. So to high light his character this Sanchi was introduced. She would be all drooling for him..and though she is beautiful, rich, young, educated , modern and a girl who is entering into marriage for the first time...J would REJECT her and CHOOSE to marry a balika Vadhu. Neither the Shekar's nor the Singh's (includng Sumi) are bad here. It would be too dramatic if all the singh's go gaga over Ganga..so they made sumi a little over possessive. So here, Everything is all right! Ganga will be the choosen one. That doesn't mean he will marry her though.

It's just that i wished they showed this new Balika Vadhu to be a bold, dignified woman who has high self respect , who's assets would be boldness and sincerity in working hard to stand by her self. I didn't expect her to reduce to the level of a cry baby and let everyone know that she is in love already.👎🏼
goofyCat thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: samvi.

Actually Puja the goal of the directors is to marry J to another child marriage victim(which is a good idea as per the original concept of the serial-Balika Vadhu). They can't show him falling in love with Ganga as his character would be butchered. So they had to make it an arranged marriage kind of thing with all the family members pushing him into it. At the same time it should also not look like J married Ganga due to lack of any other choice. So to high light his character this Sanchi was introduced. She would be all drooling for him..and though she is beautiful, rich, young, educated , modern and a girl who is entering into marriage for the first time...J would REJECT her and CHOOSE to marry a balika Vadhu. Neither the Shekar's nor the Singh's (includng Sumi) are bad here. It would be too dramatic if all the singh's go gaga over Ganga..so they made sumi a little over possessive. So here, Everything is all right! Ganga will be the choosen one. That doesn't mean he will marry her though.


It's just that i wished they showed this new Balika Vadhu to be a bold, dignified woman who has high self respect , who's assets would be boldness and sincerity in working hard to stand by her self. I didn't expect her to reduce to the level of a cry baby and let everyone know that she is in love already.👎🏼

Very rightly said... Agree to each & every point !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".