Semifinal Score: Politics 10, Talent 0

plz dun create these type of topics state ur view but remember ur limitations

Originally posted by: amitguptag

The semifinal was the most depressing of all the episodes and a true pitcure of what India is all about: 'POLITICS' with no one including the judges having any clue as to whether they are judging a talent competition or a reality show.

Performance 1: They compare tanaaz to Helen and Bakhtiyar to Shammi Kapoor. Yet do not find anything wrong objectively with their performance and give them just 9. However when it comes to Tina and Hussain, why are they not compared to Madhuri and Prabhu Deva. They even admit that their performance was ok but end up giving them complete score.

Performance 2: The judges admit that Tanaaz and bakhtiyar's performance was so good that it brought tears to their eyes, yet when it came to giving points they gave them scores equivalent to the worst performances (Yash & Ghouri) of the day. i.e. 8

Talking about the judges, only Malaika was anywhere close to judging based on performance. For Kunal Kohli, even if Tina would not have performed, he would have given her 20 out of 10. Yes you read it right. If you have any doubts, watch any of the episodes. As far as Saroj Khan is concerned , she is probably getting a contract in Kunal Kohli's next movie and so he runs her judgement.

Originally posted by: Ektaj

Hmm.. so now since the tables have turned in HuTina's favour.. the whole show becomes rigged & its all POLITICS? Its the channel who is pulling the strings here..while all HuTina have done is stand in front of the judges and smile.. and voila, they got the scores!! 😃

The judges were happy to compare TB to Helen-Shammi Kapoor..coz their performance reminded them of the latter. HuTina were not compared to Prabhudeva-Madhuri, coz they did something different.. and both are achievements in their own right!

No doubt TB's Yaadein performance was good.. I loved it.. but then, I agree with Kunal when he said, with this song, TB maintained the same level as their Kal Ho Na Ho song..when they could've taken it a notch higher..

Everyone knows that TB are brilliant..and so the judges expect them to give brilliant performances. Talking about Kunal liking Tina.. maybe he does.. but he still has doubts if she can carry off certain things, like he mentioned after their K Sera Sera performance got over..