MADHUBALA IS A FICTION NT A SCHOOL. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.2k

Users

11

Likes

65

Frequent Posters

Heartless_Freak thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
nice post..n i think most of us watch all type of movies but still can differentiate btw good or bad den why can't we do dis wid a show..r we so dumb?? 😎

n dis show is a fiction not real life jispe itna drama ho..if it wud have been real den dis story itself wud not have started in d first place becoz in my opinion madhu is d most unrealistic person in d show..sometimes slapping a superstar n sometime saving a gangster..if u can take her as fictional why can't u do d same wid RK's charac?why double standards?😲🤢
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: love.abhay

nice post..n i think most of us watch all type of movies but still can differentiate btw good or bad den why can't we do dis wid a show..r we so dumb?? 😎


n dis show is a fiction not real life jispe itna drama ho..if it wud have been real den dis story itself wud not have started in d first place becoz in my opinion madhu is d most unrealistic person in d show..sometimes slapping a superstar n sometime saving a gangster..if u can take her as fictional why can't u do d same wid RK's charac?why double standards?😲🤢



Yes madhu did a very unrealistic and dumb thing slapping rk. It wasn't the brightest thing to do to go up against a gangster either and it is highly unlikely that some girl would do such a thing in real life.

The DIFFERENCE is that no one is ROMANTACISING madhu's behaviour. No one is saying madhu did a heroic thing. PPl are able to recognise it as unrealistic and just something that can be shown in indian tv shows. What the mahila mandali is unable to understand is:

1. PPl feel that rk should STILL get/deserves the girl (madhu) after all that he has done to her. (Nobody watching dexter thinks that his girlfriend deserves him!!).
2. That even though he has done all this, he still counts as a hero (NOBODY says dexter is the hero of that show!!)
3. Majority if not all of rishbala fans were chanting the redemption mantra not that long ago. Saying that they realise he has done wrong and that he should be sorry. He is not sorry. It has been made obvious that he will not be sorry. So..WHY IS HE STILL BEING SUPPORTED? WHY IS IT STILL RISHBALA?

Yes if you get amnesia of all and everything of previous episodes and just watch current episode, then I can understand it. Otherwise the only conclusion I am forced to draw is the one that I do.
Edited by Oh_No_Soaps - 12 years ago
-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
A post saying we don't need preaching and moral policing...And yet, what do we see in comments...??*Sigh* Some more preaching and moral policing..!!!.LOL😆😆State of this "mahaan" forum now..😳

For people who have forgotten about this rule..Here's a reminder...😉 It's copy and paste from DT-new rules btw!!😳

Preaching + Moral Policing Posts - Enough with the Rishbala fans did this, Sulbala do this and pinpointing members. We had allowed preaching posts given they were not targeting and attacking. However, all we see is preaching and moral policing on the forum today. Therefore, effective now - no more moral policing and preaching posts. Any posts made on members will beclosed down and given its content, it may even lead to a warning level increase.
Edited by dilnasheen - 12 years ago
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: dilnasheen

A post saying we don't need preaching and moral policing...And yet, what do we see in comments...??*Sigh* Some more preaching and moral policing..!!!.LOL😆😆State of this "mahaan" forum now..😳


For people who have forgotten about this rule..Here's a reminder...😉 It's copy and paste from DT-new rules btw!!😳

Preaching + Moral Policing Posts - Enough with the Rishbala fans did this, Sulbala do this and pinpointing members. We had allowed preaching posts given they were not targeting and attacking. However, all we see is preaching and moral policing on the forum today. Therefore, effective now - no more moral policing and preaching posts. Any posts made on members will beclosed down and given its content, it may even lead to a warning level increase.



Definition: Preaching
  1. Deliver a sermon or religious address to an assembled group of people, typically in church: "he preached to a large congregation".
  2. Publicly proclaim or teach (a religious message or belief).

Now go back to my post read it and apply this. <----- THAT is preaching. My post isn't. It doesn't tell you ANYTHING about my beliefs nor is it telling you to change yours. It is asking a question.

Now go and report this.


DonnaHarvey thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
I am sorry but in what language is PUB a swear word?
We can all agree or disagree with out involving s**t shaming.
There are trigger words in your post. I hope you know that and if not, please reference for future.
Edited by DonnaHarvey - 12 years ago
-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Oh_No_Soaps



Definition: Preaching

  1. Deliver a sermon or religious address to an assembled group of people, typically in church: "he preached to a large congregation".
  2. Publicly proclaim or teach (a religious message or belief).

Now go back to my post read it and apply this. <----- THAT is preaching. My post isn't. It doesn't tell you ANYTHING about my beliefs nor is it telling you to change yours. It is asking a question.

Now go and report this.



First of all sweetheart, I have NEVER reported a single person for "expressing their opinion"..Even the hardcore moral policing posts..!!So No need to be rude and start ordering me around...😛I'm neither your slave nor a desciple to follow through..😳 So if anyone has reported you anytime, it wasn't me.

So you were stung by my use of the word preaching..?In your opinion preaching only means it should be done in a church..??What about "moral policing:" then...?does that apply to your post..??😳

Here's the meaning for you..."When one feels they have to enforce morals."...😳
Did I just see your comment asking Rishbalian's exclusively why they are supporting RK still when he is wrong and why are we still supporting Rishbala..?
Let me assure you, we have our own brain cells to think and form our own opinions and our own reasons for it, which we are completely entitled to do btw.So we DO NOT need anybody enforcing their views on us..😳 and about that quip about what level of education we have gotten in schools..uh-uh..that's getting personal dear..!!😳

I did NOT quote any post, yet you have taken the comment personally..So I'd say that alone proves my point...😊

I'm sorry if you got offended by my comments..Wasn't my intention..Hence the "no quote"..!!😊 this one was just a reply to YOUR quote..So I'd like to say good night now..😊 contrary to what some believe we DO have our jobs to attend in the morning..😳
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: dilnasheen


My response in bold
First of all sweetheart,...thank you! I have NEVER reported a single person for "expressing their opinion"..Even the hardcore moral policing posts..!!So No need to be rude and start ordering me around...😛 ...my apologies for the ordering. And I wasn't rude.I'm neither your slave nor a desciple to follow through..😳 I have no need of followers or disciples so am glad -rk style doesn't appeal to me remember! So if anyone has reported you anytime, it wasn't me.Cool. Thx for letting me know

So you were stung by my use of the word preaching..?In your opinion preaching only means it should be done in a church..??What about "moral policing:" then...?does that apply to your post..??😳 You asked me a question. My answer is No! It doesn't apply to my post. But it does to yours!! 👏

My dear..note I didn't call you sweetheart. You are not worthy of my sarcasm. Nothing on this forum "stings" me. Mildly irritates yes, perplexes definitely, makes me wonder yes.

Here's the meaning for you..."When one feels they have to enforce morals."...😳
Enforce means... "Cause (something) to happen by necessity or force." So who is able to "enforce" anything let alone morals on the internet? Hmmm? Try talking sense. At least try. Speaking for myself, my dislike for rk's doesn't stem from any morals!

Did I just see your comment asking Rishbalian's exclusively why they are supporting RK still when he is wrong and why are we still supporting Rishbala..?
Let me assure you, we have our own brain cells ..pls notice..no sarcastic comment from me here.. 😳to think and form our own opinions and our own reasons for it, which we are completely entitled to do btw. YES you are! So GIVE your frigging opinion na!!! THAT is what I have been asking. That is what my QUESTION was in my last comment. WHY do you support rishbala? What did I get? "WE have our own brains and opinions blah blah blah...I say bull poopies! YOU did the policing by copying and pasting rules and then accuse ME of POLICING!😆 👏 Isn't it moral policing to quote and remind ppl of rules? But its ok...I can understand why you can't see the stye in your own eye ..So we DO NOT need anybody enforcing their views on us..😳 and about that quip about what level of education we have gotten in schools..uh-uh..that's getting personal dear..!!😳 Quote me correctly..😊 I said if you got more of an education period rather than just was was is needed to pass exams you (not you personally) would know what abuse is, what self respect is. Is it personal? No its my pov. No more personal that the personal pref of liking rk or sultan. Its a pov. Nobody is born knowing what self respect is or what abuse is.

I did NOT quote any post, yet you have taken the comment personally..So I'd say that alone proves my point...😊

I'm sorry if you got offended by my comments..this apology seems as genuine mickey mouse is real but its ok, I will take it at face value. 😊Wasn't my intention..Hence the "no quote"..!!😊. this one was just a reply to YOUR quote..So I'd like to say good night now..😊 contrary to what some believe we DO have our jobs to attend in the morning..😳. Errr...what do I say...congratulations on having a job? Ohhh you got stung by someone's comment about some peeps not having jobs.ok. ok. Wasnt' me. But still..congratulations on having a job. Dunno what else to say, coz its completely irrelevant to what is going on in this show. Or to this topic.

In a nutshell honeypie. Yes have your opinion. Pls have it. But if asked why you have it, try to explain why if asked and if you can't, at least don't accuse others of moral policing when you are the one doing it! 😆




-Dil- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
I'm sure any third party reading the comments will realize who's post was rude and whose wasn't.Whose post has (even milder version) swear words and whose doesn't..Whose posts were instigatory and whose wasn't..and whose post is polite and whose isn't..!!😳

P.S - I never knew stating the forum rules which are to be STRICTLY followed is called moral policing!!I was under the misconception that it refers to only when one tries to enforce change in the opinions and thinking!!My bad..!!!😊 I stand corrected..!!

One more thing which "stung" me though is talk of my worth..What am I worthy of..??🤔I hope my friends and family can answer this...😊 I'm really interested in knowing what they think I'm worthy of now...But hey it's not personal for people who don't know me to comment on my worth right..??of course not. Its a pov..I hope I got it right!!😳

As "stung" as I'm with the talk of my worth here, the mod's say either report or ignore but do not go in for fights.Since I don't report, I guess I will go for the second option..😳
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: dilnasheen

I'm sure any third party reading the comments will realize who's post was rude and whose wasn't.Whose post has (even milder version) swear words and whose doesn't..Whose posts were instigatory and whose wasn't..and whose post is polite and whose isn't..!!😳


P.S - I never knew stating the forum rules which are to be STRICTLY followed is called moral policing!!I was under the misconception that it refers to only when one tries to enforce change in the opinions and thinking!!My bad..!!!😊 I stand corrected..!!

One more thing which "stung" me though is talk of my worth..What am I worthy of..??🤔I hope my friends and family can answer this...😊 I'm really interested in knowing what they think I'm worthy of now...But hey it's not personal for people who don't know me to comment on my worth right..??of course not. Its a pov..I hope I got it right!!😳

As "stung" as I'm with the talk of my worth here, the mod's say either report or ignore but do not go in for fights.Since I don't report, I guess I will go for the second option..😳



No you are not worthy of my sarcasm. I save that for those who deserve and you don't. it coz it can be very cutting. You are worth more than that. You have chosen to expand that to you as a whole and brought your family and friends thoughts about you into it. I too hope that like me, they don't think you are worthy of my sarcasm.

As for the moral policing..moral police think that what THEY think/believe is the RULE. TO BE strictly followed I don't think that Nor have I tried to enforce it. You seemed to have skipped the part where I say that morals cannot be enforced on the internet even if one wanted them to be.

It is a moral duty to follow rules. You stated the forum rules and that even though the rules are there, ppl are not following...ergo moral policing. Rules and morals are not necessarily mutually exclusive! But I guess discussing that would take this all thing off to yet another tangent...

Yet again all i had asked was WHY do those who support rk support him. In what way do they support him. I know and I have stated many times, that I think rk is essential to this show. I don't want him out. You like other rk supporters again ignored this question. In the absence of any answers, I am forced to draw my own conclusion based on what is implied and how it is implied, what is chanted, etc and then ppl take umbrage and start shouting "moral policing" or "its just a fictional show" or "rishbala forever" or all 3!

Related Topics

Madhubala - Ek Ishq Ek Junoon Thumbnail

Posted by: Heja

6 days ago

Here are some proofs that Madhubala is not actually a good character

Madhubala's character in the series was portrayed as a character who showed mercy even to her well-intentioned enemy. But when I watched the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".