Episode 213 Discussion: 7th March 2013 - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

119

Views

18.1k

Users

32

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: _charu_


Shri, that was superb, awesome, mindblowing post 👏

I can't fathom from where it's coming from, all the negative reviews...it's been one month exactly since the unwedding drama happened, i can't locate any post where any of us justified RK's revenge, and that we want Rishbala together RIGHT NOW 🤢 I'm with you on this issue, I'm here for good discussions on MB the serial...all of us have a liking for some character or the other but that's about it...i won't be a part of ED thread if that was the case...at the end of the day , the show should be enjoyable...

ETA I'm not insecure about Rishbala 😆 frm my side, if Madhu wishes, she can marry Sultan or even his servant...to me, it's her wish which counts..all i wish is that she knows what she's getting into this time around..


Charu,
Huge Thank you for the support you showed.

@bold I was so upset at reading that. I was like...what...when ..how...!!! And if analysis as introspective from within character shoes and retrospective outside character shoes, does speak of plausible reasons for revenge, that does not mean justification of the event. Right ? There is always the character point and there is always the people against him point of view. And when the character is explicitly cursed in the drama, who has the guts to defend his actions...it just becomes a review for us...a reaction towards an action - the event.

We are not here to pass judgements. We are just here to present our views in an amicable manner. And we have corrected between ourselves if we became biased and skewed in our opinion. And we have all supported each other to keep the thread neutral.

supercool3 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
Finally got around to watching the episode 😆

It was more or less just establishing the setting and characters for the upcoming drama. Yesterday the CVs reminded the audience of Madhu's basic characteristics. Today it happened to all other characters, with RK being the main focus.

Madhu, I know you're insane. Each time someone tries to put you down, you jump even higher. But did you hit your head on something (the tree yesterday I guess) that you forgot about what to do when lost -- Like call and inform immediate family members. 😆

RK, did you watch a lot of action movies recently? I mean, look at the speed you're shooting at. 😲 I like it, but I don't think those around you have the capability to handle this. Keep calm dude 😎

I liked what I saw of the Aryan-Sultan relationship. I hope to see the writers exploring that angle a lot more in upcoming episodes.

The bonding between Aryan and Madhu was cute. I liked it as well. But it just looked misplaced a bit. I guess I'll take it as the calm before the storm.

Overall, throughout the episode I felt that CVs were creating a situation where the ball is in Sultan's court. And all other characters, RK and Madhu included, are currently the players.

Precap - One of my favourite songs! <3
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Ananya05

Keeping aside all the relevant bloopers, logic and the fact that this was the first time Madhu had met Aryan, I liked the interaction between Madhu and Aryan. It was indeed very adorable and warming. And the kid is very very cute. 😉


And it bothered me.

What would a father feel, who is raising kid the way he wants, tough manner, even if it was insensitive; to see a woman who is no one to his kid, showering all attention that he denied to his kid. As it is children are hungry for love and affection. What if the child craves for something that he cannot provide.

Would not have been a problem if Madhu was the boy's nurse or governess. She was just a temporary person in Sultan's house. How is even correct for Madhu to bond with the kid ?

At random, we can support what Madhu did as right. Consoling a scared kid. All logical and natural.
But again an emotional trap for Madhu and viewers. Why form an equation with a kid with whom you know there cannot be a rishta ? Well ...all okay for me, if I know that Madhu is going to stay in that home for good. Just that it did not seem like that.
zoya_naziya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Cutieee1992

Can I too share my views here? I hope no one minds.

I feel we don't analyse Madhu through her character, that's why find her dumb etc when she clearly isn't. It's how her character is. She is always ready to help even if ther person don't, want it. Always adaptable to her environment easily.

When she did the same with RK, we didn't find anything wrong in her actions after all she is doing better for RK, but we do find her wrong when she does the same with others after all she isn't doing it for RK. However, I will say RK isn't her life. I mean we can't expect her out of her character with others, but feel okay with her when she does the same with RK.

She has a character of her own. & She will be same to everyone. That's my Pov. I hope no one minded it. 😳


You are welcome to share your views over here:)

@bold: We protested even when she did for RK back then, in the early days of their r'ship... It is only after RK allowed and accepted what she did for him, did we calm down...

0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Cutieee1992

Can I too share my views here? I hope no one minds.

She has a character of her own. & She will be same to everyone. That's my Pov. I hope no one minded it. 😳


Personally, I have never refused to see the way you are asking me to see her. I have called her muddlehead. Yes, if Madhu was my sister, my daughter, I would have been praying to God, that this girl does not get me and my family into any trouble.

And yet I have loved her equally like any other character in the drama (except Dips). And if on the days she makes me happy, I praise her. On the days, I feel her neglecting her family the most, the basic principles of femininity, I react. Is that a problem ? Hope we do have some kind of freedom to expect logic and practicality when people all of sudden display thinking from heels rather than head.

We cannot always blame it on CVs if CVs have purposefully designed the characters like that ..so that drama can happen.

Since when we have become Madhu bashers...that people are getting so insecure. If CVs churn out the drama like this for two days, we are equally criticising Madhu and RK. I think people need to read our reviews carefully especially the one we put on the summary snapshot on Page 1. We don't add every post to that list. That's the collective thought there.
Ananya05 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0


Charu,
Huge Thank you for the support you showed.

@bold I was so upset at reading that. I was like...what...when ..how...!!! And if analysis as introspective from within character shoes and retrospective outside character shoes, does speak of plausible reasons for revenge, that does not mean justification of the event. Right ? There is always the character point and there is always the people against him point of view. And when the character is explicitly cursed in the drama, who has the guts to defend his actions...it just becomes a review for us...a reaction towards an action - the event.

We are not here to pass judgements. We are just here to present our views in an amicable manner. And we have corrected between ourselves if we became biased and skewed in our opinion. And we have all supported each other to keep the thread neutral.



Shri,

Loved all your posts today. 👏 👏 I am going to read them all again for the peace of my mind. Not quoting all for obvious reasons. 😆

This thread has always been neutral with intelligent and logical analysis, and that is why it is such a relief from the MF. MF is just pure torture and suffocation barring a few good writers. I was shocked to know that the analysis and discussions in this thread were perceived as justification of RKs revenge and also recent posts stating that this thread is Madhu bashing adda, did not help.

And I don't see anything wrong in being a phangurl. Whats so wrong in admiring an eye candy of an actor with excellent screen presence doing justice to all the bombastic dialogues he has to deliver? For me, being a phangurl does not mean that one has justified RKs revenge and want Rishbala to unite. These are two completely different things. Why it has to be mingled with the desire of RK and Madhu reunion, I do not understand.


Ananya05 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0


And it bothered me.

What would a father feel, who is raising kid the way he wants, tough manner, even if it was insensitive; to see a woman who is no one to his kid, showering all attention that he denied to his kid. As it is children are hungry for love and affection. What if the child craves for something that he cannot provide.

Would not have been a problem if Madhu was the boy's nurse or governess. She was just a temporary person in Sultan's house. How is even correct for Madhu to bond with the kid ?

At random, we can support what Madhu did as right. Consoling a scared kid. All logical and natural.
But again an emotional trap for Madhu and viewers. Why form an equation with a kid with whom you know there cannot be a rishta ? Well ...all okay for me, if I know that Madhu is going to stay in that home for good. Just that it did not seem like that.



It is a trap. What is the need to show a don with a handicapped kid otherwise? Why not show a plain, ruthless, underworld gangster with no weaklings in his life?

I won't deny that the bonding was not bothering me.


640117 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0



<font color="#3300ff">Personally, I have never refused to see the way you are asking me to see her. I have called her muddlehead. Yes, if Madhu was my sister, my daughter, I would have been praying to God, that this girl does not get me and my family into any trouble.</font>

<font color="#3300ff">And yet I have loved her equally like any other character in the drama (except Dips). And if on the days she makes me happy, I praise her. On the days, I feel her neglecting her family the most, the basic principles of femininity, I react. Is that a problem ? Hope we do have some kind of freedom to expect logic and practicality when people all of sudden display thinking from heels rather than head.</font>

<font color="#3300ff">We cannot always blame it on CVs if CVs have purposefully designed the characters like that ..so that drama can happen.</font>

<font color="#3300ff">Since when we have become Madhu bashers...that people are getting so insecure. If CVs churn out the drama like this for two days, we are equally criticising Madhu and RK. I think people need to read our reviews carefully especially the one we put on the summary snapshot on Page 1. We don't add every post to that list. That's the collective thought there.</font>




Shri - In the beginning even I used to critisize her during Mukund time , but at the same time she was being righteous, so I didn't where to look for. I Guess people can't balance their actions. I mean it was good that she was being righteous about accident case & was fighting for justice, but at the same time she ignored her family especially Trishna'!s career. Then RK, she again did the same. I didn't know if she should be selfish & think about her family or become selfless & try to fix other people's lives even if they don't want it.


But now I am okay with her these traits. These self-righteous make her look so good, but it's also being selfish in a twisted way like she ignores her family or even herself & bring problem for herself & family. Then when I think about it, so do we want her to become selfish? We would've then too have la problem with it.


RS said that no character will be full positive /negative, so now I am okay with Madhu's character negative traits even though they look positive, but actually are negative. I don't mind it anymore after what RS said & I am glad she too have some negative traits than just being perfect.

Don't know if it made sense. I am not really good with words or analysis, so sorry if it didn't make sense.

And regarding the freedom of. sharing opinions, of course we can always do it & agree with you. We should all have freedom of when we want to critisize characters /tracks etc. & I never thought this thread members to be Madhu bashers. Please don't take it like that, but yes, I did feel we are being too strict with Madhu's actions without understanding her character. That's why I made this comment. I always read the analysis here & a silent reader.
Edited by Cutieee1992 - 12 years ago
sadumaneet thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Its show they need reasons to move story forward thats why they show characters doing mistakes or act silly this is how from day one if u go back and see in Mukund case this exactly happen Madhu forcefully wanted justice though Mukku's own family wants to give up.

Problem is when we demand for little bit logic in story and become sarcastic abt character dumbness and laugh on the same be it Madhu or RK we become basher. In this forum people judge u from ur current comment they very convincingly forget what u had post in past. Shri u really don't worry people will talk for few days and eventually everything will be alright.

P. S. This is coming from hardcore Drashti /Madhu fan.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Ananya05



And I don't see anything wrong in being a phangurl. Whats so wrong in admiring an eye candy of an actor with excellent screen presence doing justice to all the bombastic dialogues he has to deliver? For me, being a phangurl does not mean that one has justified RKs revenge and want Rishbala to unite. These are two completely different things. Why it has to be mingled with the desire of RK and Madhu reunion, I do not understand.


absolutely Ananya 👏

Out of the lead pair if we like only one and detest the other, we can never enjoy the show...it's a matter of personal choice if anyone wants to do it and make it unpleasant for others...I like Madhu & RK but I admire RK's character more bec. of all the reasons you mentioned above..i enjoyed his madness yest...😆 he's full of surprises..

if i analyze the story, I said it once that Madhu should not go back to RK, ideally ! i still maintain it... RK will pay for his sins, what goes around comes around, it's the law of nature ...i foresee a very painful phase coming up for him... t's just that CV's will come to that point slow and steady..and Sultan will be the catalyst...I wud love to watch RK & Madhu together again but not without a proper redemption track ...also the showdown b/w Sultan and RK will be something to watch out for..I don't see Madhu falling in love with Sultan but after RK's revenge drama, nothing will surprise me..i did that mistake once, i won't do it again...I'll go with the flow..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".