Why Asad took so long to rescue Zoya? Unjustified!

moonstruck thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
This was such an amazing but also terrifying episode!!Felt like i was watching a crime show...or something on another level...not a daily soap.
HOWEVER...I'm really angry that they showed asad leave with those people after seeing Zoya, 1)unconcious 2)among dirty men 3) among bunch of dirty men with guns 4) looked like they were digging...he could see that when he was leaving.
Asad knew the kind of men they were...they could have raped her, shot her...whatever else god knows but he KNEW they would kill her - yet still he kept walking 😡
On top of that he went into the goddamn car! I was disgusted. 😡
At first i thought he was only walking because he was pretending to go with the men and was looking for a chance to break free...but NO.
Why the hell did it take asad to find out that mariam was raped in order to go back and save Zoya???
If Mariam hadn't been raped or he hadn't found out, would Asad have left Zoya to be buried alive!!??
I really need some answers from the makers because just for the sake of creating drama they (and other shows) pass the limits of sense and decency.
They could have shown Asad struggling to go back to Zoya and save her...and then after hearing about Mariyam's rape getting even more aggressive about escaping and saving Zoya.
This was really wrongly portrayed by cvs. Very wrong.
edited
I like people's responses.
It's nice to hear different viewpoints.
I understand that a lot of you have said it probably took him some time to realise what was happening and then process it...then formulate a practical plan to save Zoya as like you say he can't run with her when she is unconcious. Good point.
Nor do I think it would have been realistic to show him fight all the goons who have guns.
But ... there is a subtelty of reaction that was missing...they could have shown him looking horrified and confused and shown a bit of a struggle...struggle.. i say...not FIGHT. Then perhaps his uncle would have slapped him..dragged him away...i don't know.
And nor do I feel disappointed by his behaviour because I think he is the hero and should save the heroine no matter what. that didn't cross my mind.
I think what upset me was as a show promoting modernism and struggle against traditional culture etc
I felt Asad didn't need to be in love to save a girl. It doesn't matter that she annoyed him and put him in trouble, she doesn't deserve death for it, he should do it for the sake of humanity. (Although they have already shared some emotional moments so there is a connection there anyway).
Even if she was a stranger whether Asad is a guy or girl I'd expect them to show some feeling and try and rescue the victim...especially when the victim is going to be buried alive.
Personally I don't think the time lapse they showed was anything to do with Asad's character and how he behaves - I think it was to create drama...increase tension..a conscious decision by CVs... but it didn't sit well with me
Edited by moonstruck - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

4.1k

Users

29

Likes

114

Frequent Posters

-RohitMaxwell- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I find it normal cz its really takes time to think which so many events are happening together; its normal to process all the infos on mind taking times cause he isn't in love with her to save her in cost of his life. also i don think he knew the cruelty of villagers
nikita_786 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Coz he is normal human being... He is not perfect or mahan... Every1 has flaws
Mystic_nights_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
asad couldnt have reacted in any other way
hhe had no other options against the goons...they would have killed both of them...i found it a perfect scene...
RosyRosh thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
I think his reaction was justified. At first i was disappointed too, but u have to think about the fact that he was flustered and its a normal reaction.. He was processin and if he rebelled, he would have been killed too so he had to wait to get them off his back so he can go back and save zoya.. Otherwise both would be dead and pointless
-iLoveKaran- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
see to b honest...what he did was justified coz he cant fight 10 men at one time and he knows that zoya is unconsious so if he trys to run she wont b able to run with him he cant just pick her up n run infront of 10 men...i think he knew that to keep zoya alive he needs to b alive so he first saved his life n then saved zoyas bcoz when he came bck the goons were gone so it was easier for him n plus there were too many things happening at one time he needed sum time to think and calulate what to do next
Rogue... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
I think he did exactly the rgt thing !!...there were far too many armed men !...trying to do sumthi'n heroic o'er there wud mean getting himself buried beside Zoya ! ...guess he acted very sensibly !
Oishi23 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Dont u think it would have too much unrealistic if he would have fought with 10 strong people...who was carrying Guns & swords?
then everyone would have said..too much action..unbelivable scenes..heroic actions..
So I prefer this realistic and Asad type...solution..who later realised that He cant leave zoya like that
Champa2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Character Asad is a practical person. Rational, practical person would've done just what he did today. If he had tried to fight them, they would've shot him immediately. Of course, if it was zoya, she would've done what you are expecting. Wouldn't have thought about the reactions and just acted.

I thought it was more natural this way than showing him fight off 10 men with weapons to save her. That would've been too dramatic. Of course, they could've turned it around like Yash would come in the car and run few of them down the vehicle and help Asad to save Zoya, but that would've been too dramatic for a soap too. Cops are no use in this track anyways since they will do whatever the sarpanch says.
blessing-beauty thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
If Asad had fought during tht time they wud have killed him tooo n as a normal person too it took certain time to register what was happening at that moment Coz so many things came in front of him at 1st the dead body then suddenl;y Zoyas fainting n all of sudden the goons...He cudnt have saved him or Zoya if he had fought or went againnst those cruel villagers who had swords pistols in their hand unlike other times when the goons khali haat ..whatever he did i felt it was justified

P.S idk if i had made sense or not but i wrote what i felt after watching the epi

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".