why so unfair ??

in the poll "is ravinder ravi better then aditi paul " people voted "no" .. then why do u all feel that ravinder ravi ws voted out after aditi paul ?
why so unfair to aditi ?? i mean both didnt win but still she's the 6th best and he's the 5 best .. he is considered 5th best and aditi next to him .. is this fair ? for me she is the 5 th best and ravinder 's 11th cause he can sing only punjabi songs ..

I completly agreed with u sweetheart,, Aditi Paul has gr8 talent
& i personly like Aditi more then Prajakta,, coz Aditi has a
mature sence of singing & she can sing all the types of songs,,

In case of Ravinder,, i never understand why judges even
select him as a top 11 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😕

i too agree with both of u i feel that aditi paul is better and as far as i feel ravinder has been able to come till the 5th best just because of the public vote other wise there were some times when he was not at all singing well

i felt exactlyt the same way.. in the poll i posted a similar post..

I feel rather than music emotion took the lead and people wanted him to win atleast something before he bows out.

i totally agree with everyone here. actually Aditi was way better than Ravi. people just pitied him because of his financial condition being worse. so, even a highly talented singer like Saxena was voted out early instead of Ravi, although Ravi sang worse than Saxena on the same round and went off-tune. people's votes poured in out of pity for Ravi, not because of his talent, as the indian audience is extremely emotional. the voters thought that Ravi literally needed the prize money more than anyone else participating in the contest. but in case of such important nationwide contest where only a few candidates are selected, the emotional voters should not have done injustice to the talented ones.

Originally posted by: sweetremix

in the poll "is ravinder ravi better then aditi paul " people voted "no" .. then why do u all feel that ravinder ravi ws voted out after aditi paul ?
why so unfair to aditi ?? i mean both didnt win but still she's the 6th best and he's the 5 best .. he is considered 5th best and aditi next to him .. is this fair ? for me she is the 5 th best and ravinder 's 11th cause he can sing only punjabi songs ..

in addition Abhijeet won but it doesnt mean we was the best.... i can name 4-5 ppl who were much better than him in the Indian Idol

yes shabanaz but dont u agree that aditi ws better than him ? i also agree that sana's beter than abhijeet but that ws because of looks that he ws voted .. ppl didnt vote amit cause he ws too bad and then only abhijeet ws okay in looks and he sang preety well but what bout ravinder ? only financially ?

Ure right. Personally, i think Aditi Paul was the best out of every1. Ppl just got emotional abt RR but even then they took it too far as he was voted out after singers who were much more talented than him. Unfair to all of them!!