Reply: Why is Sameer in the show?

gana_priya thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Because this show had to reach a new low in recent days.

Otherwise, how can you explain Sameer's selection to a national level singing competition. I was shocked when a kid who sang ordinarily a ordinary song of a nasal singer was selected among the 6 late entrants for the top 22. Then I waited every week hoping that he would be out, that some sense would prevail on the 3 judges(or jokers?). But that was not to be.

I have nothing against this kid. I'm purely talking in terms of the theme of the show, i.e. singing. It needed a Jagjith singh atlast to tell the truth that Sameer lacks "Saans, isliye awaaj kamjor lagtha hai our awaaj me sur nahi lagtha". If not for Jagjithji, I'm sure that day all the three jokers would have given A+.

Now I'll describe Sameer's singing: He absolutely lacks breath (same as Twinkle, lacks strength, melody not even in the vicinity). He strugles so much , one can even see his nerves on the neck. There is a misconception among the people, that whenever a person strugles too much for singing, he is "dil se gaa raha hai" .

Then come to his tantrams. I think initially from his facial expression I could observe that even he was surprised at the continuing selection of his. Later on he tried to overact to look more cute, staged various little dramas at various stages including the one in which Shaan wept.

All in all more than the shock it gives me pain to see this state of affair of our music, our people's sense of judgement, how a mass brain wash can be done. I appreciated Abhijith as a great passionate singer(he still is),but can not beleive he too is part of this biggest tragical joke in the history of this show, oh, it is such a painfull experience every week to change the channel whenever this cute kid Sameer jumps cutely on to the stage.

God please give a sense of judgement to our people.

Created

Last reply

Replies

144

Views

7.4k

Users

45

Frequent Posters

rewasen thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
VERY TRUE 👏 I COMPELETLY AGREE WITH YOU.
Bhaskar.T thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#3


Not again.......

Why do you all have to bash these kids always. If Sameer has faults in singing then other have too. To sing this way at this agre is a credit in itself.

Just a question to all who are criticising these kids. How many of you can sing as well as they are doing at is age??? And that too on that SRGMP stage???

Encourage them. Stop criticising them please....



rewasen thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
Nobody is crticizing the kids,its their singing in question that too bcoz of the show.y wud anybody be against the kids.
i am sure everybody appreciates their efforts. 👏
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Sameer is in the show because he performed well in the auditions to get selected.He is in the show, because he has been doing fairly well.He is in the show because the judges and the public want him to be in the show.

He is in the show, because he has proved he can perform very well on stage despite his young age and he is in the show because he is more talented than me or you.

Does this answer your question !!!!

Edited by adi_0112 - 19 years ago
Guardian Angel thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Here we go again! I am beginning to feel real sorry for MODS and Sameer supporters. You people writing such Forum must be real paranoid about Sameer. I think after this is all over all Sameer supporters and the entire SRGMP team here will need a great big vacation!! 😆 AND WE WISH TO TAKE ADI TOO WITH US, ok Adi!!!!
Edited by Kusum MB - 19 years ago
shamil thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: gana_priya

Because this show had to reach a new low in recent days.


Otherwise, how can you explain Sameer's selection to a national level singing competition. I was shocked when a kid who sang ordinarily a ordinary song of a nasal singer was selected among the 6late entrants for the top 22.Then I waited every week hoping that he would be out, that some sense would prevail onthe 3judges(or jokers?). But that was not to be.


I have nothing against this kid. I'm purely talking in terms of the theme of the show, i.e. singing. It needed a Jagjith singh atlast to tell the truth that Sameer lacks"Saans,isliye awaajkamjor lagtha hai our awaajme sur nahi lagtha". If not for Jagjithji, I'm sure that dayall the three jokers would have given A+.


Now I'll describe Sameer's singing: He absolutely lacks breath (same as Twinkle, lacks strength,melody not even in the vicinity). He strugles so much , one can even see his nerves on the neck. There is a misconceptionamong the people, that whenever a person strugles too much for singing, he is "dil se gaa raha hai" .


Then come to his tantrams. I think initially from his facial expression I could observe that even he was surprised at the continuing selection of his. Later on he tried to overact to look more cute,staged various little dramas at various stages including the one in which Shaan wept.


All in all more than the shock it gives me pain to see this state of affair of our music, our people's sense of judgement, how a mass brain wash can be done. I appreciated Abhijith as a great passionate singer(he still is),but can not beleive he too is part of this biggest tragical joke in the history of this show, oh, it is such a painfull experience every week to change the channel whenever this cute kid Sameer jumps cutely on to the stage.


God please give a sense of judgement to our people.







If some of u think that way, its ur opinion.Dont post it as if all of us shd agree with u. I love his way of singing and so does a lot of others. If it really pains and shocks u people to see him sing, just stop watching the show. 🤢
shamil thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Kusum MB

Here we go again! I am beginning to feel real sorry for MODS and Sameer supporters. You people writing such Forum must be real paranoid about Sameer. I think after this is all over all Sameer supporters and the entire SRGMP team here will need a great big vacation!! 😆 AND WE WISH TO TAKE ADI TOO WITH US, ok Adi!!!!


😭 Take me too...kusumji .I feel exhausted 😆 😆 😆
srgmp-fan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Bhaskar.T



Not again.......

Why do you all have to bash these kids always. If Sameer has faults in singing then other have too. To sing this way at this agre is a credit in itself.

Just a question to all who are criticising these kids. How many of you can sing as well as they are doing at is age??? And that too on that SRGMP stage???

Encourage them. Stop criticising them please....


Bhaskar.T:
Stop being the forum "Police" 😡
We are having healthy conversations but yet again you put your foot in between, Please stay away.

shamil thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: srgmp-fan


Bhaskar.T:Stop being the forum "Police" 😡We are having healthy conversations but yet again you put your foot in between, Please stay away.



Go and have private conversations pls. Ur 'healthy conversation' makes us sick 🤢

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".