Harry Potter Debate*SPOILER*

Page

Next Last

Charmed1

@Charmed1

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

Let's Debate!:)

Let's talk about this whole Snape thing

How can he do this? Dumbledore trusted him!!! 😡

Comments PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!

Quote

Frequent Posters

ketaki_ry

@ketaki_ry

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 20 years ago

If Dumbledore really trusted snape for that silly reason, then I think snape is pure evil!

and if there was something else dumbledore trusted snape for (which he didnt reveal to harry,) then there is a lot to add in the story..😊

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rashmi

@*Rashmi*

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 20 years ago

I'm firmly rooted to the belief that Snape is not evil. It's just a thing I have at the moment. I can't believe that Dumbledore, the wisest man Harry knew (why he said so himself) could be fooled that easily. He must have seen something in Snape which made him stand by him for so long. Therefore, I belief Dumbledore, for reasons known to him, asked Snape to kill him. Snape can't be evil... why, how many times have Harry and Ron thought so, and turned out to be wrong? Couldn't they have been wrong yet again?

Quote

Meha

@meha

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

I AM ALL FOR 'SNAPE IS NOT EVIL' thing!!!

Quote

sumant

@sumant

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

i am for the thing that 'snape is not evil'but could anyone tell me the reason as to why snape told harry that he was tha HBP

Quote

seeya

@ronit13

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

i think there have to be a better reason 4 dumbledore to believe snape

Quote

seeya

@ronit13

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

and i think there is which will be revealed in book 7 i hope so

Quote

Charmed1

@Charmed1

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

I think snape must have been knocked off his rocker when he saw harry use HIS spell

Quote

lakshmi

@lucky_lakshmi

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

Originally posted by: *Rashmi*
I'm firmly rooted to the belief that Snape is not evil. It's just a thing I have at the moment. I can't believe that Dumbledore, the wisest man Harry knew (why he said so himself) could be fooled that easily. He must have seen something in Snape which made him stand by him for so long. Therefore, I believe Dumbledore, for reasons known to him, asked Snape to kill him. Snape can't be evil... why, how many times have Harry and Ron thought so, and turned out to be wrong? Couldn't they have been wrong yet again?

i agree!dumbledore is really the wisest man in the world n he himself is confdent that he is not being fooled by snape!great man dumbledore!if dumbledore has belief in snape there is a very good reason 4 that!i am sure!afterall albus is a great legimens (snape too is good) but do u think snape is better that dumbledore in clesing his mind all along!dun think so!