Sugni V/S Kuhu

Page

Ron

@ronshaan

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Hi every one .

If we say Sugni got raped then Kuhu got raped Too.

Both woman had a choice but they choose to do it

Sugni could - LEAVE , DIE , RUN AWAY , CHECK WHAT HAPPENED WITH ADI , REFUSE , FIGHT BACK ext

Kuhu could - LEAVE , REFUSE , SAY NO , ext

both of those woman did it willingly ...

Vkram did not jump on sugni and force her into it... yes he blackmailed her but also did digvijay

every male said something else

Vikram to Sugni - DO IT WITH ME ELSE ILL KILL YOUR HUSBAND

Digvijay to Kuhu - DO IT WITH ME ELSE ILL KILL MY SELF..

IF SUGNI IS RAPED SO KUHU ALSO RAPED

but is it rape ?? rape is when some one force the other do this without his will but here both woman AGREE to this then is it rape ?

Edited by ronshaan - 12 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Joyel

@Joyel

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Rape may be classified on the basis of circumstances prevailing in the lifestyle and culture of people living in different countries,whether,if a husband forces his wife to have sex with him without her intention,is also grouped under the category of rape.But kuhu did it intentionaly,but the case of sugini;she has to prove herself in the court of law.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

indianstargyul

@indianstargyul

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

i differ in my opinion here. Kuhu was not raped.Kuhu is very naive She was manipulated into doing it , i agree but which woman after she is raped come out happy and smiling. Did you all look at her when she met Sugni at the bus station and then she looked up @ Digvijay and she had love on her face.

. Cvs also made them get married because all along in this serial, as i ahev said before, everythingis symbolic, and just by putting sindoor on a woman's forehead amongs to marriage. so we can say they got "married" cvs tried to legalize tthe act in this way.

In Sugni's case, it was different, despite the fact that she consented to it, it was under duress We have to look at the intention behind the action.

Afterwards she looked somewhat violated, and i guess she must be in a dazed as to what happened to her, hence her reaction or lack of it. I think her main concern is for Adi right now . She hasnt had time to really digest all that have happened and the consequences.

on another note, i know we mad at cvs, but we have to rememeber the foundation this story was built on,, teh story of Bednis who tried to change her lifestyle . Maybe they trying to show us that there is no escape for a custom that is so deeply embedded and is very difficult to divert from.it, as long as there ae rich and powerful people who condone it. however they should not have made Vickram nice person at the beginning and then drastically turn around his character;he should have had true thakur's character; then the entire story line would have been acceptable in some way.

And this may be the reality of life for these women, so we cannot hide from the truth. CVS just exposing a culture... its up to us to look at it or reject its contents.

Quote

Dr J Bhattacharya

@jmoyee200

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ronshaan
Hi every one .

If we say Sugni got raped then Kuhu got raped Too.

Both woman had a choice but they choose to do it

Sugni could - LEAVE , DIE , RUN AWAY , CHECK WHAT HAPPENED WITH ADI , REFUSE , FIGHT BACK ext

Kuhu could - LEAVE , REFUSE , SAY NO , ext

both of those woman did it willingly ...

Vkram did not jump on sugni and force her into it... yes he blackmailed her but also did digvijay

every male said something else

Vikram to Sugni - DO IT WITH ME ELSE ILL KILL YOUR HUSBAND

Digvijay to Kuhu - DO IT WITH ME ELSE ILL KILL MY SELF..

IF SUGNI IS RAPED SO KUHU ALSO RAPED

but is it rape ?? rape is when some one force the other do this without his will but here both woman AGREE to this then is it rape ?