Ek Hazaaron Mein Meri Behana ?????

munnihyderabad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Disclaimer: please do not copy my work to FB or any other social networking sites ..without my prior consent and due credit..


Ek Hazaaron mein meri behana hai - what does it impart, so different and unique in terms of the relation between two sisters ? .Right from the 1st episode it intended and showed in making one sister the bhagwan to the other sister, by forgoing her unborn and save her sister . Is this the whole intention of the story from the diya scene in ganghat to BMT.. that ek hazaaron mein meri behana hain .. is to save a sister from death by sacrificing her unborn..

but in all this, there are innumerable demises, of the basic foundation blocks of human relations .. the trust, the support for her sister , protecting (not about BMT) your kid sister, standing by your your little sister, understanding her intentions ..on a .day to day basis... where there is unconditional love.. wouldn't you care to give an opportunity to your sister to explain herself.. don't you want to believe in her words.. don't you see the truth in her eyes. don't you see through the intentions in her heart ..

but in trying to glorify this single objective of the show, a sister saving another sister,I say that particular track is the spinal cord,, but what about the sensory nerves .. .they have missed out big time on the basic things, between the sisters.. where is the implicit trust? where is the firm support ? where is the protectiveness (I don't want to talk about BMT here ) ? where are the convictions.. her decisions are always influenced...where is the pillar of strength ? where is the understanding ? what is the priority of your sister in your life ?

If you go by the title one in a million sister,... let's see how the sister's trust, her support, her belief and her convictions in her choti behen are shown '

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Karan Singh Shekawat:

It was jeevika's inquisitiveness,,, she asked Mannu about Maanvi's reference to Karan over the phone.. Maavi explains .. Jeevika is all ears to Maanvi's conversation without a question .. As and when she speaks of Swamini bua.. Jeevika drifts back to Viren's words.. to stay away from swamini bua...

and lo and behold.. instantly her interest in Karan's topic takes a backseat and she harshly tells off Mannu, to stay away from Swamini bua...and be a bahu and not a jasoos... If she is an elder sister. she can as well explain Mannu in a relaxed way..but aisa kaisa karegi.. di hain na.. no, maa hain na.. Maa doesn't try to find out the whole truth .. Maa doesn't believe her kid.. she just tells off coarsely 'she doesn't explain to Maanvi that Virenji does not want Maanvi or herself to get into SB's issues.. there is utterly NO TRANSPARENCY in their relation ..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

tu hamesha meri list mein number 1 hain Mannu:

huh, really...there are more than one instance, where she proved who is number 1 for her, it is Viren ..but it is Swamini bua..more than Viren...

In today's episode, . as and when Maanvi speaks of Swamini bua.. Jeevika drifts back to Viren's words.. to stay away from swamini bua...her inquisitiveness,. her eagerness took a U-turn and she stood against Maanvi and told her off ..all because of Viren's words.. Is Maanvi number 1 for her di,..

In chachu's case, she took her husband and her in-laws side... and did not give a chance to the poor girl to explain, Here Maanvi is definitely not on top of her list...It was the choice she made to not trust the real intentions of Maanvi.. as she never cared to look at Maanvi's intentions...

After Virat and Maya's break up - she was against Virat and Maanvi's friendship.. because she was more worried and concerned about what the families think, specially swamini bua- she was thinking from their perspective and not from Maanvi's perspective.. here again, Maanvi was not at the top of her list .. she told off Mannu to stay away from Virat, never tried to understand or listen to what Maanvi has to explain... because, she might end up agreeing with Maanvi and going against her family ..which she did not want to...It was her own choice to stand against Maanvi..she stood against her husband.. because she cares more of Swamini bua and her izzat.. reminds of Kashish and Prerna.. .. in this where is the ek hazaaron mein meri wali behana.

during VirMan wedding, she ran away from her gudiya's wedding because bua was angry with her .. ohhh so you did this for bua,, tab toh Maanvi is not number 1 in your list

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

hum hamesha saath rahenge, aur hamesha kay baad bhi:

why ? why do you want to stay with her so that you can take care of her as you are concerned for her?? really ??

today, in all this she makes a revelation that it was SB who first thought about Mannu's health perspective, If you are her di/Maa .. if she is your bachchi ..why did she not think of Maanvi's health even before SB thought .. this is not Ek hazaaron mein meri behana essence. the very dream of having her sister married in the same house, came true and now she does not even think of her Mannu's health perspective until swamini bua reminds of it...Is this the essence of Ek hazaaron mein ..
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mujhe Mannu ki bahut fikr hain..,,
Ohh yeah .let's see how much fikr you have.., in today's episode.. she did not want Maanvi to be involved in SB's case.. reason is not that Maanvi might stress herself and exhaust herself..causing a physical and mental drain.. she never said "Maanu stay away . as you will be unnecessarily stressed out .. " there was no CONCERN for Mannu or her health .. .. it was a mere one sided decision, where she has to follow her husband's words..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Tu meri aatma hain... Mannu meri rago mein daudthi hai :
is it true .. is this how much you know yourself... your aatma.. aatma..keheti hain..can't she see what is in her soul ..
and please if people defend J's stand today, that she wanted to save Maanvi from any untoward trouble from their in-laws, then forget it ' if it is such a strong love for your sister over 20 years.. you will have the inner strength to stand against your family.,. your husband and support your sister.. instead of admonishing and telling her off, like a little kid..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Maanvi meri bachchi hain :

yeah technically for saving her life forgoing her unborn.. Maanvi is her bacchi..but will a mom leave and run away from her beti's wedding .. and for whom.. for swamini bua,.so here Maanvi is not number 1 in her list, proved...

Maa will always be concerned about her kids . wherever she is ..the thoughts of her kids will always be on her mind.. then why was it that Swamini bua had to remind about Maanvi's recovery and her health..why did not her maa/di remember it...

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Inder chachu's case:

Forget about ek hazaaron mein meri behana.. any sister, who loves her kid sister, would understand her, trust her, stand by her..during chachu's case..
forget about trusting her Mannu, she did not give the poor girl a chance to explain herself..
forget about standing by her Mannu.. she was the one who stood against her Mannu and asked her to get out
forget about supporting her Mannu. she was the one who walked away running, when her own Mannu came to her di to seek some support, to believe her..to trust her.. was her di, the pillar of strength ...
If she was her mom, like di.. Mom's never are so harsh on the kids ..for a simple issue.. she realized her mistake only after Inder chachu tells her... until then she was hurt for telling off Mannu..but she never tried to know why Mannu did what she did in that situation
If she is bhagwan ' she should know the intentions in Mannu's heart.. without any explanations
If you believe your sister is 1 in a million ..you will side her and protect her against the whole world.. couldn't she stand against her own husband and his family .. people find the inner strength to protect the loved ones because you trust them implicitly ,. here she did not trust neither did she support her nor did she gain the inner strength to stand against her newly found in-laws

All she cares is about her husband and his family - aakhir SPA mein favorite bahu jo jeethna hain na

Ek Hazaaron mein meri behana hain - really huh, except for the abortion and BMT track.. I do not see the essence of EK Hazaaron mein type feeling .. where they claim to love each other beyond anything '

love is not about HUGS and KISSES and tears and giggles... love is all about the implicit trust, understanding the unsaid words..standing by each other in times of dire.. protecting each other in dire..caring and being concerned for each other..

In all this she stood as a true sister, only one other time, other than BMT, she stood by Maanvi's side , making the family agree to Virat and Maanvi's marriage ' I applaud that. but she could as well do the same during chachu's case and even now with respect to SB ..

Overall the creatives tried to create more and more drama..by giving up on the basic things.. Why is it that should scold, or tell off Mannu .. just because she is elder .. why couldn't she sit and try to talk or explain by giving proper reasoning .. she did not tell, for once that Virenji did not want them to inquire further into SB's past.. where is the TRANSPARENCY between them.. ?? Is this the unconditional LOVE between two sisters without TRANSPARENCY and TRUST andUNDERSTANDING ?? ***rolling my eyes**


p.s: well do I need to care for sense or pans today.. . because it is all about Munni badnaam hui😛...highlighted in blue not in pink for obvious reasons😛
Edited by munnihyderabad - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

8.2k

Users

22

Likes

273

Frequent Posters

Shrav123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
UNRes--

awesome post di... 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 ...agree with each and every word of yours... 🤗 🤗 🤗

"main kisi ki bhi daant sun sakti hoon lekin jeevika di ki nai"

"kaisi neend ayegi virat,didi ne bhi mujhe daand diya,unhe bhi meri baat paar yakin nai hain"

"yayy ham ab hamesha ek hi ghar mein ek saath reh sakte hain"

"main di ke liye kuch bhi kar sakti hoon"

above are the few lines used by maanvi ...each and every dialogue tells us how much she loves her di..and her love is NOT limited to words,she did implement them... for example,when di asked her not to speak to virat,she blindly followed it...she was like "hamara saath yehi tak tha virat,iske baad bhi agar main tumse baat karti tho di ko bura lag jayega"

this shows the love she has for di..how much she respects her and all but on the other side,J she says dialogues like this--

"koi mere ghar walo ko pereshan kare..mere ghar mein mayoosi failaye,yeh main kabhi nai bardash karungi...aur plzzz kabhi is ghar mein wapas mat aana"

"jab dekho tumhara dimag swamini bua ke piche hi pada rahtha hain..koi album mil gaya tho tumhe wo album mein wo adhmi kaun wo janna hain..unka rishta janna hain..ab agar karan ke paas bua ki photo mili tho fizul ki soch chalu"

i reallly wonder how many times maanvi talked about bua in front of J...only twice till now,...

"aur tu pata nai unke baare mein kya anap shanap kahaniya bana rahi hain"

"chod yeh sab fizul ki baate aur hame chain se jine de"


maanvi is not making anyone's life mushkil..is she munni di???? *scratching ma head*..

leave that,where did her ek hazaro meri behna wala go in mumbai...as soon as she gets a call from viren she leaves the place (near the door) and goes away..and in hrishikesh,J goes away because her huby is suffering from COLD...is cold more serious than cancer??

where there is unconditional love.. wouldn't you care to give an opportunity to your sister to explain herself.. don't you want to believe in her words.. don't you see the truth in her eyes. don't you see through the intentions in her heart ..

even i want to know the answers of the above questions di...maanvi was literally begging J to listen to her ONCE but what did jeevika do..she gave a class on "adarsh bahu"..first of all is J adarsh bahu??i dont think she is...she herself ran away from her dewars marriage and now??*where did her knowledge about this bahu thing go that time*.???if she was a ek hazaro mein behna ,would she run away??


*omg this became a very long reply... *😲 😆 🤣
Edited by shrav_virman - 12 years ago
..Gowri.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Karan Singh Shekawat:
Dii, i perfectly agree with your take here.. Manvi tries to tell evrything to her sister, she listens to it at the first second, thinks of her husband's words at the next second,& scolds her behna at the third second?? LOL, the CV's are really portraying J to be a poor conphused soul! Her emotions & priorities always gets so mixed up..

tu hamesha meri list mein number 1 hain Mannu:
The one thing which leaves me wondering is, what are J's priorities? Viren, SB, Khandaan Izzat seems to be the competitiors..I really see her taking a lot of interest in Swamini Buaji these days.. May be bcos she welcomed her back from her runaway escapade with hugs?😆 !!! One thing's sure, Maanvi is nowhere to be seen!

hum hamesha saath rahenge, aur hamesha kay baad bhi:
So that the badi behen can always use her power to insult her in front of the elders in the house??Dear CV's pls dont use such meaningful dialogues, if u cant stay true to it everytime!

Tu meri aatma hain... Mannu meri rago mein daudthi hai :
LOL, y are these CV's hell bent on making us laugh again & again at their inconsistency? Someone runs away & creates a scene at their own Aatma's marriage to satisfy her guilty conscience? Wait a min, Guilty for saving her own aatma's life?? Instead of being proud of sustaining her own life & blood, she chose punishment??LOL, i forgot, she's no mortal!

The elder sister can definitly scold the younger one, BUT, for such silly & pathetic reasons? Did the motherly feeling really come to fore yesterday? I doubt! No mother prioritises Khandaan & buaji before the kid!

All relations in the world has its own beauty, its own charm..Here, the sisters are supposed to be mad for each other, causing explosions all around with their love.. At least that was the original theme.. One's still the same.. She considers dii before evrything.., But the elder one is concerned abt all other matters in the world & less of the sister! Where are explosions?? LOL, In our minds!😆!

The problem lies in the execution, Initial portrayal..Had J been shown less of bhagwan, we would definitly have not minded cos Human Flaws are always pardoned.,But wen God errs.. Questions arises for sure!



PS : Dii, Sorry no one liners this time! I was venting out! CLAPS TO YOU for this absolutely humane & perfect post!👏👏👏
Edited by ..Gowri.. - 12 years ago
sreshta90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
chodo yaar.. one day they show something touchy nd the other day they show some other stuff wich is not at all related to previous epi.. nd at last it comes in jeevika's favour saying adharsh bahu..
ananyakai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
unres
u said it all👏
totally agree wid u!
ek hazaroon mein behena huh..
runnig away n ruing d best day of ur sis...
shouting n misundestanding her always..
caring for swamnin bua more..
she wants to b d best vadhera bahu n is just after dat..
soory to say but after inderchachu case i never like d badi behenaa
like u said she didnt wanted virman to becum one coz she cared more abt swamini n her anger den her sis happiness
bottom line is jeevika just wants to be good in d eyes of swamini n for dat she can go to ny extent
if dat mean ek hazaroon mein behen den i m so thankful dat i have a normal sis n not a mahan sis

Edited by viratmanvi - 12 years ago
js1234 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Hey Munniji
I have always always felt that despite them going on and on about EHMMBH - J's stance has always been her inlaws first than Maanvi. Maanvi actions has always been carried from heart without any malice - whether its for her di or her di's sasuralwale. I have mentioned this before as well that J's character is not very mature at all (you have highlighted number of things already) - dont forget mumbai scenario where M had to undergone some procedure and then gets kicked out so Viren and J could have some romantic time together (afterall it was their second honeymoon). They obviously didnt go there for M's cancer treatment!!! Even in hospital where they have gone to discuss further treatment - she was kuchikooing with her virenji! (really!!)
I am not blaming characters here at all but CV's. There has never been any consistencies in what they show - or may be our expectations are too high! We all know that M's wedding was a total disaster - especially from J's perspective.
Everyone has been saying that J's inner strength will come out during cancer track but big NO. Even during BMT considering courtroom drama - why could she not stand up to family and say this is what i am going to do - No one has right on her and her child apart from her husband.
BTW - loved your OS on karwachoth re VIRMAN - i would have really liked this to be have shown instead of Virat saying i cant go hungry (REALLY - Virat!!!) i only watched first 10 mins yesterday.
sonot sure what happened afterwards. why do CV's always spoil things - why cant they show relationships as it should be and keep to all the characters strength
Apologies for the long rant but i have been so frustrated with this show for a while now!!
madhu0702 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
What a post ! Munni di, you must have surely ruffled a few feathers here with your post 😉 😆

Anyway logically I should not comment here since its a behena post lol but then I decided to drop in to say that this is the main reason the behena relationship never appealed to me .

In the quest of establishing that one in a million sister concept(read BMT and abortion) they failed miserably to establish the basic essence of a sisterly relationship. All started when Jeevika throw Maanvi out of her house and that is when the behena relationship lost all my respect and nothing could redeem Jeevika. I mean, just to create some drama, they totally killed the concept then and there. Even the Jeevika supporting Virat-Maanvi relationship dint make sense to me. It was rather irritating to see her shed tears all the time. I mean, she is no different from the typical SP bahu. Why cant they show for once, Jeevika taking a strong stance for Maanvi without having any dilemma or thinking about her in-laws? Even in accepting Virat-Maanvi relationship, she took her own sweet time so much so that I dint even get the point that Jeevika is the one who made Vadheras accept VirMan relationship !


I cannot say about yesterday's episode because have nt watched it yet. I have told this many a times. This show is not the same anymore for all the jodis and fan groups. I can see the show going down the drain in terms of everything. I dunno about others but nothing interests me these days. I have stopped hoping and given up. Just watching for the sake of it !

Shrav123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: madhu0702

What a post ! Munni di, you must have surely ruffled a few feathers here with your post 😉 😆



🤣 🤣 🤣
-SweetGirl- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Like seriously CLAPS for this post 👏 ! You penned everything down That too so with point why some people including me CANT think Jeevika Ek hazaro me wali Behna & bear her mahanta act & than same stupid song My sister is my priority without any respect to the words.

Lets keep BMT topic aise Well said.

Talking about last night her Daant to M : There are two people with Whom Maanvi is more concerned are Virat & her Di.She tried to tell of & asked to seek of support from Both.In last episode we see Both dint seem supporting her out.

BUT I say Virat once at least tried to believe her.He went in store room with her.Her bad luck.She could not prove anything to her man.Even in Hotel.He run out here & there to ask for Photo until he seemed that lady's face clearly saying there was nothing.Then he asked M to stop.But for a once he went ahead on his will.

Now comes on DI.What Di did.In just second after hearing she asked her to SHUT up & be BAHU.That too taunting her like Bua loves you & what are you doing ? I say Mrs.Viren Vadera If Bua loves Maanvi so whats yr kind view on Maanvi's feeling toward Bua.Considering a fact you call her yr Dil ,Dadkan & AATMA.You must be aware what Maanvi thinking over all these .Any thing person can make out M has nothing to do with any damn thing rather her newly started married life could mess up But just bcuz She found that plesant smile on SB's face on those pic Which she feels missed now & wanna bring back .She her self gone through term oil & pain to hold back some truth Thus she want Bua to take it out feel relax & hv better life.But unfortunately Mannu's Di in spite of calling her AATMA dunno what must her aatma thinking.LOL/And Please in yr so called act to be great Bahu respective best wife who just blindly obey yr Hubby's word.dont expect M too behave so.That girl has her own will & stand.She will prove her point & I m sure that day you would jump on taking credit I m SORRY par tu meri Mannu hai.Kya pyaar hai sach me.


And with all these flaws Still Jeevika is supposed to be called EHMMBH I so badly want Creatives to show even M prioritizing her married life ,Her Man & in laws over her DI's so called word.What DI did after marriage many a times.and people justified called a married woman has so man ythings to looked forward.So same would go with M.If Its forgotten with one sister to be said EHMMBH let it get off from other;s mind to whos MAD behind her Di's obsession & would be ever after ( Thanks to CVs keeping her like that so they can prove their point to show One GREAT lord & other Devoted human only)
nobo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
well wont go in Past analysis...m still to go through all of past episodes...

But Munni, as for karan Shekhawat part..yeah she was a bit harsh...but she have every right. & how can we conclude so soon that that outburst was really in concern of Swamini bua😕
I mean she was worried other day that what if Karan harms her family..& then Manvi suddenly says that Karan was friendly with them in Mumbai, relates her with Swamini & tries to get involved...So for me ..it was out of concern ( jus my pov)

Its natural only...& even Virat said ( in front of jeevika ) that Manvi was getting too worked up for this . It added to her worries

& yaar if time demands she can indeed stnad up against her family for maanvi😳
As for manvi being No1, I possess entirely diff view points here which wont help in discussion here😆

& oh yeah Swamz was looking pure beauty in that pic 🤣
Edited by nobo - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".