is esha blame james

i watch that episode of farangi terka n i feel like esha feels james responsiable for her injury,when esha n salman call on stage they didnt say it once that james come here ,n james was crying in hawa mehal ,after his performence with salman he said esha im sorry his voice was shaky is about to cry but salman n esha both didnt say a single word only maneesh say it james dont worry,whats that ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, judges nay bhi koeeconsolation nahi kia with james?????????????kia really james responsiable,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, bura sa laga after allwo mehman hai n accidents hojatay hain

Yes even I noticed that!!!
Isha not a single time said its just accident or not even salman! Infact she was giving emotionl speech of her passion for dance(which is true) & that guy(foreigner guest) was looking terribly guilty with every word of hers & she just ignored him on stage, it looked like she was resentful of James!!! Worse is that judges looked v cold in this all, not a single word of niceness!!! Every1 understood what isha was going thru but we didnt set good example of indians as warm-hearted ppl!!! Its sad that it happened like tht but lil generoity would have made him feel better!! V proud of Manish the super host to have uttered those words of comfort to james instead of making him feel blamed!!

Originally posted by: DiviNitya

Yes even I noticed that!!!
Isha not a single time said its just accident or not even salman! Infact she was giving emotionl speech of her passion for dance(which is true) & that guy(foreigner guest) was looking terribly guilty with every word of hers & she just ignored him on stage, it looked like she was resentful of James!!! Worse is that judges looked v cold in this all, not a single word of niceness!!! Every1 understood what isha was going thru but we didnt set good example of indians as warm-hearted ppl!!! Its sad that it happened like tht but lil generoity would have made him feel better!! V proud of Manish the super host to have uttered those words of comfort to james instead of making him feel blamed!!

Lines in blue ...agreed completely.

Originally posted by: Mrinmayee

</div>

<div>

Lines in blue ...agreed completely.

Manish deserves appreciation for this.

Yes That was the only saving grace in that whole segment ironically!!!!
If we cutoff Manish's sentence n see that would have given impression of bad sportmanship!!
He wrapped it up v nicely by saying like that breaking the ice in the room!!!
Im suprised Isha could b that cold shoulder but understand her pain too, thats ok!!

I also felt the same. Isha seemed so full of herself in that segment and lets not forget when only isha and salman were there, salman got hurt. did she blame herself for salman's injury? I felt so sorry for James. he looked like such a kind hearted guy. Isha dint even give him a smile when he was talking to her. Bless James and Bless Manish. Dont worry James, all the audience knows it wasnt your fault and you had no reason what-so-ever to feel guilty for.

So easy to point finger at someone calling them cold and what not. Only the person in her shoes would understand what she's going through. She is not only going through physical but there is mental pain involved here as well. No one knows what happened and how she fell, what if it was Jaymes fault, just what if. Imagine coming this far in the competition and something like it happens, being a human it's natural to have grudge for someone who might have been responsible for her condition. And it seems her injury is quite severe and sometimes such injury can heal but you might not be able to use your limb like before, I am saying this being a med student and have seen such conditions. Secondly, we don't know how Isha and Salman reacted behind the stage. If it was an accident, I am sure she would let it go, but for the time being, it can be difficult for anyone be it you, me or her. But such logic sometime can't be seen beyond the hatred that certain people on this forum has for her. If you can't say anything good about her condition or empathize with her, at least don't pour bitter words left right and center.

Simply my 2 cents, rest up to you all.

Originally posted by: khamosshhh

Haven't yet watched the epi so don't know how evryon1 behaved and I prefer to come to my own conclusion than believing in heresay. Anyways der r just 2 points tht I want to make.

Firstly, if everyone, including the judges r cold towards James, then Isha can be hardly blamed, as afterall she is injured and it is her loss the most and hence her reaction a very human one.

Secondly, if James is feeling guilty, then obviously he too is feeling responsible and blaming himself. He too must hv found out tht Isha was the best and was a potential winner and hence all reactions r totally understandable.

Anyways if Isha would hv been warm towards him, some ppl would hv accused her of being fake and faking her injury. 😉

I said the exact same thing 😃

@underlined: With some people, you can't win either way. It's like people will find any reason just to hate someone. It's hard to knock sense into someone who is either an extreme fan or an extreme hater. Both are maha dangerous.