||Jeevika-Manvi AT#12||'Manvi Mera Dil Hai'

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

CREDIT: -Priya-

~*Jeevika & Manvi*~

The soul, the essence, the heartbeat...the everything of 'Ek Hazaron Mein Meri Behna Hai'. We can discuss, analyse and simply talk about the magic they create on-screen.

Right now the thread will look extremely plain but I'll be working on it to make it look somewhat decent.

I don't believe in too many rules but please take the below in to consideration

    No spamming No personal chit-chat
  • Stick to the Behnas. No harm in bringing the other characters in but the main focus should be the sisters only.

JOIN IN :) If you want to be part of the memberlist you can 'LIKE' this post OR PM me. If you do not see your name there then please PM right away.




Memberlist


1)*Reemz*
2)saraaa.
3)_innocent_
4)..Omniscient..
5)canuck-umz
6)ifyaa
7)-Pj-
8)jasminedayal
9)Eyes-Wide-Shut
10)Aisho.
11)shadowstreet
12)priya1804
13)jessiekarthik
14)poojaroy1985
15)anumber1
16)Amii90
17)AyushiSinghania
18)..-Marj-..
19)*Eva*
20)Fallen Star
21)Meepha
22)aaliya25
23)wizzgirl
24)riya01maddy
25) Kitnimohabbat
26) Uniquebluerose
27)-Arushi_kajen-
28) cutykoo27
29) TheMelody
30) xMidnightStarsx
31) Nainanino
32) _Aanchal_
33) mushiroxx
34) Shreya_94
35) isha.raj_98
36) xoanyaxo
37) viratmanvi
38) -Noorii-
39) medhahps
40) ahaanfan
41) Aussie_Girl
42) -Jennifer-
43) Sameerah1992
44)EHMMBH-lover
45) riddha
46) ana.khan
47) Virman_lover
48) Yuvika_15
49) luv_mannu
50) Kiara_angel
51) Preeti_Shadia
52) soni595
53) Amu.PunjabiKuri
54) OnlyHope
55) Cutykoo27
56) Hazel-eye
57) .ayesha.
58) Eowyn
59)Dina98210
60)arohi16
61)DaMiniii
62)VampireAleena
63)Daminipatel12
64)Neeshoe
65) littles12
66)Evanescent
67) solitude
68) ViRaLi13
69) CaptainREX
70) kajal18
71) VirmanArhi4ever
72) ChocoLavaish
73) neenzz
74) ayeshapasta
75) TerenceKiToli12
76) MKMJohal
77) isha01
78) avi_k_
79)Shona_Mayur
80) luvmannu
81)naina-syed
82) ---Shweta---
83)Crazy4Virmaan
84)shaz2009
85) neetusidhu
86) -SaruuKaSh-
87) SweetAddiction
88) DaMiniii
89) cutyvirman
90)LoveWillPrevail
91) NikiBh8
92) harshiii
93) Such
94) Farikina
95) gulati_simar
96) .Kryptonite.
97) HarshadAnupriya
98) sweetydee
99) sayara
100) simar_VirMan
101) Aisha202
102) cherry...
103) -Veena-
104) pinky0902
105) -Jafrina-
106) stillunwritten
107) indian10
108) ita_04
109) munnihyderabad
110) jesss.
111) happygolucky
112) Maangeet4ever
113) -Subbiha-
114) Veronica1504
115) Neha.K
116) Rabz_14
117) -tehreem-
118) HinaMahekian
119) RockStarHuda
120) akrititaurus
121) virMan_forever
122) Shine123
123)Sari2
124)nobo
125)sarah_kelly
126)riddha
127)nrithyao
128)Vaarya53
129)shruthigowda
130)Pooja_Chs
131)UrshP
132)*mittu*
133)*Shifali*
134)-EndlessSmile-
135)chaitu-monaya
136)TRULYNANDINI
137)meg_met
138)hnisha
139)reshamc
140)screen22
141)sabeeha
142)veems
143)subhakmhl
144)nabiha
145)shamzi20
146)lovelyvirman
147)Cutecj
148)lits_virman
149)RICOPUNK101
150)Nandita1990
151)virmaan84
152)LoveWillPrevail
153)simran_virman
154)..Amira..
155)MJHTMonayaSajan
156)-Pankhuri-
157)-Jen-
158)-NightDreamer-
159)loveleen12
160)J.LO
161)lmfao1
162)Bluerobin
163)stuti_29
164) Nimishrr
165) sudipta1988
166) virmaandvd
167) nupsdips
168) ali_281
169) adenah
170) shrav_virman
171) preetivr
172) Preeti_KPS
173) Abhi911
174) gia.khan
175) anitamalik
176) Mehak_Luvs_Rani
177) akku8910
178) js1234
179) a2zahid
180) jeemanrocks
181) ammyanshu
182)nabiha
183) keertu
184) ZAHARA.
185) prettyR3
186) atthi
187) sakshi_aditi
188) GiNa_kavya
189) fimbles
190) dailysoaplove10
191) fari.samed
192) SM28
193) xoxsweetestgal
194) Labyrinth89
195) riastar
196) niCeline
197) Sunitha_Swayam
198) Gabriella
199) ...Jes...
200) Sruthi_Virmanli
201) voltage
202) MaaNeetLuv
203) aysha1989
204) Saraa.7
205) Mariaa395
206) ...Poojie...





Edited by *Reemz* - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

71.7k

Users

36

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

Neha.K. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
yeahhh 12 th AT... Congrats everyone..mwaaah.



maine kabhi apne dil ko nahin dekha hai lekin jab main manvi ko dekhti hun toh mujhe samajh mein aata hai ki dil bhi aisa hi hota hoga..
manvi mera dil hai..jiski dhadkan se iss jeevika ka jeevan hai


*Eva* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Congrats girls!!!! 🤗 Keep it going...you guys are the coolest bunch EVER 😎 Hope number 13 will be here ASAP 😃
EHMMBH-lover thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
New AT ki badhai behnas! 🤗

Hey Eva! Cakes!! Remember? 😈
Neha.K. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
neeni time..
ve hectic day tomorrow:(... so bye bye for now..
JeeMan dreams to me☺️
ciao, cya all tom.

@my dil ka tukda my entertainment channel-----------❤️ will reply to ur pms tom🤗
Edited by Neha.K. - 13 years ago
-Pj- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sabeeha



<font color="#ff0066">This was actually part of the GCSE RE course, so I'm quite surprised if normal schools don't do it :S</font>

<font color="#ff0066">Lmao, it goes with having a vast population of chavs living off of dole money because their life revolves around the Job centre and the local off license. What a society, makes me proud to be English :) </font>



GCSE RE? I did a short course in Re as that's what my school did, we didn't cover that at all. I think the AS did when they did philosophy and theology. Wish they did it at normal GCSE and even in KS3, but then RE doesn't have a curriculum it had to follow. But it is compulsory to teach in schools do it can depend on each
boroughs or county's to decide what they wish to teach in RE.

Haha well Chavs living off the dole and finding the nearest off licence is never going to change.
munnihyderabad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Hello everyone...🤗

new AT 🥳 yipee



delete1234 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -Pj-


My 6th Form Philosophy, Theology and Ethics course hasn't done anything about abortion yet :L Too bust focusing on the humanist view of life as opposed to the Christian view

I have no idea how you've managed to teach in a Christian school; they just blow my mind.

:L Chavs, speaking of which, it seems there is a little congregation of 12-year-old charvers having a great time at the end of my street.

I wonder how much ethics is taught in India, seems the writers never took the course, judging by the way they've treated the cancer in the show. Or any of the medical aspects; prime example being the constant hide and seek games with the cancer initially. Which doctor would actually withhold telling a patient they have a life threatening illness on the whim of a relative?
Seems no ones ever told these guys that you can have drama AND logic working together rather than be at odds.

-Pj- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Your still in 6th form. Good luck for next year and hope your AS went well. Oh I didn't doPhilosophy, Theology and Ethics but I wish I did I would have really enjoyed that.

I went to a Catholic university so many of the schools I taught it during school experiences where in Catholic schools. I was teaching RE, in a year six class- gosh that was hard but I learnt more than the children I was teaching. Honestly I really enjoyed the Catholic schools.

Luckily for me there are no Chavs currently on my street, but they come during the day.

I know this subject is sensitivity all around the world for ethics and religion but one should think about that before, they tease the possibility. The way in which they have handled cancer is disgraceful. If I didn't like Jeevika and Maanvi so much, I would have stopped watching completely when they began this mockery.
*Eva* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sabeeha


:L I'm getting flashbacks of countless posts now. Honestly, I can not begin to describe the sheer amount of times people have highlighted just how great the show *could* have been, had they focused on the cancer like they should of. It's just plain mockery right now, especially the 'this is the ONLY treatment in the WORLD' that could save Mannu. Bad direction, bad writing, bad dialogue, all it adds up to is a half baked pie of a show.

The sometimes dragging, sometimes zooming - giving me a headache :P The whole cancer track - the one single main track of the entire show seems like it's already over when it's just begun, and I blame that on CVs for having such a predictable plot. They really can't get their pacing right at all; it was great to see Manvi and Jeevika finding out about the severity of the cancer quickly, but then the whole Doctor's meeting was skimmed over too quickly.

But anyway, the ethics behind it all is quite fascinating. I think it all depends on, in regards to abortion, on where you personally believe life begins. The anti-abortionists would say conception, the liberals would say when the heart starts beating (40 days isn't it?) and then the pro-choice would say at birth. It's murky waters which can be debated over aeons.

Abortions were all part of my Ethics course which I did when I was fifteen, and to get a class full of fifteen year old boys and girls to shut up, pay attention, and visibly be shaken by what they learn, it takes something big. I remember watching a vid about the suction-aspiration abortion method, and the way that they just pull off the limbs of the foetus, it's horrible to think about. Again, this revolves around whether or not the foetus actually feels pain. The partial-birth one, some kid in my class ended up researching it and mentioning it, we were horrified. Jamming scissors into the base of the neck? It makes you shudder.

:L Controversy.



I honestly couldn't agree more. It's very unfortunate actually. The CVs had evidently planned Manvi's cancer from the very beginning of the show, so you would think that they'd have the time to do plenty of research to get them educated on the issue. The problem with the CVs is that they don't know who and what to prioritize. I'm not going to divulge into the discussion of other fangroups, but being ignorant of the main conflict of the show for the sake of fan requests? Why? My concern is that the CVs can't execute medically factual writing and consistency. The ONLY TREATMENT in the world remark was a total facepalm 😳 Erm, what ever happened to stem cell transportation and immunotherapy? There are quite a few targeted therapies, hormonal therapies and angiogenesis inhibitors around. The 99% success rate talk was a joke. Basically, what the doctor said was that if the cancer patient has a sibling who is willing to donate his/her bone marrow, the patient is guaranteed survival. For real? Why are the writers making it sound so easy? Most of the time, the only dialogue I genuinely enjoy comes from the sisters; the dialogue that tries to suffice Manvi's condition has no logic whatsoever. As for the dragging, oh brother! Dr. Manan revealed the cancer to Beeji in February; it's almost September and we've just reached the BEGINNING of the pivotal point. The pacing has been atrocious (excuse my harshness), to say the least. The cancer was shoved under the carpet during the Maya track, Virat's realization, after Mumbai (the Mumbai track itself was a waste) and then the 7 day track. Together, all of that accumulates to at least 3 months. The constant inconsistencies of this show don't help either. I predicted the BMT track as well, but right now, I'm just intrigued to how everything will play out. I fear for medical science though. The bias in me blatantly knows that I watch for the sisters, but the writing is very crucial; there's no way I can appreciate the show in its entirety if the writing is so shabby. I was disappointed with the build-up to the revelation of the reports to Jeevika along with the revelation itself sadly. It really bothers me how the cancer is fizzled out and then emphasized upon, for the sake of the writers' conveniences.

I won't divulge into the ethics of the abortion issue as we'll be here for hours, but I wholeheartedly agree. More than anything, it's a personal belief (which may be based on religion, science and poltics). I really wish some people could keep personal bias aside for this issue because agreeing/disagreeing about Jeevika's decision on the basis of Jeevika/Manvi/Viren/Virat being your favourite character/jodi/actor/actress wouldn't be ethical IMO.

15?! Wow! That must have been a lot of information to digest at such a tender age! I took an ethics (mainly based around medicine) course during my first year of university followed by a few oncology courses. Personally, I got exposed to many viewpoints, and I was definitely seeing the world from different pairs of eyes. Oh goodness, it's such a harsh thing to think about right? Fetuses feeling pain is another issue with contrasting perspectives. There's no confirmed answer, but most studies are saying that they can feel pain after certain growth. The amount of growth needed is debated on frequently though.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".