Reason to Hope???...Or Not??? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.1k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

heyitsrupy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: lighthouse

Agreed KS is losing its luster but keeping J&B apart cannot be the only choice for keeping the business profitable....

J&B campers and yours truly can never get tired of seeing J&B together in bliss albeit fighting the common enemy whatever it is... If the creatives are thinking(if they are awake at all) that another June 19th will be boring and the only way to keep the fans on the edge is to follow oft beaten path they are plain wrong...

LH, that is just so true...Somehow Indian tv has this strange fixation with 'eternally apart due to circumstances, perpetually pining for each other couples'...There is so much they can do with a love story...And to see Jai and Bani together and focussing on the maturing of their relationship can be really exciting...To show their mutual adjustments, their daily troubles, their differences and love...In J and B, Ekta has two such amazing characters that she can keep the viewers hooked for quite some time to come...

U know a point in light is Saath Phere...I have never followed the serial very closely, but from what I have seen from trailers and stuff, the two protagonists have been very much together for some time to come, and fighting all odds together...And yeah....SP is even more popular in terms of ratings than KS...

But then somthing on these lines requires a serious coming of age of K-serials...something I am beginning to get skeptical about happening really soon..

love

Rupy

heyitsrupy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#12
😭

Originally posted by: srkcc

Hi all

Is this a character from another serial that Kekta masacared???

Were there a lot of people who were as vocal about how they felt about the storyline of that serial as everybody at IF is about KS.

I am just hoping that Balaji know how their audience feels and they DO NOT disapoint.

I am also hoping that the creative's wife who did not send luch for her husband when JW was killed off for a day is not happy with the current state of affairs and makes a few more such threats!!!😉

Yeah...Sujal was and continues to be a hugely popular character of Kahin to Hoga...One of the most brilliantly conceived characters...He stood out as the epitome of steadfast, passionate and irrevoceable love for one woman Kashish...With loads of deliciious shades and complexity to his personality...It was played to perfection by Rajeev Khandelwal till sometime last year, but after he quit the show, the character was massacred...so much so that its unrecognisable today!!!...

KTH was one of the most popular shows of the time...And Rajeev/Sujal had/has a crazed fan following, the likes rarely seen for any male protagonist in an Ekta serial...But despite the public support and outcry, especially after rajeev left, there were horrendous changes in the storyline...And yes...Sujal and Kashish were kept apart for a greater part of year and a half...and the viewers were kept on tenterhooks all the while😭...

Anyhow, the point is not to discuss KTH here, and yeah, the above happen to be solely my personal views...so I am sorry if it upsets ny1...but the fact that such twists do happen in K-soaps....so its quite possible the J-B may be kept apart for eternity.......But then lets cling onto hope....There's nt much else we can do, except perhaps stop seeing the serial if the torture gets too much to take...

love

Rupy

heyitsrupy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

Hi Rupy,

Great analysis, as always!! 👏 I loved the way you put forth all the positive and negative points..u r right, the scale is leaning towards the negative as per the happenings in the recent past..maybe thats just what Ekta wanted us to think! while in reality she'll surprise us yet again!! like RK said so in one of his interviews -- "expect the unexpected" (well its been quoted by pmtwist quite a lot of times on this forum now 😆 )

So while most of you are angry and upset and disappointed and completely given up hopes on KS, I'm still clinging on to a little bit of optimism..hope Ekta and the creatives don't let me down this time!!

Dhruvie, thats what I am trying to bank on too...the unexpected....Another thing, I am surprised at the pains they are still taking to keep Pia's character in the clear....I mean as of now, they are trying really hard to show that she doesnt have any intentions with respect to Jai...The way they justified her going to Walia mansion (coz she couldnt go anywhere else)....or the way she was disgusted when Pushkar questioned her about working with Jai...That only means they dont want to turn her point blank negative as of now....So may be its what you say....a red herring!!!...So lets just keep hanging on😊...

thanks so much for ur feedback....always wait for it...😳

love

Rupy

anushka_5 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: heyitsrupy

Ekta serials have often proudly claimed credit for venturing into uncharted territories...She has vouched for her 'sensitive' handling of issues like rape, mercy-killing and the like...So whats next on her social agenda???...A 'sensitive' portrayal of wife-swapping???....A new take on open marriages???....Is that whats in the offing in KS now???...A Jai-Pia angle, followed by a Bani-Pushkar track???

I have been loath to write a premature obituary for KS over the past few weeks...Despite the slowdown in the story...the mounting bloopers....The growing complexity of the tracks...the contradictory stances of the characters....the ominous signs....I have persevered in hoping...for the best. I must admit today though that that hope is wavering really low today😭...The clouds have darkened too much.......

There are just two reasons which are ready to keep my optimism afloat...albeit precariously...

The first is Jai....and his character as it has shaped up till now....Its simple...I just trust him...to take care of himself...and his life...period!...It doesnt really matter if Pia is in his house...Roshni was in a room with him remember???...In fact on the same bed...AND he was drunk...Yet he stood rock-steady.

Even today, I was feeling sorry for him...The poor guy was trudging up and down the stairs in the middle of the night...Trying to deal with a hysterical couple ....Witness to the most unsavoury and ungainly fight...I loved the dignified way with which he removed himself from the scene when the confrontation began to centre around him...And the expression on his face when Pia was praising him said loads...It wasnt triumph....it wasnt disgust...it was just supreme indifference...Even if Bani was not in the picture, Pia's constant ping-pong attitude seems to have finally ensured that the scales have fallen out of his eyes as far as she is concerned...for eternity.

In fact for his part, Jai was behaving like a perfect brother-in-law and gentleman today....It was in keeping with hs character to stop Pushkar from hitting Pia in front of him...It would have been unacceptable if he had stood by and watched it all...If Pia chooses to misunderstand these vibes, then again...I trust him to handle it...and handle it well!!!...I doubt if her being Bani's sister or any other reason will make him be nice then.

The other reason for a degree of optimism is the KS track record till now...Till now, this serial has always surprised us...At every juncture...The expected, good or bad, has hardly ever happened in the way we thought it would...J-B marriage...their consummation at a time when their relationship was stilll largely undefined....Pia's abrupt arrival on the morning after...Bani's hug to Jai before the bomb blast...Jai's death...We have always been kept on the edge...So at a time when things seem so bleak, and inevitably set in a predictably unwanted direction...It might just turn out to be the opposite...Jai and Bani may just decide to join hands to seek a reconciliation between the two Ps...And in the process, breach their own gulf.

Yet, the reasons for pessimism seems equally valid...😭....Firstly, the way the track has been built up gradually....Its not been a sudden twist in the serial...The pieces have been set up gradually beginning with Pia's joining the office, to Pushkar's name being written on Bani's hospital form, to the growing vibes between Pia and Jai, to the present...It all points to the fact that the track is not going to be a short-term scenario..Rather things may just be taken to the brink...

Also, I know many people are arguing that Ekta would never separate J-B as that is the USP...But then the converse is also true...J-B are the selling point...so a quick reconciliation b/w the two would be bad business...Better to keep them apart for as long as possible and keep the fans on the edge...They may not necessarily marry other ppl...But then they may still be away from each other and keep pining...!!!

And lastly, well, the going has been too good till now... I mean its been 6 months....We have had a brilliant story line...Even better characters which have remained well-etched out and consistent...In Jai and Bani we have had two protagonists who have been utterly different from the umpteen others we see on television all the time...How long can it last???...Did I hear Ekta loves Jai's character...Its time to get scared then...She loved Sujal too...And anyone who's ever followed KTH knows what happened there....So if our JW gets massacred by the creatives, well, why get shocked...

Sorry for being so negative...But the balance is tilting the other way...Lets see what happens next....But come what may, we still have discretion of keeping our JW alive...fantasise abt J-B in our own way...The only hope is that that may not be the only thing left for us!!!!

love

Rupy

Wow! That was beautifully written👏 Yday's episode had me at the end of my wits! 😡😕

I completely agree with you... I Trust Jai to handle any woman drooling over him, be in Pia or Roshini. He is Property Mrs Bani Walia and intends to remain for life and beyond😳 I really see no way that Jai will retrace his steps back to Pia ever... as u said her oscillating nature has surely put him off PERIOD!

I really hope Bani comes back.... and Jai has to get her back... I really want to see that man in action now. Enough of him sitting and waiting for her to get back... as a matter of fact i am watching KYPH...one of those rare occasions... And Angad has woken up from a slumber to get back his wife and his child.... and he keeps giving these cheeky grins... i want to see Jai in an aggressive mode.

🤗 is for you... u know why? Coz u summed up Sujal's character so beautifully! I bet u spend a lot of time writing that reply about Sujal. If Ekta plans to slaughter Jai... then i really hope she does it well... so that i never even dream of shifting to zee at 9! I hate to sit front of the TV at 11 now😕 Ek waqt tha jab....😭

Lots of Luv

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".