Saif or SRK in Kal Ho Na Ho?

I've watched that movie 3 times (with this being the third). The first time I saw it, I loved SRK's performance & loveddd Aman's character. I watched it the second time, and felt Rohit's character was better than that of Aman's..and NOW, after watching it the third time I feel not only do I like the character of Rohit more than that of Aman's..I think Saif performed way better than SRK in that film, and this is coming from a SRK fan. Saif was made for Kal Ho Na Ho's Rohit and I personally think he was the best part about KHNH (I'm no Saif fan by the way..)

The reason why I'm bringing this up is because I just finished watching Cocktail. & since I just saw Kal Ho Na Na a day back, I couldn't help but think of how Saif's best goofy/rom-com kinda performance was that of Rohit from Kal Ho Na Ho... Not to mention, I couldn't help but notice how Saif really has aged...and how he looked cuter back then...I'm sure it all has to do with me seeing back to back films of Saif that are nearly a decade apart. 😆

anyway, just wondering..whose performance did you guys honestly like in KHNH btwn SRK & Saif?

But I prefer Aman because he basically convinced Rohit to marry Naina. I don't think he would have fallen in love with her if Srk didn't help him notice her.

Plus, Aman is the guy that hid his love because he knew he would die. It was just so sad and sweet. This movie always makes me cry.

Saif was really cute and fun too. Esp the gay scenes with Srk & Saif was hilarious. But his love wasn't as intense as Aman's, so Aman definitely took him over in the romance part.

But in real life, if I were in Naina's place, I would also marry Rohit. He's a realistic guy, a little naive and foolish perhaps. But he's good at heart and simple. Not to mention, easy to influence which is always a plus 😆

aman was over the top at least for me.

of course. 😆

I actually am a SRK fan, but I honestly loved Saif in this film..and way more than SRK. I think his character as Rohit was far more interesting & realistic than that of Aman's which is one of the main reasons. From whatever I've seen & heard, a lot of people associate Kal Ho Na Ho with SRK or Preity..but I don't think anyone else could have played a better Rohit than Saif..so I'd say he had a lot to do with the film doing well.

and Burcidi..I think Aman's love for Naina just seemed more intense because of all the things he did for her. Rohit loved Naina too..but his way of showing it wasn't the same as that of Aman's..and I think that's just how their characters were supposed to be.I actually liked Rohit & Naina's friendship more than any other relationship w/in the movie.

They're not even in the same league as performers.

Both are very different characters, however, I loved Saif in the movie.. SRK's character was sad :( ..sad characters usually dont appeal to me.

But, both were good, acting-wise :)