Disallow previous contestants of music shows

really , it is annoying to see participants from SRGMP /VOI/ etc etc on Indian Idol 6..they already had the

IL needs a policy that any one who has competed in any television show in past 5 years in ineligible to
enroll..compete etc etc . what do you think?

Well I dont think that is fair.. Cuz singers can improve with practice.. Judges will anyways pick the fine singers.. So singers who failed in other reality shows and coming here for another chance, should not be a threat to the freshers.. If freshers are fine with their skills, nothing can stop their selection..

Auditions should be done ONLY based on talent..

You cannot... atleast of star plus show I know abt... if you participate in their singing shows... you cannot take part in any other singing contest on other channels for certain years. Its their clause.

Originally posted by: prerna4rishav

Well I dont think that is fair.. Cuz singers can improve with practice.. Judges will anyways pick the fine singers.. So singers who failed in other reality shows and coming here for another chance, should not be a threat to the freshers.. If freshers are fine with their skills, nothing can stop their selection..

Auditions should be done ONLY based on talent..

Completely agree... As sad it sounds it doesn't matter if they been on a different show before... in any industry with time there are improvements