Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
My question is about how the CVs present a scene for viewers perception. I'm discussing two instances in NBT, where i thought it was blatant cheating and not a genuine twist in the tale.

Ist Instance:
I'm sure most of us remember the Khoon Bhari Maang and Mantra scene wala episode. Towards the end of episode Megha is shown to make a decision but full detail is not revealed.

The Viewers, who don't have accept to the Internet and these Articles, would have thought that Megha is deciding in favour Mohan. So viewers would have been so excited to see megha taking the decision but then a shocker will await them, when Megha says she can't marry Mohan for some reasons.

Since we knew what is going to happen, we were head-desking for showing not only stupid but unnecessary Cliche, when she is not even going to do it in his favour.

2nd Instance:
Now last episode, the Manav-Mitika angle, the scene were shown in very mysterious, suspectable manner. Manav's dialogues over phone makes the viewers even more doubtful. "Tumhare baare me ghar pe nahi bata saktha" and few more dialogues - completely misleading ones. Why would such a thing be said to a friend seeking help? Iske ke baare mein ghar ke logon (woh bhi Vyas parivar) ko bataane kya zaroorat😕. From the article we know she is a friend seeking help. Then this dialogue is surely to mislead the viewers(who don't have access to these articles) into thinking that Manav has some affair with this girl and mohan will find the truth and stop the Shagun on time.

Just to give some excitement, they are doing these things. My question is - Is this correct? Is this a creative Strategy or cheating the viewers?

Having a suspense about the track is good. But is this correct to fool the viewers by giving misleading signals/symbolism/dialogues? Or am I even right in calling this "fooling the viewers" or cheating?

What is your opinion on these?

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

kkkap00r thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
😆Thats why such teams are called CREATIVE TEAMS... show the things that are actually not going to happen
zobia14799 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
is se zyaada twists and turns waala show maine kabhi nahin dekha!!!
it seems as if the writers themselves dont know whats gonna happen in the show and they are forced to put unwanted twists in the story... y cant they keep it simple????
crazy87 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Sunna_Deewani

My question is about how the CVs present a scene for viewers perception. I'm discussing two instances in NBT, where i thought it was blatant cheating and not a genuine twist in the tale.

Ist Instance:
I'm sure most of us remember the Khoon Bhari Maang and Mantra scene wala episode. Towards the end of episode Megha is shown to make a decision but full detail is not revealed.

The Viewers, who don't have accept to the Internet and these Articles, would have thought that Megha is deciding in favour Mohan. So viewers would have been so excited to see megha taking the decision but then a shocker will await them, when Megha says she can't marry Mohan for some reasons.

Since we knew what is going to happen, we were head-desking for showing not only stupid but unnecessary Cliche, when she is not even going to do it in his favour.

2nd Instance:
Now last episode, the Manav-Mitika angle, the scene were shown in very mysterious, suspectable manner. Manav's dialogues over phone makes the viewers even more doubtful. "Tumhare baare me ghar pe nahi bata saktha" and few more dialogues - completely misleading ones. Why would such a thing be said to a friend seeking help? Iske ke baare mein ghar ke logon (woh bhi Vyas parivar) ko bataane kya zaroorat😕. From the article we know she is a friend seeking help. Then this dialogue is surely to mislead the viewers(who don't have access to these articles) into thinking that Manav has some affair with this girl and mohan will find the truth and stop the Shagun on time.

Just to give some excitement, they are doing these things. My question is - Is this correct? Is this a creative Strategy or cheating the viewers?

Having a suspense about the track is good. But is this correct to fool the viewers by giving misleading signals/symbolism/dialogues? Or am I even right in calling this "fooling the viewers" or cheating?

What is your opinion on these?


Totally agree with you that these CV's are making fool out of us...They even don't know what to do with this Manav like character...So,they want to keep both sides open where they could turn him into a negative or positive character...After having read the article regarding it I fond that conversation on phone totally illogical...He was talking as if he was talking to her najayej bibi😆😆
sitamma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
i dont know if the article is wrong or if the phone conversation between manav and mithika is misleading.
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sitamma1

i dont know if the article is wrong or if the phone conversation between manav and mithika is misleading.


If the article is wrong, then its OK. I will accept that. But if the girl turns out to be a just a friend/patient, then thats blatant cheating.

Maybe creative writers can say the difference - if its really a strategy to keep the viewers guessing or unethical cheating by giving misleading scenes.
crazy87 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sitamma1

i dont know if the article is wrong or if the phone conversation between manav and mithika is misleading.


In one of the interview's Kunal said that Mohan ko lagta hai ke shayad Manav Megha ke liye shahi nahi hai...He emphasized on "Shayad" a lot...So,I don't think there is any thing wrong in the article the girl turning out to be his friend...And that phone conversation was just a lame gimmick of CV's to confuse us...
adoremevirgo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
well...this always hapens in every show and even in movies...dialogues and scenes r created in dubious manner and in the end many questions remain unanswered...this is part of showbiz and we hv to accept this...

and in daily soaps...it is always possible they may bring last minute changes...most times wat the articles say does not turn out to be true...
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: crazy87


In one of the interview's Kunal said that Mohan ko lagta hai ke shayad Manav Megha ke liye shahi nahi hai...He emphasized on "Shayad" a lot...So,I don't think there is any thing wrong in the article the girl turning out to be his friend...And that phone conversation was just a lame gimmick of CV's to confuse us...


Yes true. Manav being again bad like pracreep will be too repetitive and seen in million other shows.

I think this confusion will remain only between mohan and nanhi but the article said Vyas family doubts manav, which doesn't seem like happening. Its just a false hope for mohan, nanhi and the unsuspecting viewers.


Edited by Sunna_Deewani - 14 years ago
swapna82 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Lol ! Tum itni si cheez ke liye sochne lagi... 😆 😆 😆

I almost gave up any expectation from these brilliant creatives jabse papaji ne 'PRASTHAAV' rakha tha.. C'mon.. who talks abt insurance like that !!!
Maanav scene is like nothing, compared to that 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".