Had Yash not blasted Arti, Palak would have except

Palak was fine until Yash's out burst! Like seriously, they sang, dance, cut the cake the whole time your telling me you didn't realize it was Aarti? Ok maybe Yash didn't, but Palak did. So, that proves, she was ok with Aarti being Arpita. Had Yash accepted or even not accepted in private, Palak would have seen Yash happy and gave in to Aarti. I feel she mimics her father. If he is upset with Aarti so is she. Everything was wrong today, Aarti for going over her boundaries, she should have asked Yash and explained her plan to him. Yash for being so irrational in front of kids and spoiling the whole happy party, Palak for not understanding Aarti at all. Everything was wrong. The only thing I think can make Yash repent now is the fact that Aarti gets hurt. She also gets into a accident this very day but only to live. Maybe Yash might accept her worth if he is about to lose her. I know he isn't in love with her but he does care for her (the rain scene when aarti was going to get cake) I really hope Aarti runs out of there and drives her self off to somewhere...I know it won't happen but after today, I want Yash to replay what happen that last birthday, only this time he has the option to maybe change the outcome.

Yash is such a paranoid over Arpita tht little did he realise that he was spoiling his daughter Palak's happiness on her birthday!!!! Did he not see his daughter enjoying herself ???????? Why then did he do this???

i think Yash over reacted... wayyy over reacted... he could have shown his diapproval in a different more mature manner... palak had accepted Arti thats why she cut the cake... Yash's outburst made her take two steps back... not fair to Pakal or Arti

Originally posted by: maan-and-geet

i think Yash over reacted... wayyy over reacted... he could have shown his diapproval in a different more mature manner... palak had accepted Arti thats why she cut the cake... Yash's outburst made her take two steps back... not fair to Pakal or Arti

i totally agree with all of u. pity the girl palak...she was longing for motherly love and was going to settle with aarti when yash out burst his feeling, destroying the posibbilities of palak getting to know aarti more.

The whole thing was just out of wack...I mean he is so in love with his wife that he doesn't see anything and anyone beyond that...

Palak accepted arthi but her mood was spoiled by yash. Even she cut the cake without her mother.

Agree with u.yash didnt realise it will affect palaks birthday.aarti should have told him before.
It is a shock for him to see aarti took the arpita place.
He has to understand her intentions.

Palak was fine only becoz she thought she would see arpita later. She did not buy that aarti was arpita. even if Yash had not yelled, Palak would hv probably enjoyed the party and then asked for arpita. what then? Is enjoying a birthday party the ultimate happiness that aarti wanted her to give!

Originally posted by: DMKJ_VB

Palak was fine only becoz she thought she would see arpita later. She did not buy that aarti was arpita. even if Yash had not yelled, Palak would hv probably enjoyed the party and then asked for arpita. what then? Is enjoying a birthday party the ultimate happiness that aarti wanted her to give!

I disagree...because I think Palak said that if Arpita didn't come she wouldn't cut the cake. And she did. I think a major part of palak's rudeness and unhappiness is because she knows her father is unhappy. She wants Arpita back yes because she misses her mother but also because her father misses her mother. Palak repeated "sorry" to her father after is out burst like 5 times...why? Why is she sorry? That is what Yash needs to understand that his hurt is hurting his daughters. Payal is young and really never knew her mom,hence she is happy with Aarti's love, but Palak stops her. Same with Palak, she won't accept Aarti until her father accepts her 100%