Disabled and Differently Abled

-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
So while we fight the spammers on one hand and trolls on the other. Let's not forget today' s episode.

I think today's was a very feel-good episode. It was good to see the stories today and heart-warming to see people rise above their disadvantages. But again what was missing in today's episode was sensitization.

We need to be aware of the problems and issues that people with handicaps face everyday. Just take the case of railway stations - the walkways and the over-bridges have only stairs and no ramps. Not just the physically challenged, but people with asthma and the elderly are daunted by these. It takes a physically challenged person a good 15 minutes to climb up one way, and then they have to climb down and then walk the long platform only to find there are no benches and no shades at the end of the platform. A few stations do have the golf-cart cars for the elderly, but they are available only on one side of the station, if you come from the other side, you have to wait for at least half an hour before getting the cart. The cart will anyway not ply on the inner platforms. The coolies will charge you an extortionate 1000 Rs upward just to fetch the wheelchair so at the end one feels that it is better to brave the long walk instead of being so fleeced.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.5k

Users

11

Likes

50

Frequent Posters

TheInkMistress thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Second you Chitranshi, it indeed was a heart warming/breaking/awekening episode and yes there were certain flaws but railway stations do have underground ramps- may be some of them still lack the facility, though.
Asthamatics and old-age would have been out of league topic but yes a small voice of dicussion would have been great nonetheless.
All in all I'd rate it 9.5 out of 10!
-Purva- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Actually apart from Delhi (to some extent, only in Paharganj), Mumbai(quite accessible) and Pune (has ramps on one side and stairs on the other on all overhead bridges), I have seen no railway station equipped to handle the problems of the physically challenged.

Another thing, I'm not talking about the Metro stations, I'm talking about stations for long distance travel. Most trains don't even have the facility for the disabled to board or de-board.
whatthewhat thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Sensitization is sooo important!

The way we treat the physically (and mentally) challenged is appalling (as individuals and as a society). I'm glad to read from Chitrashi's post that the situation is Delhi/Mumbai railway stations is okay...but on whole, public spaces in India are not inclusive in the regard.

Glad to see they brought up the issue but sad to hear they fell short of sensitizing the public to needs of the physically challenged.


TheInkMistress thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Actually my native city's railway station is equipped with ramp though its multi-purpose it also helps people to carry heavy-loads easily but then railway stations can only have long ramps rather than short once *obviously because of the distance*!

Originally posted by: Chitrashi

<font color="#0066FF">Actually apart from Delhi (to some extent, only in Paharganj), Mumbai(quite accessible) and Pune (has ramps on one side and stairs on the other on all overhead bridges), I have seen no railway station equipped to handle the problems of the physically challenged.

Another thing, I'm not talking about the Metro stations, I'm talking about stations for long distance travel. Most trains don't even have the facility for the disabled to board or de-board.
</font>

.dream-catcher. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: fire.whiskey

Actually my native city's railway station is equipped with ramp though its multi-purpose it also helps people to carry heavy-loads easily but then railway stations can only have long ramps rather than short once *obviously because of the distance*!

I dont know about places but once i visited Surat their i found was lift and railings and I think its a very good thought it help even the old people and even disableds
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

I disagree Chitrashi. I think today's episode was the best episode of Satyamev Jayate so far.

It had an inspirational tone, it did lay down facts/stats, tell stories, it did have moving and emotional parts too - but the sentimental bit did not dominate - which is a good sign.

Aamir has improved A LOT as an anchor. I like how his reactions, mannerisms have toned down a bit and his crying has also lessened. I noticed it in episode 5 also. Good to see him get more stable since he clearly begun on a shaky ground when he first started out!

I think it is APT that he did not give the show a despondent feel and kept the mood upbeat, allowed the courageous differently abled people to express themselves openly, and even joke about. It just helped ordinary people see that the disabled are not some weirdos but are, at heart, as normal and alike as them!

I think the needs of the physically challenged were shown well through the videos of disabled people struggling at public places, Javed Abidi's interview on employment and other rights of disabled and detailed coverage of Amar Jyoti school and its facilities.

The show can not go into minute details of how many stations in India have ramps or not and how coolies extort the disabled etc. Disability is a broad issue and its each facet has many other intricate issues attached with it. The show would be never-ending if it tried to go into too many nitty gritties.

The only issue that I have is that he covered physical handicap and did not even talk of intellectual handicaps & mental disabilities. That should have also been touched upon.

Plus, I didn't like skimming the surface when it came to biases at educational institutions and blaming only other class conscious parents! We know teachers and principals are no saints either and many have their own biases and do not want trouble of handling special kids with normal ones.

Lastly, I am glad he showed Nisha's case. It was gut-wrenching! I was not only appalled to learn of her condition but also flabbergasted by what she had to go through! No salute is enough for that girl's courage and her parents' unconditional love for her.

This episode made me feel ashamed of myself, how I worry about things and have at times given up on my dreams just because I got affected by what nasty & discouraging stuff other people said or did to me! Here, these guys are so proud of themselves and doing their best to live to the fullest, despite the callous comments of world around them despite their handicap. And ones like me? I am ashamed for not being able to muster courage myself and respect myself, the way these guys respect themselves and don't give a damn to naysayers!

What this episode has shown - is something which majority of Indians do not even think about. So I don't worry about other fine details which it might have missed. No one ever wondered about lack of simple facilities for the disabled. So I am glad it jolted indifferent masses' conscience! Best thing was attack on notion of disability being result of previous birth's sins or notion that being ''kind'' to some disabled person will get you some blessings or wash your sins! This notion is DEEP-ROOTED in masses of India. Too happy to see Aamir and participants on the show kicked it to the curb!👏

It was much better than other shows on this topic on TV. I don't think it failed on any count really.

Fatima_Q thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
@annika20: Totally agree with your post...you pretty much summed up what I wanted to say.
The show highlighted the prejudices shown to disabled people. The story about a woman spitting on the little girl was heart wrenching. And it is prejudice that is one of the biggest roots of evil in our societiess isn't it? Whether it's basis is a person's sex, skin color, caste, religion, economic bracket...and even disability or physical appearance.
I live in the US, so there are a great amount of handicap facilities available here...but they didn't come about overnight...many people fought to have them common here. Also existence of public facilities doesn't change public perception...discrimination still exists, especially in the work place.
People fail to recognize that the disabled can be enabled to become productive and contributing members of our society. It's silly isn't it?...on the one hand we look down on them for being a burden on society...and yet we don't want to empower them in any way.
The struggles disabled people face on a daily basis just to live out their routine daily lives is really something we don't think about especially if we are "Normal". Certainly after watching today's show...I'll be more grateful to God for what I've been given and will think twice before complaining.
A note on Aamir: I guess I never really focused on how he's doing as a host...😆...I've been more focused on the issues presented. But he seems to be doing fine, considering the nature of his show.
Edited by ummesulaiman - 13 years ago
cs-07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
the topic was sensitive indeed.

i do have to add an experience.
once a blind man boarded the bus, i had noticed he was quite regular .. maybe he worked in a government building around.

the man sitting at the seat reserved didnt get up for a long time even after noticing the blind man was standing right in front of him. it was a bad experience, in the end someone else got up to give the person a seat. i still wonder why didnt i say anything whne the guy didnt get up
Super Kool thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
I really liked this episode...the best part was when KK said "don't discriminate, why snub us or give us sympathetic treatment"...I think his statement was bang on...disabled are not from other planet...they are like an average human being...why treat them differently...in fact the guests on the show had an insight that was way above than that of an average individual...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".