Soona Mann Ka Angaan

sangitadas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Soona soona mann ka aangan

Dhoondhe payal ki woh cham cham

Sooni sooni dil ki sargam

Dhoondhe geet tere humdum

Man me sham ho ya savera

Laga tere hi yaadon ka dera

Tune bandhan kyon yeh toda

Tune kahe ko muh moda

Kaho na kaho na

Phool phool bhawra dole, mann me gunje teri yaad

Bag mein papihaan boley, pihu pihu pihu kaha … Kaho na

Kaise katey sooni ratein kaho na, kaho na

Kaise bhuley beeti batein kaho na, kaho na

Kaise thamey phir tera damaan

Kaise mahekey mann ka yeh angaan

Kaise bhuley preet teri sajaan

Kaise bandhey toota yeh bandhan

Man me sham ho ya savera

Laga tere hi yaadon ka dera

Tune bandhan kyon yeh toda

Tune kahe ko muh moda

Kaho na kaho na

Phool phool bhawra dole, mann me gunje teri yaad

Bag mein papihaan boley, pihu pihu pihu kaha … Kaho na

Yesterday, I sat down with a lot of trepidation and all my anxieties came true. I wanted to distance myself from two of my all-time fave telly characters and watch KS with equanimity and I must admit that I lost it. It was as if I am caught in this roller-coaster ride of life along with Jai and Bani and like them, I am unable to bring myself to terms with all the mis-happenings that are taking palce in their life. In short, I failed, probably the first time, as to where emotions are concerned. 😭😭😭

My heart went out to Jai when he picked up the bangles he had gifted to Bani from the dresser drawer. And my heart felt a pinch. 💔And I asked God, why them? 😲Look, this is the first gift that Jai had given Bani out of his own free will and its also the first gift that Bani had received from the person she loves whole-heartedly. Love, she does, otherwise why is heart-broken stance? If we are convinced of the wrong doing of any individual for whom we do not feel anything, then its very easy to hate that person and take revenge. It's not pity that Bani feels for Jai, its love along with all the equivocal feelings, swamping through her senses.

Coming back to the bangles, Bani had to part with it and Jai had to get it back! How sad! I am sure that even if Jai had bought French Polynesia for Bani (please, no offence meant), yet the bangles would always be much more important and expensive for her. 😛Firstly, because it's a husband's gift to his wife, acknowledging her status and role in his life, and secondly, because this gift came at a particularly tricky time when their relation was without much of a meaning and they were trying desperately to gain a foothold, even while walking on thin ice all the time. Jai's feelings for Bani, when he gifted her the pair of bangles, was also crucial in view of the fact that finally he was willing to let her in - inside his life, his room and his heart.

The way Jai clutched onto the bangles yesterday just tore at my heart. Later also, I kept on thinking, whether it was a momentary impulse, but I kept on feeling a constricting feeling, every time I replayed the scene mentally. It felt as if somebody has taken out my heart from my body and is putting it stomping it all around.

I was proud of Jai when he told Mausi the truth without any frills whatsoever as to the main reason of Bani's departure from his life. Mausi is the only lady to whom Jai will always look upto in troubles, when in pain and when faced with a dilemma of any sort. That's why he took great pains to ensure that Mausi never learned about the truth of his marital status. And how sweet is Mausi. She not only tried her level best o understand her Munna but also gave him courage that one day, Bani would definitely come back to his life (a big hug to Mausi from me), just as she had stepped into his life all of a sudden without any preliminaries. 😳😳😳

Now, my honeybun. 😛Yes, she does love Jai with all her might and all her soul. But, at present, she is too psyched up about the accident causing her mother's death and all the related happenings that she is letting events decide the course of her life and not the other way around. I think she's more hurt because its Jai who's involved in her mother's death – the only person whom she had looked up to for safety, security and a tad-bit understanding. And she had been doing pretty well too. She knows very well that she's in love with her husband and that over the past few days, her husband was also being affectionate towards her. ❤️

Just look at her helplessness when she closes the window and reminisces about how in a previous occasion, Jai had helped her do so. It's a classic conflict between the head and the heart and she is equally torn between the two. She wants to start a new life altogether on her own strength, but she is well aware of the fact that all her life, she will carry her husband's love with her and help it nourish and grow. She can never forget him, but can only try to cut him away from the present scheme of things. As a result, she has refrained from telling the truth to her sisters also, though they definitely deserve to know it. 😕

I don't know why Pia gives me the creeps (I think I am perfectly spooked up). Her reactions appear so funny and phoney to me, I can't understand why. And her jealousy when she accused Pushkar of taking more care of his friend than his wife, is so not done. Why did she forget even for a moment that Pushkar's friend is actually her elder Sister who has done so much for them? 😡On the other hand, Rano is more natural. Maybe because she has realised way back, that her Bani Di loves her husband a lot but is resigned to fate to decide her future. It was so sweet of her to say that 'at this time, u should be with your husband'. Jai would surely have had a heart attack if he had seen Bani standing on a chair to change a bulb.

Jai looked so sweet sitting in his room and looking like a Devdas 😉at his wife's photo and missing him like hell. But, I feel that he should stress more on getting Bani back to his house for her own self, and not because of the child. This stance is going to hurt Bani more.

This is for Jojo, especially, and all my other friends at IF ( a ghazal by Jagjit Singh, written by Gulzar)

"Ek parwaaz dikhayi di hai

Teri awaaz sunayi di hai

Jiski Ankhen mein kati thi sadiyaan

Usne Saadiyon Ki Judai Di Hai

Sirf Ek Safha Palat Kar Usne

Beeti Baton Ki Safai Di Hai

Phir Wahi Laut Ke Jaana Hoga

Yaar Ne Kaisi Rihayee Di Hai

Aag Mein Kya Kya Jala Hai Shab-bhar

Kitni khush-rang Dikhayi Di Hai"

(from the album – Marasim meaning Relationships)

I found this ghazal very touching and very true to the core of Bani and Jai's relationship right now. U just have to feel every word and understand the implications. I wonder how Gulzar manages to write so beautifully.

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.3k

Users

9

Frequent Posters

princessjojo thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: sangitadas

Yesterday, I sat down with a lot of trepidation and all my anxieties came true. I wanted to distance myself from two of my all-time fave telly characters and watch KS with equanimity and I must admit that I lost it. It was as if I am caught in this roller-coaster ride of life along with Jai and Bani and like them, I am unable to bring myself to terms with all the mis-happenings that are taking palce in their life. In short, I failed, probably the first time, as to where emotions are concerned. 😭😭😭

My heart went out to Jai when he picked up the bangles he had gifted to Bani from the dresser drawer. And my heart felt a pinch. 💔And I asked God, why them? 😲Look, this is the first gift that Jai had given Bani out of his own free will and its also the first gift that Bani had received from the person she loves whole-heartedly. Love, she does, otherwise why is heart-broken stance? If we are convinced of the wrong doing of any individual for whom we do not feel anything, then its very easy to hate that person and take revenge. It's not pity that Bani feels for Jai, its love along with all the equivocal feelings, swamping through her senses.

Firstly, because it's a husband's gift to his wife, acknowledging her status and role in his life, and secondly, because this gift came at a particularly tricky time when their relation was without much of a meaning and they were trying desperately to gain a foothold, even while walking on thin ice all the time. Jai's feelings for Bani, when he gifted her the pair of bangles, was also crucial in view of the fact that finally he was willing to let her in - inside his life, his room and his heart.

The way Jai clutched onto the bangles yesterday just tore at my heart.

It really was a poignant seen. It really hurt Jai to see that his beloved left the first gift he ever presented her. It conveyed the extent of Bani's pain and seeing those bangles, seemed to have made Jai realize how hurt she was. And it hurt him tremendously as well. Like you said, by leaving the bangles, Bani meant to leave him, his room, his house, and his heart (only if she ever can!).

How adorable it was to watch him stare at Bani's photo. He really missed her...her absense created a void in his room...he seemed so restless.

Im glad Jai disclosed the truth to Masi. I loved his dialogue 'ab jhoot kehne ki himmat nahi rahi.' He realized he hid too (much if not lied), in his relationship with Bani and Masi. This line seemed to be a direct response to Bani's accusation in the hospital room, where she blamed him for lying to her all along in their relationship. Im very glad this line was spoken by Jai. He realizes he lied and he doesnt want to repeat past mistakes anymore! Made me too emotional...

Originally posted by: sangitadas

Just look at her helplessness when she closes the window and reminisces about how in a previous occasion, Jai had helped her do so. It's a classic conflict between the head and the heart and she is equally torn between the two. She wants to start a new life altogether on her own strength, but she is well aware of the fact that all her life, she will carry her husband's love with her and help it nourish and grow. She can never forget him, but can only try to cut him away from the present scheme of things. As a result, she has refrained from telling the truth to her sisters also, though they definitely deserve to know it. 😕

You know Sangita, that was a perfect scene! It totally captured the emotions, and the implications of this separation! Bani remembered Jai while closing the window, an everyday, mundane thing! She is used to him and sees him in everything she does. It only emphasized how difficult it will be for her to face life, without the love of her life by her side, not physically or financially, but emotionally.

Originally posted by: sangitadas

Jai looked so sweet sitting in his room and looking like a Devdas 😉at his wife's photo and missing him like hell. But, I feel that he should stress more on getting Bani back to his house for her own self, and not because of the child. This stance is going to hurt Bani more.

This is for Jojo, especially, and all my other friends at IF ( a ghazal by Jagjit Singh, written by Gulzar)

"Ek parwaaz dikhayi di hai

Teri awaaz sunayi di hai

Jiski Ankhen mein kati thi sadiyaan

Usne Saadiyon Ki Judai Di Hai

Sirf Ek Safha Palat Kar Usne

Beeti Baton Ki Safai Di Hai

Phir Wahi Laut Ke Jaana Hoga

Yaar Ne Kaisi Rihayee Di Hai

Aag Mein Kya Kya Jala Hai Shab-bhar

Kitni khush-rang Dikhayi Di Hai"

(from the album – Marasim meaning Relationships)

I found this ghazal very touching and very true to the core of Bani and Jai's relationship right now. U just have to feel every word and understand the implications. I wonder how Gulzar manages to write so beautifully.

You have read all my posts voicing my concern over this issue, havent you! I agree that a repeated mention of Jai's longing for the child will hurt and distance Bani from him, further....

Jai's only fault here , like someone mentioned, is that his actions pine for Bani, but his words convey something else. Actually its wrong to call this a fault. He knows that an expression of his thoughts to Bani, may not help ease the situation, keeping Bani's agitated emotions in mind. At the same time, he cant help but express his longing for the child....Well, lets just blame it on the circumstances!

But my fear remains that Bani will really start to believe that its only the child that matters to Jai...

Thank youuuuuuuuuu so much for that dedication! Beautiful lyrics! Totally apt for the situation.🤗

"Phir Wahi Laut Ke Jaana Hoga

Yaar Ne Kaisi Rihayee Di Hai"

Wow!! Too much said in those two short lines there! How appropriate...Bani, the woman who has made JW meet the real him, is now gone...When Jai said that line, it meant that his identity doesnt remain the same with Bani out of his life...and those two lines from the Gazal state the same so poetically!

Wonderful Analysis Sangita! And the Gazal accentuated your words.👏👏👏 for the choice...

Luv, Jojo

sangitadas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
Thanks Jojo. I am literally in tears everytime i hear this particulr ghazal - its a fave of mine. i guess my hormones are workign overtime.

And thanks for going thru' the post. Maybe its not worthwhile, but can't do more in the office.

A big hug for you too 🤗

Thanks also to Sarah ... u guys rock 😛
princessjojo thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: sangitadas

Thanks Jojo. I am literally in tears everytime i hear this particulr ghazal - its a fave of mine. i guess my hormones are workign overtime.

And thanks for going thru' the post. Maybe its not worthwhile, but can't do more in the office.

A big hug for you too 🤗

Thanks also to Sarah ... u guys rock 😛

What!! Its not worthwhile? Come on now! Dont be modest! Ok, Ill spell it out, it was brilliant!

Btw, I also think your hormone are working overtime! Just noticed your avatar!😆😳

Last post for the day, gotta go hit the bed now!

TC, Jojo

sukk rocks thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
👏 great anylise...
keep it up.. 😃
lil_desi_goddes thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
didi.. ur analysis was soo heart renching! 😭
sangitadas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: princessjojo

What!! Its not worthwhile? Come on now! Dont be modest! Ok, Ill spell it out, it was brilliant!

Btw, I also think your hormone are working overtime! Just noticed your avatar!😆😳

Last post for the day, gotta go hit the bed now!

TC, Jojo



Yep, 😆😆😆 Have to do soemthing about my avataar 😆😆😆

Besharam Me 😆😆😆

Thanks for being so kind. 😛
heyitsrupy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Beautifully written Sangeeta... 👏 👏 Bani was really wonderful yesterday...its amazing how her vulnerability comes across when she thinks of Jai, and she begins to glow with this inner strength when she's with her sisters...
U know, Pia was making me uncomfortable too... Seeing the determined expression on Pia's face, I got a feeling she's going to come and blast Jai again today...I hope Jai strangles her if she does...Or if the hand in sling prevents him from doing that, at least kick her out.... !!!
love
Rupy
mayona thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
Sangita your analysis was awesome 👏 It almost made emotional for our sweet pair Jai and Bani 😭 😭
mayona thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: heyitsrupy

Beautifully written Sangeeta... 👏 👏 Bani was really wonderful yesterday...its amazing how her vulnerability comes across when she thinks of Jai, and she begins to glow with this inner strength when she's with her sisters...
U know, Pia was making me uncomfortable too... Seeing the determined expression on Pia's face, I got a feeling she's going to come and blast Jai again today...I hope Jai strangles her if she does...Or if the hand in sling prevents him from doing that, at least kick her out.... !!!
love
Rupy

I agree buddy Pias expression sounded trouble I hope she doesnt blast Jai again anyways as u said hope JW kicks her out this time😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".