killing curse

hi everyone... im kinda new to this forum... i've been a huge HP fan for the
past 5 years now...and i'd ocassionaly visit this forum but i never really
posted until a few days back....

i was wondering how snape was able to kill dumbledore... cuz i
remember moody saying that in order to perform the killing curse, the
person must really mean it or feel it... snape was able to successfully
perform the killing curse so did he really mean to kill dumbledore?

i'd love to hear what everyone here has to say

well there was a rumour or something that dumbledore aint dead and that snape didnt really do a killing curse only made it seem like it

Originally posted by: MainEkHasina

well there was a rumour or something that
dumbledore aint dead and that snape didnt really do a killing curse only
made it seem like it

i hope that's true...

mmm well i dont knw either...

would love to read wht other people think

Originally posted by: SpoILed BraT

hi everyone... im kinda new to this forum... i've been a huge HP fan for the
past 5 years now...and i'd ocassionaly visit this forum but i never really
posted until a few days back....

i was wondering how snape was able to kill dumbledore... cuz i
remember moody saying that in order to perform the killing curse, the
person must really mean it or feel it... snape was able to successfully
perform the killing curse so did he really mean to kill dumbledore?

i'd love to hear what everyone here has to say

ur reason convinced me. so i think dumbledore is gonna come back👏👏and welcome to the forum. hope u will have fun here.😃

dylan.

Originally posted by: potter4ever

ur reason convinced me. so i think dumbledore is gonna come back👏
👏and welcome to the forum. hope u will have fun here.😃

dylan.

thanks dylan! btw, im rashmi 😃

i sugget you check out the link Dumbledore's hintswww.dumbledoreisnotdead.com

thanks! i'd still really love to hear what everyone has to say tho

i don't think he's coming back...this is not one of ekta's dramas where people die and come back,it doesn't happen like that...and anyways proffesor mcgonagal wud not be able to become headmistress if dumbledore hadn't died cuz its got some kind of magic...i mean remember when umbridge tried to take over she cud not get excess to the office cuz dumbledore was alive.On the other hand mcgonagal got in proving that he's dead.
About the snape thing...well my theory is that snape did feel great emotions when he cast that killing curse...probably not hate but something strong towards dumbledore because he was making him do something he did'nt want to do...so he felt dislike towards him cuz he really didn't want to kill him.
I really hope this is making sense 😳

well i dont think hes dead.......cuz u know when snape tought them how to do a spell but you can say something else or not say anything at all???

well i think that he said the killing curse but said something else in his mind that didn't actually kill him!