Shirk In Jannat 2 Song

Page

khan baba

@khan.baba

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

I was just listening the song Rab ka shukrana .. . i highlighted blasphemous lyrics in the song "rab ka shukrana". i strictly condemn this blasphemous song, it was kind of distorting our beloved religion islam . this pathetic song was sung by a hindu singer mohit chuhan . he and all the crew included in making this song were not suppose to hurt sentiment of billions of muslims . . it should be banned . This film is named as jannat 2 . I just hope that all the Muslims around the world will endorse me. I want all of you to listen this song before posting a comment. Thanks

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSUSJTEddU4[/YOUTUBE]

Edited by sonunigamfan - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Rehanism

@Rehanism

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

What are you waiting for? Run to the Deobandis and get a fatwa issued on the dirty kafir singer and the lyricist [and the actors too, for good measure]...Blasphemy can never be tolerated...Burn some effigies, vandalize the embassies, break into theaters, demand public executions...Let the filthy kafirs know what's the consequence of hurting religious sentiments..Protecting religious sentiments is the most important duty of the state and judiciary...Everything else comes next.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Forever-KA

@Forever-KA

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sonunigamfan
I was just listening the song Rab ka shukrana .. . i highlighted blasphemous lyrics in the song "rab ka shukrana". i strictly condemn this blasphemous song, it was kind of distorting our beloved religion islam . this pathetic song was sung by a hindu singer mohit chuhan . he and all the crew included in making this song were not suppose to hurt sentiment of billions of muslims . . it should be banned . This film is named as jannat 2 . I just hope that all the Muslims around the world will endorse me. I want all of you to listen this song before posting a comment. Thanks

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSUSJTEddU4[/YOUTUBE]

1- There is no need to say "a hindu singer mohit chuhan". He has sung sufi songs as well and there we dont say that a Hindu singer Mohit Chauhan sang that song.

2- The lyrics were written by Sayeed Qadri or Sanjay Masoom. It is not clear however we can say that at least a Muslim was part of the lyricist team of this album and could have pointed it out when album was prepared.

3- Kalma is dervied from kalam which means speech. Similarly deen does not mean Islam only as for a hindu, hinduism is the deen and imaan just means belief. Jannat is not a concept specific to Islam. So literally one can make a case that there was not a reference to Islam.

However the use of word Azaan means that there was probably a reference to Islam.

4- In poetry when one says she is my kalma or deen then most of the time it is figurative and not literal, reflecting importance. In chaiyyan chaiyyan line was "mera naghma tu, mera kalma tu". This did not mean it was religious kalma. What it meant that she holds the importance for me as Kalma is important to a Muslim.

4- This is a movie and it shows a character singing this. The name of the character was Sonu Dill aka KKC i.e. kutti kameene cheez. Basically the girl in question can be his kalma or she can be his deen. It has nothing to do with Muslims though the religon was involved figuratively.

5- The question of shirk does not arise as Mr. KKC is not a Muslim. If you meant shirk in larger context then we know that anyway so this song does not anything new.

6- We are still free to not hear it, watch it etc.

7- I do get your concern as deen, kalma, azaan hold a different meaning for Muslims. Ideally we should avoid these things as to me its needless. There are other words which can show intense emotions for someone. Poets often cross these lines and we see examples of that in Urdu poetry as well. However considering all of the above least we can do is not make it a religious issue.

8- I can't read anyone's heart but my educated guess would be that at worst we should blame the lyricist for being careless

The writer of this post is Muslim also.