I read your discussion about N's mistake at pool. and couldnt stop writing about my view point :) Its been long time I wrote essay on AN's feelings from my point of view :D
Personally whenever i think about it, i have different opinion each time. Sometimes i feel N should have spoken something, if not saying those 3 words to A, atleast stopping armaan from making such a mess..
But then i think that she did try that, armaan was in no mood to listen that time and A was hell bent on making her talk.. Timing was just not right..
I dont know what N could do there.. N had already told armaan that its nothing like he thinks about A but still he didnt understand, like fool he kept saying you are innocent, you dont understand all these things and what not...
A was on another trip that time.. he just wanted to see N choose him infront of everyone. In some ways i think it was his mistake too.. if he loved N he should have seen how much Armaan means to Niki, he should have tried to see her confusion.
did you notice how each time (think about Kirti sangeet, outside marriage hall just after riots - the almost kissing scene, and then pool scene) he saw armaan coming towards both of them, he kept pushing N to show her feelings even more. he was acting as armaan isnt present there. he didnt matter from A's side but for N it wasnt the case and that always lead to jealousy and unreasonable expectations esp when he knew there was time when N was in love with armaan, He couldnt accept that and N couldnt come to terms with her feelings.
Well in my opinion one can always make mistake. It might be perfectly ok to feel hurt, betrayed but one shouldnt make more mistakes in that anger.. .And in my opinion A did exactly those mistakes when he said those harsh words again and again about her character.. First it was quite ok, for his wounds were fresh, but he wasnt able to heal himself overtime, learn from the way he had to face humiliation. He was in revenge mode and it was really hard to watch him make those choices.. it might be hard to forget, forgive but one has to.. Otherwise life would be full of broken hearts.. I think as a person this should have lead both of them understanding each other and themselves even more..
So after all this thoughts i still dont know if it was A, N or both at fault. I end up tipping either side each time i think about it but most of the times i end up thinking it was both of them and the Timing.
PS: this is all forgetting A's those dreaded words - I am married... I think A would be so so wrong in all these scenes if he was actually married :) So this all talk was under assumption that marriage track didnt air at all :)
Whowww.. This seems like bigger than your upate ;-) :) *hints*
Edited by anotheranfan - 13 years ago
265