tanthya thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1



The marriage state, with and without the affection suitable to it, is the completest image of Heaven and Hell we are capable of receiving in this life.

RICHARD STEELE




So the Marriage ceremony ends and nuptial games begin with PAYASH indulging in undoing the knots tied on the wrist, Payal has a go first followed by Akash ..both untangle the knot at the same time ..while this knot brings PAYASH closer, The other recently knotted pair are coming unraveled ...Arnav is at the doorstep , eyes slightly wet, sadness in his eyes as he sees the happy family in front of him.. and behind him stands his pillar, Khushi cringing ,diffident as her hands clench -unclench, she holds on to her lehenga rumpling it in her fear, eyes filled with tears downcast, looking woebegone , Arnav takes a step forward , realizes that Khushi is not keeping pace with , He turns to look at her , holds on to her hand , pulls her inside the house , draws a reluctant Khushi inside ...That family notice the approaching duo and are stunned as if they have had their vision of promised land !!

The nuptial game indicates that the the various knotty problems that this two families are going to face will be solved by PAYASH , PAYASH will uncover the truth..Payal it will be who initiates the process , Akash will take over or both will do it simultaneously ..Also a pointer that Khushi will not open her mouth .. seriously can Garima emote ??

How did the garland appear magically ?? one shot Arnav's neck was bare and next shot, he stands with the Garland around the neck..


Marry'd in haste, we oft repent at leisure.

BENJAMIN FRANKLIN


Arnav & Khushi stand together , side by side holding hands face the family, their deed forcing them to avert their eyes from the family , A sense of shame rendering them incapable of looking straight into the eyes of the family..A stupefied Buaji exclaims in shock as does mamiji who says it is a big joke !! The family are unable to comprehend the truth ..Buaji comes up to Khushi and almost pleads for explanation from a quivering Khushi, Garima joins in to seek her share of explanations... The raizada's are represented by Nani who demands an explanation from Arnav... SILENCE ,RINGING SILENCE is the only answer forthcoming ..when Nani peremptorily questions Arnav again, he looks straight at Shaym, with a borderline insolence, arrogance replies calmly that he has married ...Anjali it is who wants to know the reason for the hasty wedding ...then we get the prelude to the present ;

Khushi is dragged towards the poolside , Arnav demands to know whether she will do anything for her sister , A puzzled and uncomprehending Khushi replies in affirmative ..ASR then puts the 6 Months contract marriage proposition ..A mortified, shocked Khushi refuses to even consider it, rubbishes the offer , proceeds to leave but she is tugged back and a monosyllabic anser is demanded ..A strong Khushi firmly states NO , wrenches herself away from his grasp, A single tear begins to course down on her cheeks as her dreams die ..Khushi brokenly asks how could arnav even consider such a proposal, Khushi is on the verge of spilling her expectation her love for arnav when Arnav interrupts, orders her to think again ..when Khushi seems disinclined to accept his proposal, Arnav roughly turns her towards the Mandap , emotionally black mails her ...

The Scene was rife with subtle touches ...The shock and shame reflected in the eyes of Nani , the desperate need for comfort, the tension, a small flame of hope that Khushi might be teasing in Buaji's voice and demeanor ..while the Arnav feeling the weight of his pain as well as Khushi but unflinchingly facing the barrage of questions, the clipped curt reply reminiscent of ASR ..the check mate look of ASR when he looks at Shyam quickly turning to guilt n anguish as he sees his sister ...and Khushi ..the trembling , the tears, humiliation on being forced to go against her values ..The scene by the Pool..when ASR is all business and icy rage ..the refusal to soften even on seeing her dejection.. focused and ruthless whilst Khushi is confused, shocked , hurt...Khushi almost confessing her love for him but holding back ...That one dialogue , Tum tumhari behen ke liye .. serving to remnd us that A ASR who never believed in Marriage and rituals is willing to go thru that for his sister , How far will Khushi go?/ will she sacrifice her values for her sisters happiness ...

Whose was the dubbing voice , it was jarring to hear dubbing voice in midst of BS N SI's voice ..Is SI unwell, her eyes were sunken ??..it looked as if 6 months was added as an afterthought , a last min improvisation

Present ;

Arnav refuses to answer Anjali's posers, does not have the courage to look at her..A disbelieving Anjali slowly walks backwards, away from arnav, the distance growing between them while a hapless Arnav can only look unable to give her the explanation she seeks for the explanation would kill her !! The grilling starts with Khushi being pummeled with questions by Garima & Buaji ..when Khushi replies in affirmative , a resounding slap greets her and she is thrown against Arnav who holds her, shoots an angry glare at the woman who dared to slap Khushi but looks away impassively as soon as Khushi rises her head to look at him, a plea in her eyes is ignored ..while Nani fruitlessly tries to elicit information from Arnav, Khushi is not spared by her family , who angrily, in tears demand an explanation ...Khushi can only suffer in silence for she herself is ignorant of the reason ...

Prelude;

A plaintive Khushi pleads with Arnav for mercy but a merciless Arnav refuses to heed her plea and promises to make good on his threat , Arnav commands Khusi to obey his condition, follow his words to a T for 6 months..But Khushi flatly refuses , An angered Arnav retorts that Khushi shud be ready with tissues to wipe Payal's tears ...Arnav moves to stop the wedding and Khushi begins to think of the implications ...Khushi impulsively cries out to Arnav, Arnav turns back..stands in front of her, awaits her reply, his piercing gaze probing her...after a short pause, A broken khushi accepts his terms...The tautly tensed body of Arnav relaxes slightly , his tight face relaxes , his eyes reflects the pain he is causing Khushi ..Khushi promises to follow all his terms and conditions ...Khushi melts while a tormented Arnav watches unable to console or comfort her... A crushed Khushi covers her face , refusing to show her defeated spirit but this time the protective hand which hovered over her head in the hospital stays firmly by the side of ASR ...

Present; A momentary , silent communion between the tormented souls ...


When a match has equal partners, then I fear not.

AESCHYLUS, Prometheus Bound


This was a scene where Abha, Sanaya, Barun stood out ...the pain , the sense of outrage , the hurt that one of her girl had done it, a hope that may be all this is false , a joke from Thithaliya..Abha delivered on this ...while the guilt, shame, pain that they are the reason for the trauma endured by the family exchanged in the furtive looks was brought out by SI n BS ...

The second thing that pleased me was the effective use of FB... Khushi's mind leaps back to the time when she arrived too late , to stop her sister's life from being destroyed , Khushi had no power then to undo what had already happened ..but today ..She held Payal's life in her hand but there was a price to be paid for Payal's happiness ...That was her own Life/happiness ..Khushi willingly accepted the trade off ..

Third factor I liked was the continued silence of Khushi ..This will help Arnav to understand Khushi's silence regards Shyam ..


Note to CV's :

Barun is long overdue for a hair cut and a shave...I am not willing to see a typhoid patient , I wish to see a Business tycoon ...😊

Second... Monsoon is 4 months away, what is the need to start raining so soon and so persistently ...Yup !! am speaking about the never ending glycerin induced tears ...we need some relief , time to move on...



Edited by tanthya - 13 years ago


DO NOT COPY THIS POST AS THIS IS EXCLUSIVE TO INDIA FORUMS


Created

Last reply

Replies

290

Views

26.6k

Users

65

Likes

969

Frequent Posters

sbk2 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Hi Sathu 😃

Brilliant recap of the episode.

Loved it!

I do not like the actress portraying Garima at all..she lacked the correct expressions of shock and disbelief.

Loved how Arnav's face showed fleeting moments of conflicted emotions..by the pool when Khushi agrees to his shart, when Khushi falls into his arms after that horrible slap and when he looks at Shyam, then back at his sister.

Sanaya and Barun rock!

And so do your posts 👍🏼
365166 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Satya,
Thanks dear. Your posts are truly perfect analysis. You never miss even a fraction of second that is aired. For every scene I had to remind myself its just a fictional show. Mind you. No tears please. And LM himself has posted This to shall Pass and it will pass. That was my plight to say the least. I am a sucker for happy happy light hearted serials and this one is surely taking a toll on me. I really want this saga to end soon. I hope LM listens.
Edited by mommamia - 13 years ago
peppygeek thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
I was waiting for your post. missed the last couple of days. Okay. let me go and read now.

Brilliant analysis overall. I mean seriously what is wrong with Garima's expressions?! Today Payash's silence while everyone was reacting reminded me of the episode on 1st of dec where the four of them are returning together against the sunset. Damn but I can't past the pic. I hope you get my point.

Will PAYASH bbe the bridge between Arhi even in the darkest of times? What do you think?
Edited by pgm7 - 13 years ago
nema123 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Wonderful post Tanthya..!!! Quotes were awsomelll
Loved the one about the " When a match is has equal partner fear not..." 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Arnav has got his equal partner for sure...!!!
Love this show..
.Saraa. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
loved it..loved the epi..arhi back..loved the way u desribed the epi...
meera30 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Wonderful analysis of a classic episode

I know people are unhappy but I think this track shows just how creative the makers are.

The predicted route would have been to let Arnav blame Khushi and to allow her to play the sacrificial lamb despite loving Arnav. THAT would have meant tears and drama...and ONLY that till Arnav discovered the truth.

But by cleverly allowing Arnav to keep the real reason a secret even from Khushi, the makers have made sure that Khushi has reason to blame and hate ASR too till the truth surfaces.

Brilliant?...may be not...but clever all the same.

On another note, forum members are really angry with Garima and Buaji (to a lesser extent) for their reaction. But tell me this, isn't a mother (real or step, good or bad) justified in being upset with a daughter who chose to take the biggest step of her life (in their lives this is the biggest step in a girl's life) in such a way?The slap may have been too much, but the anger? Is it really that wrong?
premparbat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Sathya,
Brillaint quotes and writeup as always. Couple of things that I noted .
I liked the way Arnie kept holding her hand throughout and his reply to his nani ..It is what you see we are married.
What surprised me that Arnie seemed emotional while facing his family. He knew what he was doing so why was he not strong in front of them. He does not have to answer them but he alwys has one even when it was with breaking his engagement with La.
The dubbed 6 months was an after thought and it makes me feel that the Cvs have made a last minute change and deviated from their original plan for a twist and a unconventional fututre track. Maybe someone chickened out hence a lot of bloopers with Arnie's missing mala & Khishi's manicure ...
The monsoon season is here to stay and I think it will let up briefly as NK will be leaving soon and they may decide on some foolish departure plans.
Thanks again for your daily dose. There are a lot of poeple including me waiting to read it.
Rgds
nema123 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: meera30

Wonderful analysis of a classic episode


I know people are unhappy but I think this track shows just how creative the makers are.

The predicted route would have been to let Arnav blame Khushi and to allow her to play the sacrificial lamb despite loving Arnav. THAT would have meant tears and drama...and ONLY that till Arnav discovered the truth.

But by cleverly allowing Arnav to keep the real reason a secret even from Khushi, the makers have made sure that Khushi has reason to blame and hate ASR too till the truth surfaces.

Brilliant?...may be not...but clever all the same.

On another note, forum members are really angry with Garima and Buaji (to a lesser extent) for their reaction. But tell me this, isn't a mother (real or step, good or bad) justified in being upset with a daughter who chose to take the biggest step of her life (in their lives this is the biggest step in a girl's life) in such a way?The slap may have been too much, but the anger? Is it really that wrong?

I sooo agree with you..!!! This is wonderful twist...!! both will hate each other...!
And as a mother... I would have angry with my child... same like Garima and bua.. only Garima's acting was bad..
Doodle thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Tant, great explanation. It's TANTASTIC. 👏 👏 👏 I loved the connection that you have joined. Mera tuition fee kahan hain??? 😆 Just kidding. 😆 Sorry for the late analysis, my laptop crashed yesterday and tablet doesn't have all my files.

Well since you have touched almost the important parts of the episode, I will as usual not touch them but throw some light in a different angle.

As you said indeed the game has begun. But, CVs and Channel seriously??? I mean seriously you were going in for Actual Wedding??? 😡 A traditional wedding with all the pheras, sindoor and garland exchange at the temple??? I thought ASR is sketched by you and how in the earth you could have made such a blunder with his characterization??? This is such an IMPORTANT TURNAROUND and you all did not even think it through? Who has the brains behind it? Don't get angry with me please, but you need to understand why we were pressing on contract marriage. Let's see why???

Mr. Arnav Singh Raizada, a person who doesn't fear anyone in life; who is a straight forward person; who at the moment is same as a wounded lion; Who thinks in one direction always; Who doesn't even think straight when he is angry. A person who has the guts to cancel his own engagement at the Nth moment in front of the world. A person who doesn't think twice to break a possible alliance with the girl who he thinks he is not in love with even after living under the same roof for so many months. A person who loves his sister so dearly, that he can destroy the very existence of the human being, who would even think to harm her. He believes in the "Solemnity of Marriage" but doesn't believe in the "Institution of Marriage". He is not commitment phobic but he thinks it can be broken easily. He has seen the harsh realities of life hence that made him an Iron Man. Even for the sake of his sister he would not put a sindoor on a girl's forehead and exchange garlands in a holy place which he believes it doesn't exist. He WOULD NOT. Rather he would destroy the girl's life by marrying him in front of the world and the alleged partner of the said girl to punish and offer her a lifetime imprisonment and still would not give her "His Name". As Tant puts it - rather he would use a "Ready Made tag" to declare a non-existent relationship. This is Arnav Singh Raizada. So, CVs don't you ever dare to tamper his character. 😡 😡 😡

Now, you might think in that case how he would be sure Khushi will agree to marry in actual. Well in that case, they could have signed an agreement just before Payal's wedding like he did in actual, verbally. That signed agreement would have make sure after Payal's wedding happens their wedding will take place in reality. Simple. According to him, the girl who ruined his sister's life for a lifetime should also be punished for a lifetime. A marriage without "husband's name" would have been the biggest humiliation for Khushi. But, Arnav Singh Raizada can never elope and get married. This is absurd thinking.

Hence as I said in all my earlier analysis that Pretense / Contract Marriage should be the option. For logically and longevity of the serial, this is the only option if they were to be kept in the same frame. Khushi is a traditional girl; she believes in all the holy rituals, she believes in the institution of marriage. For her, no traditional marriage is a sham. It's a social stigma on a girl's integrity and honor. For Khushi this social stigma on a girl's face is unbearable. What more reason in needed for ASR to humiliate this girl who spoiled his sister's married life and the future of his neice/nephew??? Contract marriage doesn't need to follow the traditional rituals and hence ASR need not put the sindoor and exchange garlands. Contract marriage helps Khushi to walk out when the truth will be out and time comes. This will keep the longevity of the track as I mentioned in earlier analysis why possibility 2 on Feb 9th analysis.

If we need the "Trust" to build between them then this is it. This MU will be short term as it will be easy for ASR to figure out Khushi is innocent and Shyaam is the main culprit and that Khushi is also a victim as his sis. I have always believed in ASR's presence of mind and so believe he'll put 2 and 2 together eventually; like engagement with Khushi, brake fail, scorpion, money to Savita. electric shock, etc. Though he might think at first these are joint plans but at the end all will be well. How ASR saves Anji from Shyaam needs to be his first priority. Right now, ASR thinks whatever they will converse Shyaam will come to know about it as Khushi 'Shyaam are together. But, in reality Shyaam will be in dark and so his reactions will puzzle ASR. If he is a true player then ASR will throw signals to Shyaam through Khushi and wait for Shyaam's plans. But, after a short term ASR will realize the fishiness in Shyaam ' Khushi business. It will take around 3-4 weeks I suppose for him to realize the first jolt of Khushi's innocence all along. Khushi as it is perplexed with ASR's volte-face but the turnaround will have when both will get the jolt of each other's stance. Then Khushi's track will start for walking out and ASR's track will start for repentance and I want this. After 6 months' track (not in a literal sense) when the D day arrives, then the moment he'll be ready to apologize and repent, she will walk out. This track will be painful for us but short term.

One query I have thought, why 6 months??? What about after that? ASR bought time to correct things I understand but won't it be risky for him to disclose at the time of delivery or he thinks he can disclose much before that??? Or he thinks Shyaam will repent and he can be saved.

Somehow I loved the present track that the creative team and Channel are doing. Pretty good move. 👏 They really are making us to walk down the memory lane. This was needed as if we don't walk down the memory lane and rectify our mistake how can we proceed to a new life altogether.


It was the fateful night, when an innocent bubbly and determined, confident Khushi who went to change the thinking of the world; Who had a strong belief that if you stand against the wrong then you can change it to right. But, fate had to teach her the crude realities of life. That in order to change the wrong to right you need to pay a price. That fateful night she went to fight against Dowry. She went to talk to the groom but instead met the man who her DM had made for her. A cruel, dark Prince because of him her sister's wedding had never taken place. That man accused her of making the dowry money by ruining his business show. That day the dark prince answered her query of what he would do if her sister's wedding is at stake by breaking the pearls; showing her that he would destroy the dignity of that person who would think of ruining her sister's wedding. Let alone actually ruin it.


This day, the same situation again arose in front of the same girl. This day again her sister's wedding is at stake and the same dark prince is standing in between her and her sister's wedding to happen. But this day she didn't come to fight against Dowry but instead she became the "DOWRY". Little she knew that day she was determined to change the wrong and make it right but instead today she will give in to the situation and support the wrong. That day what was just a query and an answer became a reality today. Today Prince's sister wedding is indeed at jeopardy and he is determined to put his answer then in action today. YES, he destroyed the dignity of the person who in his opinion had ruined his sister's wedding. He had thrown a social stigma to her integrity for a lifetime. Loop closed indeed.


I think Sugar asked me about the loop "Badtameezi pe utra nehin hoon main'" This loop has opened today. Khushi asked him this same question "aap badtameezi kar rahe hain.." many a times on the Payal's first wedding night, in the jungle etc.. That day he said he isn't but today he really did. I won't say the loop is closed but it started definitely. The torturous days are here and I want the torture to be so more by him that when he repents the sky should also cry with him. That day the sky should pour out heavy rains and wash away all his "SINS" along with the water drops.

Couple of things before I wind off, I loved the contrast between Payash's untying the knots and Arnav-Khushi's entering home. As NK said that Payash will solve each other's problems but in reality it is actually Arnav-Khushi who solve each other's problem. Payash are the "Talkers" and Arnav-Khushi are the "Action Makers". Yes, whatever ASR had done is not good but we need to understand that he had taken a step in which he has no belief but for his Di he had to. If one hand he had sacrificed his MORALITY for his Di's sake then on the other hand Khushi had sacrificed her INTEGRITY and HONOR for the sake of her sister. His route might not be correct but his intentions cannot fully be blamed. He will destroy heaven and earth for his sister's happiness and I so am waiting for the day he will move heaven and earth for Khushi's happiness.

Speaking of Khushi, I feel the track "Di main aapke liye apni Khushi bhi kurbaan kardunga" is yet to come. There will be time when Arnav will trust and love Khushi completely and about to get married when Anjali will find out Khushi is the girl responsible for her broken marriage at the Nth moment, then she will turn against Khushi. That day, Arnav will have to sacrifice Khushi reluctantly. He has to face this of what he did today. He has to. The intense pain he had inflicted in Khushi till now and will do in future; how can he get away with only one repentance??? He has to lose her and then get her back to his life. That will be his atonement.

Another important view I had today is the difference between Shyaam and Arnav. At this juncture I see both are same. Shyaam had used Khushi for his own sake so does ASR. If Shyaam wanted Khushi for his love/lust, ASR married Khushi to save his Di's happiness. The only good thing is Shyaam cannot defend his act but ASR can.

Talking of Shyaam, Abhaas do gear up. You are a parallel lead in the show and if you don't act properly then I can foresee that there will be a time when the PH and Channel will think of replacing you.Today was one of the most important episodes and millions were eager to watch your expressions more than the leads and what did you deliver???You were simply pathetic today. Till date I can count when I seriously liked Abhaas's acting; in Bauji accident track and Anjali's pregnancy reveal and ASR v/s Shyaam faceoff. That's it. It's countable.

Edited by doodleberry - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".