Is Pratigya an atheist? - Page 3

Originally posted by: kEEnkEEn

see this is when I see red, when I see pathetic crappy lack of creative talent ruin the potential of a good story and a good point to make

If its too much for their grey matter then hand us the reigns - I swear we'd do a better job

I reckon these bloody CVs have gotten too fat and too complacent - they need to buck up their ideas a bit I swear and stop messing up with the lead's fundamental character!!

Getting Dadi, Amma and K to say "we know you don't believe in prayers" doesn't fool us for a minute. CVs - you yourselves didn't know coz you bloody well forget your own story!!!!

Forgive me all here, coz I know comparisons arent allowed and to be honest, there is no comparison to our darling show and the love we have for its characters - but if CVs wanna know how to pull off a good story for its realism as well as impart a good social message, watch a few epis of the show on immediately after MKAP...I did yesterday and I was even more pissed off because that is how you do it...

I'll say it again - no complaints towards the actors - my vitriol is purely for those cardboard cutou,t stand-in excuses for CVs!

I don't know. Yesterday's episode was a mess! She did the rituals before. Its not that she refused to do all the time! 😕 she is in a terrible situation thats why she's behaving like this. Umm voted for 'confused'.

It was one hell of an annoying episode...cudnt sit thru the Arushi or her sis nonsense...

Pratigya is not an atheist..If she was then she would not do puja or go to the temple, or keep fast or seek blessings from deities..

Probably they are thinking that whenever the TN have a havan, something always goes wrong..Will P tell the truth as she could not lie when the last baby haven took place?

Originally posted by: lovekriyan

of coarse not...prats do beleive in god...during kriya separation track she did go to temple and tied something to the tree der for getting back krishna...also during angad fiasco wen krishna was not in talking terms with her she haad fasted for him and went to temple...remember krish made her eat chilly rice...wen samar was missing she was sittimg in front of temple and praying wen her father came and consoled her...she do beleive and trust and is scared of god thats y during fake pregnancy track she confessed the truth as she cudnt lie to god...also wen krishna was in hospital she sang in front of an idol in the hospital...she do beleive in god but not in superstitions such as wen ss brought a tantrik to cure kesar or an ojha to cure chottu samar of stomach ache...

and in this case she doesnt want to give hope to krishna for children...if puja was for krishna it wud hav made sense as problem is with him...

hmmm...no P is not an atheist ...bec she do believe in GOD n had done pooja-prayers for K...i think she is behaving like this bec she is in turmoil n don't want K to know about the truth at any cost as he himself declared that he will go mad... n ofcourse , where we need medicine for our body, we need prayers for our mind...only in a healthy body a healthy mind can reside ... but some rituals r not nice n doesn't have a bearing to what we want to achieve... may be the CVs r hinting at it...

Hmmm...(clearing throat)

Loved this post! I'm quite late in posting an answer, everything's been said already 😆... but even I thought of this question when I was going my "God vs. Science" topic.

I believe that Pratigya contradicts herself, or maybe the CVs like to play with her character a lot. In any case, I have never found her to be extra-religious, or even moderately so. She seems to pray only when it is absolutely necessary. She has all the information (she preaches others about Gods) but she is very rarely seen praying herself.
I concluded that Pratigya is actually very similar to many many ppl. Lots of us, we become religious only when we really need something. At that time, we pray from our hearts, the minute we get what we want, we say a small prayer of thanks, and then move on, remembering God next only when we need him. I think that may be the reason the whole Thakur clan keeps saying that Prats does not believe in all this, because usually they see her doing nothing.

That being said, I also think that somehow the CVs have mixed up being educated with being religious. It seems like you cannot be both at the same time, it works by an inverse relationship.

Originally posted by: elle45

Loved this post! I'm quite late in posting an answer, everything's been said already 😆... but even I thought of this question when I was going my "God vs. Science" topic.

I believe that Pratigya contradicts herself, or maybe the CVs like to play with her character a lot. In any case, I have never found her to be extra-religious, or even moderately so. She seems to pray only when it is absolutely necessary. She has all the information (she preaches others about Gods) but she is very rarely seen praying herself.
I concluded that Pratigya is actually very similar to many many ppl. Lots of us, we become religious only when we really need something. At that time, we pray from our hearts, the minute we get what we want, we say a small prayer of thanks, and then move on, remembering God next only when we need him. I think that may be the reason the whole Thakur clan keeps saying that Prats does not believe in all this, because usually they see her doing nothing.

That being said, I also think that somehow the CVs have mixed up being educated with being religious. It seems like you cannot be both at the same time, it works by an inverse relationship.