JD deliberately made catan lose? To remove Shilpa?

Page

rittu_deep

@rittu_deep

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

Catan lost the task as JD lost his focus and could not give directions properly... What if it is a startegy by JD to remove Shilpa from his path? He knew that they will have to go to Tribal council...Stith, RajRani will definitely vote for Shilpa...When Shilpa suggested RajRani's name for elimination vote, JD decided against it and told everyone that it has to be Shivam...

He made Stith manipulate Shivam into voting against Shilpa... And then he gave his crucial vote to eliminate Shilpa...

After Shilpa's elimination, JD told to camera something like 'ab main tribe ko apne hisaab se chalaa sakta hoon" (I cannot recollect the exact words, but I think the meaning was the same)...

He is control freak...He wanted to rule Catan from the beginning but other Catan guys like Timmy, Abhinav, Karan didnt let him...Now they are gone, he knows that from the old team, there is only Shilpa who can pose a threat to his rule as Payal & Sangram are two dimwits, so he removed her...When Tayaks guys came in Catan, he told to the camera than these guys are young & fresh...So he probably thought that with Shilpa gone, those guys along with Payal & Sangram will follow his rules...🤪

Little does he know that Payal & Sangram can do it but not Stith, RajRani or Shivam..They are very headstrong guys...

Many people are saying Shilpa cannot be trusted...I agree that she has some not-very-good qualities but she is certainly not as bad or cunning as few other people... If someone cannot be trusted, it is Shivam and JD... Some are saying Shilpa was instrumental in the elimination of Rishi, but anyways Rishi was never a useful player for Catan...If someone deserved to go, it had to be Rishi.. For Priyanka's elimination also I think it goes with the same reason... I never thought she was a strong contestant...

JD's dislike for Shilpa and a reason to eliminate her got stronger when Shilpa cheered for Timmy and wished Harrison good luck... Shilpa wasn't exactly responsible for Catan's loss... She just cheered but JD very cleverly turned everyone against her, directly or indirectly...Otherwise, I don't think Payal is a stronger contestant than Shilpa...

But I won't defend Shilpa here...😊...Everyone has their own opinions...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Shanti

@shanti05

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

I agree with your take, Shilpa was playing her game her way , maybe she has her own instincts with her plans , Somewhere it backfired, but yes right from the start Karan also used to think JD was trying to be mommy around , Shilpa was getting weak as Timmy was not around , she was totally lost , and cheering him was wrong and also Harrison , but maybe some motive in that also like indirectly rooting for your team , I donno some strategies here also
Well now she dose'nt know that she will end up with Rishi whom she inspired shivam to vote out also Shivam had his self motive for that

I am still going to see what is Shilpa's next thought process, she may have some other strategy in the new tribe which gets formed by eliminated contestants and rules may change

The game is still on and looking forward to how it continues and how far Shilpa sticks around

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

axeion

@axeion

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Haha, I think I said this somewhere yesterday! JD is a director, he can easily write a mini-script and manipulate people. 😃

Quote

luvkasu

@luvkasu

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

i so agree with you!! JD and STITH played a dirty game! When everyone was saying to vote against SHIVAM, Shilpa was the only one who kept on requesting everyone catan member there not to vote him out as he is the strongest player!! she requetsed payal and sangram for like 10-12 times not to vote shivam out, then even in the trible council she said that she is doing what that is bad for her tribe n she is not feeling good about it..!!

JD played the most dirtiest game ever! he went to stith and told her that shilpa is requesting everyone that shivam should be eleminated! JD had problems with shilpa right from the begining! He told stith that he would be on their side to vote shilpa out..!!! n when sangraam asked JD tht why did he vote shilpa out? He was like shilpa has voted herself.. so mean of u JD

STITH then told shivam that everyone is putting his name 4wd n shilpa is instigating everyone!
payal was initally afraid of shivam and shilpa making team, so she requested to eleminate shivam

Quote

meghan11

@meghan11

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

Until yesterday I sincerily doubted JD's prowess as a manipulator...but after watching yesterday's episode I had no option but to change my mind😔...his behavior was intriguing... now he is in a controlling position in Catan...When Shilpa got evicted the expression of disbelief on Payal's face was amazing!!! She didn't see it coming..

Quote

axeion

@axeion

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: meghan11
When Shilpa got evicted the expression of disbelief on Payal's face was amazing!!! She didn't see it coming..

I hope she and Sangram atleast now realise that JD can back-stab them as well if need be!

What I don't understand is, why isn't anyone thinking of voting Payal. I mean even the ex-Tayaks, they could have voted Payal and left Shilpa. Shilpa is definitely a better contestant to have in one's team. Is Payal also like Munisha in new Tayaks?

Quote

meghan11

@meghan11

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: axeion

I hope she and Sangram atleast now realise that JD can back-stab them as well if need be!

What I don't understand is, why isn't anyone thinking of voting Payal. I mean even the ex-Tayaks, they could have voted Payal and left Shilpa. Shilpa is definitely a better contestant to have in one's team. Is Payal also like Munisha in new Tayaks?

There maybe a few reasons why they didn't nominate Dory(Payal):

1: They don't see her as a threat right now...

2: Her alliance with Sangram...don't want to aleniate the wrestler💔..they sure need his physical strengh for winning the tasks...it's a different story that he doesn't have anything to offer there too...

3: The ex-Tayaks felt that she is more trust-worthy and can count on her than Shilpa..

Quote

JD deliberately made catan lose? To remove Shilpa?

Related Topics

Explore Topics