rate rishis stupidity

i personally think its infinite.

why all are negative choices only??

it is one sided poll.

From starting he is shown as immature person...

Originally posted by: sab100

I think we are trying to go too extreme on him . Yes , he did a grave mistake indeed . But we all do say or do stuffs in some situation that we won't do in normal situation . Same happened here . He didn't say intentionally - when he saw Munna was going to beat his wife ...his first thought was to save her. He was once beaten by him , so his subconscious mind acted on that experience. Therefore, he said those stuff without thinking future repurcussions. As somebody pointed out in another thread , that he didn't even say Indira's name , it was Munna who thought it so .

I must say what a solution it was which created hundreds more problems. And u were right it was munna who thought such rubbish thought. that becoz except Sunaina there were lots of women might come there to abort their babies and the Sharma ladies came there to help them. becoz it was Sharma ladies honorable duty to help those women to abort their babies, wasn't it? So it could be anyone. Why munna thought that rubbish? He was such a dumb, wasn't he? and about Rishi... we could easily expect such blunders from him. Becoz from day one he was continuously making blunders after blunders to help Indira.

Rishi isnt dumb or stupid because he made a mistake!
Everyone makes mistakes and HD is just showing reality

Originally posted by: -Ishana-

Rishi isnt dumb or stupid because he made a mistake!
Everyone makes mistakes and HD is just showing reality

ya.u're right. everybody makes mistakes and whats the big deal that rishi makes mistakes EVERY TIME.

Originally posted by: naina158

ya.u're right. everybody makes mistakes and whats the big deal that rishi makes mistakes EVERY TIME.

Every time ? Really ?
Rishi helped her EVERY TIME.
Thats why Mandira was released from jail in Macau,thats why Sharma Niwaas is still in Indira's hands and thats why Indira had somewhere to go to when her own family kicked her out.

yah galti nahi hai yah kahin ziada hai
aysi baat koi kar bhi kaysay sakta hai
jab k woh indira ki help karna chata hai

if that was help then Indira was lot better without his left. First he helped Mandira to elope then went to Macau to rectify his mistakes. He didn't go to Macau to help Indira. he went there to remove the accusation from him. And about releasing Mandira from jail then if he didn't help Mandira to elope then Mandira wasn't in Macau. So first he created the problem and then try to solve his own created problem. and what was the solution...a fake marriage. Every time Rishi choose a wrong way to solve the problem. His every way was full of lie and deceive.Because of him for the first time Indira told lie, because of him Indira deceived her own family and because of him now Indira's reputation is in danger.A real hero never choose a wrong way in any circumstances.