My take on pia & the secret

Hi all, I'm new to this forum, for the last few days I've been reading updates here, although this is the first time I'm writing. have read a lot of different views on the actual secret, giving my take on it below.

My guess is that pia is chandani & brijesh's daughter. Before nahar met chandani, brijesh & chadani must have had an affair. brijesh must have left her since he came to know something bad about chandani's character and that's the reason when nahar asked permision to marry her, he refused outright. what other reason can he have for refusing,when he has not even seen her nor given his word to anybody else for nahar?

chandani on the other hand must have got close to nahar only to get back at brijesh. so she did not want nahar to ask permission from his family members for marraige, she knew that brijesh would refuse.

also all this drama she created accusing tara & nahar of having relationship must be for hurting brijesh alone. things went bad to such an extent that nahar came to know the truth and in his rage that she used him, killed her. the guilt of murder must be heavy in his heart and he's not able to overcome it, hence he goes to the PD everynight to remove his anger and frustation at chandani's pictures to lighten his burden to some extent.

As for pia, after chandani's death, the family must have come to know that chandani had a daughter from brijesh called pia. if you remember brijesh once said that he loves his daughter pia although she isn't with them. they must have kept her in a boarding school and must be taking care of all the expenses.

this is just my take, would welcome your views

excellent 👏👏👏 i think u r damn correct... cant disagree on a single point... i was so confused and eager to know the suspense - this seems a definite possibility....

thank you ucandoit. i could not come up with any other logic.

yup... lets see - today it will be revealed 😃

As far as I remember, a couple of days ago in US, Tara said,"Humne kya paap kiya hai jo hamara koi bachha nahi hai. Ab hum Saloni aur nahar ke bachhe ka intezaar karenge"

She said something to this effect. I remember very well. She was standing near a window when she said this..

One point that I dont agree.

If Nahar killed Chandani at any bad situation he might have fill bad about what he did for few minutes/hours or days. He has no reason to visit every night that place (Just not convincing even if it is true). He used to love her lot but he killed her after knoing someting bad considering all just not convince me the reson he need to visit that place every night (given the fact that now he has a good wife, saloni). Also I believe he noticed that saloni knows that he is visiting there and she is suspecious about all this. Considering all this no one will visit PD everynight.

Originally posted by: joypaul

Hi all, I'm new to this forum, for the last few days I've been reading updates here, although this is the first time I'm writing. have read a lot of different views on the actual secret, giving my take on it below.

My guess is that pia is chandani & brijesh's daughter. Before nahar met chandani, brijesh & chadani must have had an affair. brijesh must have left her since he came to know something bad about chandani's character and that's the reason when nahar asked permision to marry her, he refused outright. what other reason can he have for refusing,when he has not even seen her nor given his word to anybody else for nahar?

chandani on the other hand must have got close to nahar only to get back at brijesh. so she did not want nahar to ask permission from his family members for marraige, she knew that brijesh would refuse.

also all this drama she created accusing tara & nahar of having relationship must be for hurting brijesh alone. things went bad to such an extent that nahar came to know the truth and in his rage that she used him, killed her. the guilt of murder must be heavy in his heart and he's not able to overcome it, hence he goes to the PD everynight to remove his anger and frustation at chandani's pictures to lighten his burden to some extent.

As for pia, after chandani's death, the family must have come to know that chandani had a daughter from brijesh called pia. if you remember brijesh once said that he loves his daughter pia although she isn't with them. they must have kept her in a boarding school and must be taking care of all the expenses.

this is just my take, would welcome your views

I agree with you joypaul. Good guess. I too think that pia is Brijesh's and Chandni's daughter.

I think Brijesh killed Chandni in a fit of rage and that is why Nahar wants to hide it. Had Nahar killed Chandni, he would have told it to Saloni, but he does not want to put his brother to disgrace because then he will have to tell Saloni as to why Brijesh killed Chandni.

Originally posted by: sangeeta

I agree with you joypaul. Good guess. I too think that pia is Brijesh's and Chandni's daughter.

I think Brijesh killed Chandni in a fit of rage and that is why Nahar wants to hide it. Had Nahar killed Chandni, he would have told it to Saloni, but he does not want to put his brother to disgrace because then he will have to tell Saloni as to why Brijesh killed Chandni.

sorry guys, i don't think pia is brijesh and chandi's daughter. if you remember, during the whole turmoil concerning gayatri's marriage, kuki kaki had told brijesh, "what fault did pia have that she had to be born in this world as your sister?" which indicates that pia is their illegitimate/half/step sister. I think Pia and Chandi are two seperate issues. Because, if Pia was his daughter from chandni, and the whole family knows about it, then tara must also know about it, and i don't think she would stick around with him after she got to know about her husband's illicit affair.

Also, i don't think Nahar deliberately killed chandi. since he has a temper problem, he probably couldn't take her nonsense and he probably hit her so hard that she fell and hit her head, had a brain hemmorage, who knows? but i think he had not intended to kill her, she accidentally died at his hands and which is exactly why he repents every night at the purani dodi.

this is what i think.

yeah..I also think Nahar must have killed Chandni by mistake/accident.

I am also not convinced why somebody whould visit PD every night 😕
Repenting is one thing but going to that dirty room, what does he do?

Originally posted by: joypaul

Hi all, I'm new to this forum, for the last few days I've been reading updates here, although this is the first time I'm writing. have read a lot of different views on the actual secret, giving my take on it below.

My guess is that pia is chandani & brijesh's daughter. Before nahar met chandani, brijesh & chadani must have had an affair. brijesh must have left her since he came to know something bad about chandani's character and that's the reason when nahar asked permision to marry her, he refused outright. what other reason can he have for refusing,when he has not even seen her nor given his word to anybody else for nahar?

chandani on the other hand must have got close to nahar only to get back at brijesh. so she did not want nahar to ask permission from his family members for marraige, she knew that brijesh would refuse.

also all this drama she created accusing tara & nahar of having relationship must be for hurting brijesh alone. things went bad to such an extent that nahar came to know the truth and in his rage that she used him, killed her. the guilt of murder must be heavy in his heart and he's not able to overcome it, hence he goes to the PD everynight to remove his anger and frustation at chandani's pictures to lighten his burden to some extent.

As for pia, after chandani's death, the family must have come to know that chandani had a daughter from brijesh called pia. if you remember brijesh once said that he loves his daughter pia although she isn't with them. they must have kept her in a boarding school and must be taking care of all the expenses.

this is just my take, would welcome your views

I like your story line better. It makes more sense. Bft after reading today's India update it seems that the Purani Dodi secret is pretty stupid and over-hyped. Wish you had writtten the script instead - your take is more interesting.