Creative Critics Corner - 7th Sept 2011

manasi_31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

Welcome to Piya Bawari Corner for

Feedback to the Creatives



The information here is Xclusive meant for the Creatives & DP Team

Everyone Is Welcome

Start sharing your views, critics and comments

But not to forget few rules & regulations to keep the

Thread & Discussion

clean & Neat

(Kindly follow the rules)

DISCLAIMER

This Thread will be opened only by the the following Piya Bawari's exclusively for now.. As we days go by the other sincere Bawari's will be given an opportunity to open the Thread.

As of now thread will be opened by

Monday : Elizabeth Darcy - Lizzy

Tuesday : purvimeh - Purvi

Wednesday: Manasi

Thursday : Vandy

--


Piya Bawari RULES


1. We are going to open new Piya Bawari corner before airtime All Bawari's can immediately reserve after Lizzy, Purvi, Manasi & Vandy has reserved it'

2. Shift there once the show finishes & start un reserving if you can

3. First 2 pages of the can be reserved only for Serious takes for the show,

4. Share you Viewpoints of the Episode & the story in the most constructive fashion

5. Feed back and Appreciation for the Actors & the Team is welcome. No Bashing or using derogatory terms. Members will be reported immediately

6. Do not spam this thread & keep discussion not connected to the Epi of the show out from here.!

7. Don't multiple QUOTE use "@" to reply this will keep the page Clean and readable for the rest

8. Please refrain from comparing the leads from their previous shows.


So Go ahead & start your feedbacks..Anyone & everyone is welcome no permission is required.

Please Make sure you Edit your reserved Post


Lets bring the Actors to the top in IF rankings by joining their fan clubs & writing in their fan clubs twice(max allowed) every day..


Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

883

Users

5

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

manasi_31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Come here once the epi is done to Post & Edit

your reserved space.! 😃

For the time being we will follow a format for the review, which will be as follows:

PoV of Overall Epi:


Points that we liked:


Points that we disliked:

Mention Bloopers:

Msgs for the lead Actors (Sincere Comments):

Msgs for the rest of the cast../team/makeup/costume department:

Suggestions for handling of tracks:

Other suggestions:

Edited by manasi_31 - 14 years ago
manasi_31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3


PoV of Overall Epi:


Again a good fast paced epi


Points that we liked:


The way Mohan gave expressions to Kastur when she was trying to stop him from opening the door 😆

Mohan-Saroj scene... lovely... I liked the understanding they do share even after 4 years of Mohan staying away from his mom ...

Loved how Mohan was trying to first establish his point politely to baapji ... And loved even more when he argues with baapji

"Aapki soch aaj bhi 1947 se pehle wali hai" 🤣


Points that we disliked:


None as such today really


Mention Bloopers:


None


Msgs for the lead Actors (Sincere Comments):


Rocking expressions by Harshad in the first scene and awesome dialogue delivery in his arguement with baapji

Aasiya didnt breathe too heavily today except when baa caught her .. so i was fine with her performance today ...dialogue delivery could have been a bit slow in her scene with her brothers ...liked her slight blushing at the end of that scene


Msgs for the rest of the cast../team/makeup/costume department:


HC looked dashing in the red kurta during the Ganesh Pooja 😍

Surpiya ji made me love her more with the delivery of that one dialogue today ...when she asked mohan why he needs money ... The way Supriya ji said it it made Saroj look so loving yet worried and confused at the same time ... She was looking gorgeous too


Suggestions for handling of tracks:


Now that they are reaching the highpoint gradually with the revealation of why Mohan came back to India, why is he asking for money and how would he end up marrying Kastur, I sincerely hope the CVs do justify properly every act of Mohan..Eventhough he is supposed to be grey-shaded and am sure Harshad would handle it perfectly, a grey-shade character does need a strong script that shows the character "grey" and doesnt end up making it negative! I expect CVs to give exposure to Mohan's thoughts, feelings and POV too in all the mess he'd be going through


Other suggestions:


Same as above


Edited by manasi_31 - 14 years ago
-Ramya- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

PoV of Overall Epi: Good episode with a move in story 8/10! 😃


Points that we liked: Mohan ofcourse 😍 MohUr scene, Mohan's raaz khulling 🤣, Kastur's defend on Mohan from now itself! 😆, Mohan's new avatar and his exercising in anger😍, Mohan looks in Kurta for the first time! 😳 Not to forget the scene between Mohan-Saroj and the argument between Mohan-Baapji!🥱


Points that we disliked: Argument! It was much of loudness from Baapji's side! Not properly showing why the loan was taken from Mohan and his friend!😕

Mention Bloopers: Nothing I guess for today!😆

Msgs for the lead Actors (Sincere Comments): Harshad rocked as usual with this dialogs and gestures! Aisya was good in the beginning scene as a scared girl! 😉😆

Msgs for the rest of the cast../team/makeup/costume department: Dont like Kastur's costume in today's episode and make up was dull!

Loved Mohan's wardrobe today! Saroj was good at her best to help her son! 😛

Suggestions for handling of tracks: I completely hate the track that's leading to Mohan-Kastur marriage because of the load clearance that might be happening from Kastur's dad! This will be completely bad track ever ! 🤢

Guess the marriage track is coming soon which should not be so fast! 😕

Other suggestions:

Edited by ramyaks - 14 years ago
x-Sundas-x thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

PoV of Overall Epi:

Really good episode. Enjoyable, moving with the flow now. I like the points shown in today episode

Points that we liked:

Old generation vs. new generation. This was the main thing I really liked in today's episode. We got to see both point of views and it help us to know the character very well. Also the bon between Saroj and Mohan was a treat to watch.

Points that we disliked:

I think the sound department needs to tone down. Really dramatic music is played even when it's not needed. Example when Kastur gets caught and gets hyper the music was OTT.

.

Mention Bloopers:

None

Msgs for the lead Actors (Sincere Comments):

Today two actors stole the show. It was Baapji and Mohan. Excellent dialogues delivery. Gestures were bang on. Their expressions were right on the spot. Bravo to both of them.

Msgs for the rest of the cast../team/makeup/costume department:

Also Kastur needs new clothes. I think they PH are focusing on Mohan clothing; she needs a makeover in clothes term. I don't like what she wears I mean it's the same design, same type with just different colors

Suggestions for handling of tracks:

We should get Mohan spending more time with his family i.e. without Baapji interrupting. I want the rest of the family to ask Mohan about his life in London. About his friends etc.

Make Mohan have special place or Kastur in his heart rather than a business deal. Also both of them to share their opinions on certain thing

Other suggestions:

Same as above

-Shobhu21- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Im sry... I know i shud be unrsing my old one...But im tooo lazyyy...
So ehre goes the review for this epi
PoV of overall epi :
Overall a nice and smoothly moving epi...every scene fits into place...Proper emphasis at the right places...
Points that we Liked
Mohan's behaviour towards Kastur...It was fully confused and I just loved it...Kastur the way she paniced about the door being opened ...
Saroj and Mohan's interactions...The way they understand each other
Mohan & Baapji's convo...was gr8...🤣
And one more thing...Like otehr shows Thanks god they didnt drag the Pooja alone for 2-3 epis...it was just as much was needed.
Points that we disliked :
Well in yes epi Baa want in her full mood...And the way they showed Baa questioning Kastur I felt odd ...Maybe to give the epi a tensed feel...Bt it didnt work out too well here coz we know Baa's filmy and Kastur is her cutie pi so she wont doubt her
Bloopers :
NONE
Msgs for lead actors:
HC just handles Mohan's character tooo well...The 1st scebne with Asiya was gr8...The way he looked tensed upon meeting his so called friend from London, The way he manages to make Mohan look so simple in front of others when Mohan actually isnt was perfectly balanced...Loved his expressions and his pushups😆And he lookes dashing in the red kurta
Asiya did a great job as Kastur too...Her panting with tension was not req atleast not with Baa...But otherwise her way of defending her Mohan-jee was gd...
Other Msgs :
Supriya ma'am roced as Mohan's mom...The way she showed her concern yet understanding of Mohan's situation when he asked for money was great..She looked gr8 in her costumes
the rest of the side roles are doing a gr8 job...Baapji is dong a gd job also as the Garam Masala man...
Suggestion for handling track
Well now that we get to see Mohan's character unwrapping slowl and finally...CVs plll take care to give some gd and justifiable reasons as to why Mohan left his degree, and all abt the money issue, Because Mohan loves his mom...So withput a proper reason he wudnt have left his degree...
Other suggestion :
Make Baapji;s character a bit mroe realistic...i know u need to have a harsh charac lie him...But Baapji at this age seems a bit unrealistic for me
VandyP thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

PoV of Overall Epi:

dhamaakedaar...yupp thats the only word that comes to my mind...for once we had an epi which actually focussed on wat the show is all abt...mohan's past being revealed slowly...and the fact that mohan and baapji have a difference of opinion due to their generation gap...

Points that we liked:

the way the focus was on the main things...side characters were sidelined😊
the way mohan is least bothered abt wat kastur thinks(he is shown to be a guy with a carefree attitude)...the scene between baapji and mohan was killer⭐️⭐️⭐️the way kastur's nature is being portrayed...and the scene between desai siblings😊
and how can we forget the scene where mohan is exercising...keep such scenes coming😉

Points that we disliked:

none than i can think of

Mention Bloopers:

tinu is growing up way too fast

Msgs for the lead Actors (Sincere Comments):

harshad...

u r amazing as mohan...
the scene witr kastur was superb...some very natural expressions...esp ur eyes...
frnkly u stole the show in the scene with baapji...i could relate myself very very badly to it...reminded me of my days wen i used to have these kind of arguements with my grandfather...though i never had the courage to walk away the way mohan did...i salute mohan for keeping a firm stand in front of baapji
asiya was great in the scene where she realises she had been holding mohan's hands ll the while...and her sadness wen mohan leaves withouteating was very well portrayed
Msgs for the rest of the cast../team/makeup/costume department:
costume departmnt is doing an awesome job...esp with mohan's clothes
as for asiya i wish they stick to one pattern and make it her signature style...i had loved her lehariya dupattas in the initial epis...and if kastur makes it her signature...it'll be a great to see lehariya dupattas coming back in fashion😊

Suggestions for handling of tracks:

creatives...plzz stick to the pace u've picked up
there's an air of mystery involved..(mohan's past)
.a not so typical love story brewing up(mohur love story)
and a track where most of us can relate with our past and present lives (mohan-baapji faceoff)

Other suggestions:

thank god...u've made baapji and baa much more tolerable...

baa's references to salman r fine...but no more dabbang antics plzzz

baapji not agreeing to wat mohan thinks is oki...but don't overdo it

and plzzz don't make saroj go overboard with her disliking for kastur...we know she loves mohan a lot...

Edited by -vandy- - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".