we had posted enough of theories on jai-roshani secret. after reading all the theories, one thing is come out as conclusion that roshani has lot to do with the past. the way she spoke to bani about her family disease, it was so sponteneous as if spoken by family member. as if she knows her family so well. even jai's sentence that people learn from mistakes but here u r who commit mistake after learn it. so roshani knows bani's mom very well. either her sister or her very good friend.
before roshani's entry, jai never showed any kind of feeling of guilty or remember his past. all started after roshani enter in the picture. so roshani would be the main culprit & jai indirectly associate with her. or may be jai is paying for roshani's wrong did.
like if roshani did an accident which killed bani's mom and at that time jai n roshani were dating, jai hide the truth from nishikant but promise himself & nishikant to look after the 3 girls when they were all alone in the world. thats why nishikant told bani to go to jai walia after his death, saying he is the only one as their known person. so rashani is culprit and jai is paying for her wrong did by hiding the truth from bani as he don't want to hurt her.
or jai and bani's mom were in love and roshani did something to got them apart as roshani has a big crush on jai. bani's mom came to know abt it and she withdraw herself and married nishikant. so roshani blackmail jai for this matter. again roshani culprit and jai paying and save bani from being hurt.
more u think, more theories come to the mind.
any suggestion my dear detectives of INDIA FORUM...😉
love ,
kiah