happygirl123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
After watching yesterday's episode 2/08/11 I felt utterly disappointed because the way Abha's delivery scene was handled was nothing but nonsense..Yes indeed Suhasi did portray expressions with showed she was in pain..but giving birth in the first place isn't neat and tidy..I'm a medical student and I've seen deliveries there's a lot of blood involved and its not that easy to give birth all by yourself without the help of anyone because Vasu was just sitting there.

After the baby was born,he was not covered with blood and no umbilical cord was cut not to mention there was even a tilak on his forehead as soon as he was born 😆.The baby didn't even look like that of a newborn but instead looks like a few months old because new born babies haven't fully opened their eyes yet.

Later when Vasu was carrying the child they didn't zoom on Abha because its obvious that a woman who has given birth would be bleeding

I'm just feel that episode was illogical..I know its a drama and anything can happen but they should have made it seem more real

Guys if you agree with me please press the or give your comments

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

4k

Users

10

Likes

49

Frequent Posters

sahil70 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: happygirl123

After watching yesterday's episode 2/08/11 I felt utterly disappointed because the way Abha's delivery scene was handled was nothing but nonsense..Yes indeed Suhasi did portray expressions with showed she was in pain..but giving birth in the first place isn't neat and tidy..I'm a medical student and I've seen deliveries there's a lot of blood involved and its not that easy to give birth all by yourself without the help of anyone because Vasu was just sitting there.


After the baby was born,he was not covered with blood and no umbilical cord was cut not to mention there was even a tilak on his forehead as soon as he was born 😆.The baby didn't even look like that of a newborn but instead looks like a few months old because new born babies haven't fully opened their eyes yet.

Later when Vasu was carrying the child they didn't zoom on Abha because its obvious that a woman who has given birth would be bleeding

I'm just feel that episode was illogical..I know its a drama and anything can happen but they should have made it seem more real

Guys if you agree with me please press the or give your comments




absolutely agree with u

but logic goes out the window in soapies.
Arshi86 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
First off this is a TV show and that to an Indian family show, no matter how illogical it seems you can't show an actual birth, with the blood, umbilical cord, and after birth, it is too graphic. Also, they would never show an actual new born due to the risk for infection, because a new born's immune system is still under developed. Tto be honest they did everything by protocol, unfortunately the board does not allow these type of graphic scenes, and any real healthcare provider would shoot the writers and producers if they ever showed an actual newborn, it is just to unhygienic.
monachweetie thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Agree with u!but u only said na this is daily soap!any thng can happen here.i thnk they handled it well becoz they cant shw everythng as it happens really and also it nt real life but a daily soap.so i dnt hav any complaint with delivery scenes and i too agree that baby looks very tidy which did nt happen after delivery and she looks like 3,4 months baby but nt newborn child
happygirl123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ffern1012

First off this is a TV show and that to an Indian family show, no matter how illogical it seems you can't show an actual birth, with the blood, umbilical cord, and after birth, it is too graphic. Also, they would never show an actual new born due to the risk for infection, because a new born's immune system is still under developed. Tto be honest they did everything by protocol, unfortunately the board does not allow these type of graphic scenes, and any real healthcare provider would shoot the writers and producers if they ever showed an actual newborn, it is just to unhygienic.


Yes I agree that they can't show scenes like that on TV but at least they should have handled the scene in a more realistic way a different approach maybe...Even in soaps how can a lady give birth without anyone's help and it being her first time..Lo and behold a few seconds later the baby is born..illogical
Edited by happygirl123 - 15 years ago
sahil70 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
yes perhaps it would be too much to show a child birth environment in a indian soap , but then they shouldnt show a full shot of abha maybe just close ups. at least try to be as realistic as possible without the graphic details. in relation to the newborn, in todays film making world with various effects and techniques available, they could create a dummy or something that resembles a newborn so a real one isnt even required for obvious reasons.
kinu17 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: happygirl123

After watching yesterday's episode 2/08/11 I felt utterly disappointed because the way Abha's delivery scene was handled was nothing but nonsense..Yes indeed Suhasi did portray expressions with showed she was in pain..but giving birth in the first place isn't neat and tidy..I'm a medical student and I've seen deliveries there's a lot of blood involved and its not that easy to give birth all by yourself without the help of anyone because Vasu was just sitting there.


After the baby was born,he was not covered with blood and no umbilical cord was cut not to mention there was even a tilak on his forehead as soon as he was born 😆.The baby didn't even look like that of a newborn but instead looks like a few months old because new born babies haven't fully opened their eyes yet.

Later when Vasu was carrying the child they didn't zoom on Abha because its obvious that a woman who has given birth would be bleeding

I'm just feel that episode was illogical..I know its a drama and anything can happen but they should have made it seem more real

Guys if you agree with me please press the or give your comments

since this bhootni track has been started i have started to criticize YMGGK..more than usual... and after watching this horrible delivery of Abha..i am shocked 😕..they should be a limit of unrealistic.. is not it..yes soap is full of dramas but once they can show some real thing...perhaps i might be wrong from u guy's POV..but this is ridiculous,most illogical episode they have ever shown...
above all these kind of scenes even they cant show ..it is horrible..

Edited by Kinara2 - 15 years ago
sahil70 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
while on the subject of illogic still no pratibha or CP anywhere. 😕
-Imu.M- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
I haven't watched the show, Abha's delivery? - is that what was Abha was getting dreams and etc about?
happygirl123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -Imu.M-

I haven't watched the show, Abha's delivery? - is that what was Abha was getting dreams and etc about?

the dreams were about the room Vasu the ghost was locked in and died in

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".