ipkknd a copy of kitni mohabbat hai - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3.9k

Users

14

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

Kmh2best thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#11
when i see the ipkknd i realy miss my fav arjuhi and feel so bad,😭 remember my kmh1.
joiningnow thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
I also thought same and posted in IPKKND forum the same thing. Initial story is copied Like same office scene with Arnav and Khushi. That is OK but feel exactly copy is same sister situation (Purvi's husband died and here Payal's marriage broken) and she is liked by boss's brother. and then same situation like challenge from boss that office will be hell for her. what was bothering most is same scene got copied where she recorded the dictation.
When someone feels that it is copy, the answer is comparison's are not allowed which is not right. This is not comparison but a complaint of scenes being copied exactly. This is called Plagiarism which is not allowed.
What I believe is everyone should be allowed to raise their voice but it should be in a healthy way. I saw some fan of KMH posted objectionable wording in IPKKND forum and in return they said bad words about KMH like messed story etc.
Of course KMH fan should have right to raise their concern and IPKKND fan have right to defend but it should be in nice language. Initials scenes copied from KMH are Plagiarism but now they are moving from copying. like the scene where lead didnt go for western dress but insisted to wear traditional dress. That was unique. KMH was my favorite and still it is and so are'Arjun and Arohi. But when u see IPKKND, Barun and Sanya are good too. Barun is my favorite since Swayam of Shraddha, to me he looks very cute and innocent and and Sanya is too beautiful. Of course Karan and Kritika are too attractive and sensuous. Copy is directors fault so my suggestion- please enjoy the shows and promote ur favorite actors without bashing others.
Edited by joiningnow - 14 years ago
kavyasam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: joiningnow

I also thought same and posted in IPKKND forum the same thing. Initial story is copied Like same office scene with Arnav and Khushi. That is OK but feel exactly copy is same sister situation (Purvi's husband died and here Payal's marriage broken) and she is liked by boss's brother. and then same situation like challenge from boss that office will be hell for her. what was bothering most is same scene got copied where she recorded the dictation.
When someone feels that it is copy, the answer is comparison's are not allowed which is not right. This is not comparison but a complaint of scenes being copied exactly. This is called Plagiarism which is not allowed.
What I believe is everyone should be allowed to raise their voice but it should be in a healthy way. I saw some fan of KMH posted objectionable wording in IPKKND forum and in return they said bad words about KMH like messed story etc.
Of course KMH fan should have right to raise their concern and IPKKND fan have right to defend but it should be in nice language. Initials scenes copied from KMH are Plagiarism but now they are moving from copying. like the scene where lead didnt go for western dress but insisted to wear traditional dress. That was unique. KMH was my favorite and still it is and so are'Arjun and Arohi. But when u see IPKKND, Barun and Sanya are good too. Barun is my favorite since Swayam of Shraddha, to me he looks very cute and innocent and and Sanya is too beautiful. Of course Karan and Kritika are too attractive and sensuous. Copy is directors fault so my suggestion- please enjoy the shows and promote ur favorite actors without bashing others.

Exactly my point. Whenever we raise that issue we are shut up saying comparisions are not allowed. But when the creative teams of other shows are conviniently taking up the hardwork done by KMH creatives, they are backup by saying they know what is best for the show etc etc.
When a part or full fanfiction is copied by someone else it is immediately closed saying it is plagarism, same applies here, it is like they copied the story base of kmh but made some changes here and there in sequences and made it different.
If it was Balaji Telefilms we could have said it is ekta's own work, but here it is a different production house and they have done this before also. Even ekta doesnt copy so many scenes in order like this from her previous shows.
I am sure the actors in other show are good, nothing against them. and here also not everyone is bashing them . It is the fault of the production house and their creative teams.
LOVE_DMG thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#14

i know yar! but is kinda not same cuz the characters as kushi is really scared of her boss where as arhoi wasnt. but they should do something different, it kinda boring .

ishakumar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
they are seriously such copy cats!
MrinalR thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#16
watever it may be v all know nothng can b lyk kmh1 so y v r even dscussing abt it... anyone may do anything bt v know kmh is d best n d rest doesnt matter
Aizatmir thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Ya i too think that.although they r copying the concepts but they dont hv such grt dialogues,music n magic that kmh had.kmh is just incredible n no duplicate can b better than org.bt what i m feeling bad abt is that as ipkknd is on star plus its trp's n ranking is far better than what kmh had.i feel so sorry for kmh.it didnt get the channel n responce as deserved.for me kmh is n will b the best forever...
theresa28 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
ya frds kmh and arjuhi are the best...
no 1 can takes their place in my heart
.StarryPhoenix thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#19
No Comparisons between the show and NO Bashing is allowed.

Thanks
Closed

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".