Ranktheresult(not only final)of the show

Rank How fairer the show's Results --

Compare II1,II2,FG,SRGMP.SRGMP-EMET...Among these which results were fairer..

I rate like this

1)Indian Idol 1-->Not perfect result but still was better

2)SRGMP EMET-->OK until now

3)SRGMP Challenge 2005---.> Top5 were really best but afterwardas result started twisting

4)Indian Idol2--->Amey lost early,4 girls went in a row..

5)Fame Gurukul-->Shamit,Kirti,Arijit voted out very much early

My ranking would be, in order of most fair to least fair:

II1
SRGMP
II2
FG

Let's see what happens in EMET

Originally posted by: bangboy

Rank How fairer the show's Results --

Compare II1,II2,FG,SRGMP.SRGMP-EMET...Among these which results were fairer..

I rate like this

1)Indian Idol 1-->Not perfect result but still was better

2)SRGMP EMET-->OK until now

3)SRGMP Challenge 2005---.> Top5 were really best but afterwardas result started twisting

4)Indian Idol2--->Amey lost early,4 girls went in a row..

5)Fame Gurukul-->Shamit,Kirti,Arijit voted out very much early

i agree with u

agree with sonya!

II1
SRGMP
II2
FG

and i dont watch EMAET....watched like 1-2 scenes i think.....but dont noe about the results....so cant comment on it 😛

The talent in EMET is more balanced than other shows. I have my favorite singers but since they're in jodis, its hard to say which jodi is the best cause in some cases, one singer is good and the other isn't. Its like Dus Ke Dus le gaye dil...almost everyone was a good-great singer..more balanced than say II2, SRGMP or FG...

i only watched bit of indian idol 1(result epi)
i saw the result epi of fg
and i watched indian idol 2 ...

so

ii1


fg-112 on the same line

Originally posted by: sonyaee

My ranking would be, in order of most fair to least fair:

II1
SRGMP
II2
FG

Let's see what happens in EMET

ye i agree😊

I feel in all shows gals missed earleir who deserved to go to atleast in TOP 3...

like

aditi in II-1
Mona in FG(She should have replaced RR)
Himani & Nihira in SRGMP...(Both should have been in TOP 3 atleast)
Antara in II-2...she should be in TOP 3 atleast !!!!

guys like arijit rahul vaidya hemachandra amey also missed earlier !!!!

II-1
LAST RANKING IS GIVEN TO-
SRGMP,II-2,SRGMP-EMET,FG

my rating would be
II1
FG
II2..
i frequently watch srgmp so cant say much abt it