dreamsb thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
You know, I don't know why everyone who is watching this show is on a "HATE" Ratan mission.


But I really like her.

Among all the contestants so far, Rakhi and Rahul (two crazy people), this is the first swayamvar with a relatively normal contestant.

She brings up some very good points.

And while, if she gets married to some of the guys on her show, then it could be risky for her personally...i think by doing these kind of shows in India...we as a community, can learn a lot!

We get to see the kind of things people should be paying attention to when you get your daughter married, and maybe parents will think about looking grooms more carefully, rather than getting them married to the first green card/business man they find.

I honestly really like Ratan's approach. She is being decent on the show, and I hope if she marries someone on the show (like Rahul Mahajan), that she does some more background check.

So, far listening to her and seeing her interviews has made me like her more.

I saw her in Dus Ka Dum, and I felt she was quite rural in her approach...but she looks pretty and is coming across as quite a sophisticated, classy and intelligent girl.

I dont know, maybe people will still hate her...but I really like her. And I genuinely wish her all the very best in life.

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

dreamsb thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
And honestly, I think she would make a decent wife:) I dont know about other celebrities...but she looks relatively middle class and more able to fit into a traditional family than other TV celebs.
Nikhi. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

I agree with you to some extent. She's certainly more normal than Rakhi or Rahul, and perhaps that's why it was pretty shocking to see someone like her taking to the idea of a Swayamwar. I'd seen a bit of her in Rahda Ki Betiyaan, and she seemed like a respectable young lady. So seeing her choosing to have a Swayamwar was almost as if she considered herself to be at par with the likes of Rakhi and Rahul.

And because she's so much more normal than the her predecessors, her Swayamwar is considerably less controversial. To overcome this, and to play the TRP game, it looks like Imagine has made Ratan's Swayamwar even more scripted than the previous ones. And in the process of doing what the channel says, Ratan's making herself seem very contradictory and hypocritical. She says she wants a mature guy, then eliminates some of the most mature people (like Rohit) and keeps some of the less mature people (like Abhimanyu). And it makes it look like she's done these things for the sake of controversy.
In previous episodes, she's also come across as quite arrogant. I mean, I understand that she's obviously the centre of attention. Afterall, it is her Swayamwar. But in my opinion, using the phrase "sadak pe chalte hue ladke" on every other dulha, or referring to herself as "croro ki machine" is not the most dignified way of going about things.
A point to note is that of all the 'Ratan-haters' here, I doubt anyone actually hates her. We do want her to get married to the man of her dreams. And if she finds him through this process, we'll be happy for her. But to be honest, it doesn't look like many of these dulhe would fit the bill of 'the man of her dreams.' And to some degree, that's Ratan't own fault; her criteria of selection seems rather confused.
But I think you're right in saying that these shows do teach us things as a community. The show does raise some important points about what we need to know about a potential life partner before making a decision. And I'll admit that she came across as very decent and respectful when with the MILs, and I did like that.
IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Nikhi.

I agree with you to some extent. She's certainly more normal than Rakhi or Rahul, and perhaps that's why it was pretty shocking to see someone like her taking to the idea of a Swayamwar. I'd seen a bit of her in Rahda Ki Betiyaan, and she seemed like a respectable young lady. So seeing her choosing to have a Swayamwar was almost as if she considered herself to be at par with the likes of Rakhi and Rahul.

And because she's so much more normal than the her predecessors, her Swayamwar is considerably less controversial. To overcome this, and to play the TRP game, it looks like Imagine has made Ratan's Swayamwar even more scripted than the previous ones. And in the process of doing what the channel says, Ratan's making herself seem very contradictory and hypocritical. She says she wants a mature guy, then eliminates some of the most mature people (like Rohit) and keeps some of the less mature people (like Abhimanyu). And it makes it look like she's done these things for the sake of controversy.
In previous episodes, she's also come across as quite arrogant. I mean, I understand that she's obviously the centre of attention. Afterall, it is her Swayamwar. But in my opinion, using the phrase "sadak pe chalte hue ladke" on every other dulha, or referring to herself as "croro ki machine" is not the most dignified way of going about things.
A point to note is that of all the 'Ratan-haters' here, I doubt anyone actually hates her. We do want her to get married to the man of her dreams. And if she finds him through this process, we'll be happy for her. But to be honest, it doesn't look like many of these dulhe would fit the bill of 'the man of her dreams.' And to some degree, that's Ratan't own fault; her criteria of selection seems rather confused.
But I think you're right in saying that these shows do teach us things as a community. The show does raise some important points about what we need to know about a potential life partner before making a decision. And I'll admit that she came across as very decent and respectful when with the MILs, and I did like that.


Much needed post! Thanks a lot for your lucid and well-written post.

Ishya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

I agree with you both!

I don't hate Ratan, I just get mega-irritated the way she acts in certain ways. I am very much worried for her to chose the right guy, and as I would be angry if my best friend would keep choosing idiots for herself, I am also angry about this lol.
Besides the fact of notion that this show is scripted, we sure can learn much about it. The process of arranged marriage is really difficult. And more important, this girl is really a normal girl that does not know much about guys or humans in general. We can clearly see how some guys are just idiots, woh upar se kuch aur dikhte hai aur andar se kuch aur, and we fall for exactly these guys!!!! Why do we actually ignore the good seedha saadha guys, why do we think it's not sexy? Well Ratan is no different, she is choosing the 'bad guys' for herself ;) I am a psychologist myself, and I absolutely adore every kind of reality show, from jersey shore to ratan ka rishta lol! I really like observing people, so it's very informative. We girls can certainly learn something about it. I just hope she marries the right guy!!
xXxrachnaxXx thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
i tottally agree with you..i think the channel tries to make realy really dramtic for thier benefit..
StarryNight15 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

I think we can all learn something from Ratan in this show, i actually like her atleast she's way better Rakhi and Rahul.

IntrovertedDame thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Ishya

I agree with you both!

I don't hate Ratan, I just get mega-irritated the way she acts in certain ways. I am very much worried for her to chose the right guy, and as I would be angry if my best friend would keep choosing idiots for herself, I am also angry about this lol.
Besides the fact of notion that this show is scripted, we sure can learn much about it. The process of arranged marriage is really difficult. And more important, this girl is really a normal girl that does not know much about guys or humans in general. We can clearly see how some guys are just idiots, woh upar se kuch aur dikhte hai aur andar se kuch aur, and we fall for exactly these guys!!!! Why do we actually ignore the good seedha saadha guys, why do we think it's not sexy? Well Ratan is no different, she is choosing the 'bad guys' for herself ;) I am a psychologist myself, and I absolutely adore every kind of reality show, from jersey shore to ratan ka rishta lol! I really like observing people, so it's very informative. We girls can certainly learn something about it. I just hope she marries the right guy!!


This made perfect sense. I don't know why, but we girls always have a thing for bad boys. Wonder why?
dreamsb thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Nikhi.

I agree with you to some extent. She's certainly more normal than Rakhi or Rahul, and perhaps that's why it was pretty shocking to see someone like her taking to the idea of a Swayamwar. I'd seen a bit of her in Rahda Ki Betiyaan, and she seemed like a respectable young lady. So seeing her choosing to have a Swayamwar was almost as if she considered herself to be at par with the likes of Rakhi and Rahul.

And because she's so much more normal than the her predecessors, her Swayamwar is considerably less controversial. To overcome this, and to play the TRP game, it looks like Imagine has made Ratan's Swayamwar even more scripted than the previous ones. And in the process of doing what the channel says, Ratan's making herself seem very contradictory and hypocritical. She says she wants a mature guy, then eliminates some of the most mature people (like Rohit) and keeps some of the less mature people (like Abhimanyu). And it makes it look like she's done these things for the sake of controversy.
In previous episodes, she's also come across as quite arrogant. I mean, I understand that she's obviously the centre of attention. Afterall, it is her Swayamwar. But in my opinion, using the phrase "sadak pe chalte hue ladke" on every other dulha, or referring to herself as "croro ki machine" is not the most dignified way of going about things.
A point to note is that of all the 'Ratan-haters' here, I doubt anyone actually hates her. We do want her to get married to the man of her dreams. And if she finds him through this process, we'll be happy for her. But to be honest, it doesn't look like many of these dulhe would fit the bill of 'the man of her dreams.' And to some degree, that's Ratan't own fault; her criteria of selection seems rather confused.
But I think you're right in saying that these shows do teach us things as a community. The show does raise some important points about what we need to know about a potential life partner before making a decision. And I'll admit that she came across as very decent and respectful when with the MILs, and I did like that.


true! this was a very well written response. So, I enjoyed reading it. And, i agree with you on several of the points.

The scripted part for me is sometimes hard to digest. I actually started watching this show a little later. But, I feel Ratan's emotions are quite genuine...I do think she is nervous and hurt at times, and scared...which she has every right to be.

As far as Rohit's elimination, I think "professor-babu" did raise some doubts in the way he was behaving on their last date. I mean he seemed to asking Ratan to "change," which kind of threw her off. So, it might have been a personal choice in this matter.

And the fact that the face astrologer, raised doubts about Rohit. And Ratan did say she trusted him blindly, so it was kind of all coming together for Rohit's elimination.

taral83 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Actually Ratan said that herself when she found out about Gurav Jaggi. She said she wants to save the rest of girls out their from a man like you. So there is a lot you can also learn from this show. I won't say Ratan is not completely stupid for doing this because to some extent its a bit abnormal way to get married. But think about the old days when your parents saw each other for the first time in the mandap. So, thinking to its not un-conventional way to get married. Its only bashed on because people "think" its wrong because its become a "entertainment" show. Well that is another issue all together. She is getting paid to get married, its better then all the other publicity stunts other actors do (divorces, cheating, abuse, live-in-relationships, etc) As I have been saying all along, we are no one to judge, because we are not there to see what is happening in person. Nor do we know her like that to say what is going on in her heart and mind. So, just wish her the best and let it be. It doesn't change or effect your life does it????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".