Do u like the format of teams?

do u like the contestant divided in three teams

Is that how it's going to be? Then how will there be just one winner? :S

Originally posted by: Preeti_285

Is that how it's going to be? Then how will there be just one winner? :S

yes dats going to happen

No, I didnt like the format of the show.

Don't know why they cut down each group to just 4 so early. And somewhat poor choice of final contestants in each group other than Sonu's.

The quota system is unfair. QUESTION: In a hypothetical group of 24 contestants, 8 'above 25', 8 'below 25' and 8 'groups', what will happen if the top 12 contestants are...

Originally posted by: xobile

The quota system is unfair.

QUESTION: In a hypothetical group of 24 contestants, 8 'above 25', 8 'below 25' and 8 'groups', what will happen if the top 12 contestants are...

...8 'above 25',

3 'below 25' and

1 'group'?

ANSWER: The judges will be forced to pick...

...4 'above 25' (i.e. 4 deserving contestants are eliminated),

4 'below 25' (i.e 1 undeserving contestant goes through) and

4 'groups' (i.e. 3 undeserving contestants go through).

Overall, 4 deserving candidates are eliminated before their time and 4 undeserving candidates get to take their place instead, just because of the quota.

In my opinion Geetesh got eliminated because his category was full of great singers, whereas the 'Last Minute' group, who were good but not AS good, got through because their category had less competition.

I agree. Something similar was done in SRGMP 05, 07 as well and they lost a few good singers because of the forced quota system. I do think Geetesh's elimination was unfair - I was expecting them to make an exception of sorts here. The "Last Minute" group isn't going to last all that long, they look like a bunch of girls decided that they had a better chance of getting in as a group than as individuals. A "group" (i.e. a band) is not a bunch of people standing together and singing, they need to do something different, prove that there is a reason they are a group.

I think each Team should have been this way:

1 Male Above 25
1 Female Above 25
1 Male Below 25
1 Female Below 25
1 Male Group
1 Female Group

Should have been Total 18 to begin with and then each week should see elimination of either singles, or contestants.

Originally posted by: xobile

The quota system is unfair.

QUESTION: In a hypothetical group of 24 contestants, 8 'above 25', 8 'below 25' and 8 'groups', what will happen if the top 12 contestants are...

...8 'above 25',

3 'below 25' and

1 'group'?

ANSWER: The judges will be forced to pick...

...4 'above 25' (i.e. 4 deserving contestants are eliminated),

4 'below 25' (i.e 1 undeserving contestant goes through) and

4 'groups' (i.e. 3 undeserving contestants go through).

Overall, 4 deserving candidates are eliminated before their time and 4 undeserving candidates get to take their place instead, just because of the quota.

In my opinion Geetesh got eliminated because his category was full of great singers, whereas the 'Last Minute' group, who were good but not AS good, got through because their category had less competition.