New Scoring Pattern

As we all know Sandeep won the II and not all of us are happy. most of us are very depressed. well it was just favoritism. it was regional voting and not country voting. so i thought we should have a new scoting pattern:

NOTE: It would be really great f this could somehow be forwarded to people in II...not the sifymax site though.

-Ask the judges to give each one a score out of something. Count the socres as 80% of the total

-The voting should be counted as 20% of the whole percentage.

-This will make a total of 100%

OR

-If a guy is from UP then count only 20-25% of the votes from UP and then the rest of them from the whole of India. this way there is not much favoritism.
(but not declare the fact that the voting pattern has changed)

This way everything will be fair. Judges know the sur and tall of music. You can expect a rickshaw guy to know music. They totally eliminate the judges.

This way everything will be fair. and we will get a SUPERB Indian Idol.

I need your opinions.

this way just imagine a situation: Amey n Karu in final. Judges would be still considered biased by other supporters doesnt matter who they give more votes. controvs will never end.
besides, if u count 20-25 % frm a state, big city guys would never win. May be Abhijit last yr would have lost.
Ur idea is good, but controversy free contest is impossible in our region, where judges gets emotional and stage a walkout.

that is very tru movieman but at least we will get a good singer. plus i consider this that it was the judges fault that they got sandeep.
THIS WAS THE LOSS OF INDIA.
plus they should chage the judges. have you noticed that whatever singer jusdges like, india goes agaist them. we saw that in the case of RAHUL,AMIT SAN (II 1) and in tha cease of KARU,PANNA,ANTARA,PANNA.... the janta just wants to prove the judges wrong.

Originally posted by: arpita_rox

that is very tru movieman but at least we will get a good singer. plus i consider this that it was the judges fault that they got sandeep.
THIS WAS THE LOSS OF INDIA.
plus they should chage the judges. have you noticed that whatever singer jusdges like, india goes agaist them. we saw that in the case of RAHUL,AMIT SAN (II 1) and in tha cease of KARU,PANNA,ANTARA,PANNA.... the janta just wants to prove the judges wrong.

I agree with u. The judges should be someone who the voting ppl would believe and most importantly doesnot speak anything more than the needed comments.

Originally posted by: movieman1111

I agree with u. The judges should be someone who the voting ppl would believe and most importantly doesnot speak anything more than the needed comments.

yes that is very true...they sometimes speak too musch. they should be likesthe judges from FG...to the point..

Or they shud not even mention where the contestants are from 😃

Originally posted by: movieman1111

this way just imagine a situation: Amey n Karu in final. Judges would be still considered biased by other supporters doesnt matter who they give more votes. controvs will never end.
besides, if u count 20-25 % frm a state, big city guys would never win. May be Abhijit last yr would have lost.
Ur idea is good, but controversy free contest is impossible in our region, where judges gets emotional and stage a walkout.

i agree with u,whoever the last two contestants r we would have seen controversies.the peole would have bashed the judges instead of the junta then and for our kind of judges who can state a walk out,an objective decision from them was impossible.In a contest there r people who will be against the winner however good the winner maybe.

If it were amey and karunya in the final and one of them was the II people would still have been dissatisfied.antara and meenal were both very good singers but as soon as meenal was voted out some people on this forum started bashing antara.

we can't have a foolproof system.and plus what is good to me may not be good to u and vice versa.

Originally posted by: Shawn89

Or they shud not even mention where the contestants are from 😃

true very true.. they are from india....

Judges show maximum partiality. The way Sonu was swooning over Antara and the way Farah kept bad mouthing Meenal was just gross 🤢

Plus they are licensed by American Idol so they cannot change the format. I think!

that way it wud be judges idol ..not indian idol .. whether the voters r rickshaw guys or businessmen its the public thats voting to chose their idol ..unless teh public accepts someone he or she wud never be a celebrity .. so the format u suggested maybe good for some other show where ONLY sur n taal matter. the reality is that majority rules whether we like it or not . 😕

but i have to admit asian audiences r different from western audiences,, they attch a lot of emotion n support contestants unlike in the west where they follow the judges guidance more..

anyway the bottom line is its the choice of the public that ll create an idol not th judges choice