I disagree with last episode

delhigirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

DISCLAIMER:

I absolutely nloved the last episode. There were incredible performances by GC and DD. Both were fantastic in portraying their pain and emotions.
However, I still disagree with many things -
1) Maan is taking the blame for the accident but that is just the kind of a man he is. The accident did not happen because of his anger. He did leave the hotel in anger but he truly did not want geet to keep seeing dev. So he was only thinking about geet. Also when he was driving, he was very controlled and not driving in anger. The only thing was that he allowed geet to drive because she was not listening and he did indulge. Both made a mistake.
2) It is true that it was not geet's fault to ask dev for blood. Any wife will do that for her husband and considering what maan means in geet's life this was real. However, Geet should have told maan right away. She is under no obligation to either dadi or dev. The only person that she had a responsibiltiy towards truth is maan. maan's anger only got worse while she waited.
3) Throughout dev 's stay in KM, maan has not been angry with geet, but towards the situation that made dev come in the house and be infront of them. He was still thinking about geet. he clearly says that night that he cannot see geet in pain. He was only thinking that seeing dev must be painful for geet. All this time, geet is listening to dadi and doing things for dev. Even if dadi brought dev home, she should not have given any importance to dev's existence. I am afraid to say that Cvs are making her behave exactly like annie and making her look past dev's sin. Unacceptable.
4) Geet was wrong in saying that maan thinks only about himself and his anger. I disagree, he is still the only man in that house who wants to protect her from pain. However, geet was completely right in blasting him off when he said that she should have let him die. Even when maan had to choose between baby and geet, he chose geet. So he was wrong in saying that to her and she was right in telling him that he was wrong. But she should not have said that he has changed. In essence he is still the same man who thinks of her before himself.
5) Now maan wants to do more for geet. I think he will show her that he does not hate dev by asking him to stay at KM. Absolutely wrong. Geet should actually stop him from that. A man like dev cannot be forgiven for his sin towards geet until he is punished for that.
Even if dev gave blood, his sin towards geet is a crime that cannot go unpunished.
Sorry, for the long post. I thoroughly enjoyed the episode like everyone else , but this is my two sense. I do not mean to offend anyone
Kay
Edited by delhigirl - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

1.7k

Users

16

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

maanmeet1 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
i agree kay.........she was right in scolding him.......wht kind of statement was dat ki mujhe mar jane deti........leave geet, wht abt dadi, annie n all????????? everyone is dependent on him emotionally n everyone loves him so much..........ek ke gunah ki saza sabko to nahi de sakte na.......d way he made his choice geet did d same........

bt maan has to stop thinking dat he has changed........he always thinks abt geet n baby 1st..........geet was wrong in saying dat he thinks abt himself......rather i would say geet needs a reality chk........b4 blaming maan for being selfish she should see herself............

nice topic........maan has always thought abt her well being 1st so no need to blame himself for dat...........
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: delhigirl

DISCLAIMER:


4) Throughout dev 's stay in KM, maan has not been angry with geet, but towards the situation that made dev come in the house and be infront of them. He was still thinking about geet. he clearly says that night that he cannot see geet in pain. He was only thinking that seeing dev must be painful for geet. All this time, geet is listening to dadi and doing things for dev. Even if dadi brought dev home, she should not have given any importance to dev's existence. I am afraid to say that Cvs are making her behave exactly like annie and making her look past dev's sin. Unacceptable.
5) Geet was wrong in saying that maan thinks only about himself and his anger. I disagree, he is still the only man in that house who wants to protect her from pain. However, geet was completely right in blasting him off when he said that she should have let him die. Even when maan had to choose between baby and geet, he chose geet. So he was wrong in saying that to her and she was right in telling him that he was wrong. But she should not have said that he has changed. In essence he is still the same man who thinks of her before himself.
6) Now maan wants to do more for geet. I think he will show her that he does not hate dev by asking him to stay at KM. Absolutely wrong. Geet should actually stop him from that. A man like dev cannot be forgiven for his sin towards geet until he is punished for that.
Even if dev gave blood, his sin towards geet is a crime that cannot go unpunished.
Sorry, for the long post. I thoroughly enjoyed the episode like everyone else , but this is my two sense. I do not mean to offend anyone
Kay



I actually agree with these points....Maan should not fogive and forget at any cost dev......But rest you wrote exactly what I felt.........Maan chose geet life over everything else.......same does GEet ...both were right ......No. 4 and No. 6 specially,,,,,,,,,,,out of geet and Maan ,,,,,shouldt not forgive Dev ............for his sins.........I dont have any hopes for pendulum charcters like dadi and Anie.........BUT NO CHARACTER ASSASINATION OF MAAN AND GEET...
EBasso thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
OH my god Bang on post. Love all your points. Very nice point of view. He has not changed, he has been torn between protecting Geet, and keeping her happy!!! I hated that line too... it is still bothering me!!!
Echoesofpassion thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
I agree with ur 4th point!
This is not the geet who wud forgive such a man
Dev shud NOT be forgiven!
n He shudn be negative either..it wud be illogical
delhigirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: maanmeet1

i agree kay.........she was right in scolding him.......wht kind of statement was dat ki mujhe mar jane deti........leave geet, wht abt dadi, annie n all????????? everyone is dependent on him emotionally n everyone loves him so much..........ek ke gunah ki saza sabko to nahi de sakte na.......d way he made his choice geet did d same........

bt maan has to stop thinking dat he has changed........he always thinks abt geet n baby 1st..........geet was wrong in saying dat he thinks abt himself......rather i would say geet needs a reality chk........b4 blaming maan for being selfish she should see herself............

nice topic........maan has always thought abt her well being 1st so no need to blame himself for dat...........

Thanks Roopa.
If I was the CV, I will make maan apologise to geet for saying that she should have let him die. I will also make geet accept and realise that he only thinks of her and before himself and give him due credit for that
In the end, I will have maan acknowlegde dev for saving his life, but clearly tell him that he cannot forgive him for what he did to geet. Dev can only make amends by lawfully accepting punishment for that.
delhigirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: dtri

OH my god Bang on post. Love all your points. Very nice point of view. He has not changed, he has been torn between protecting Geet, and keeping her happy!!! I hated that line too... it is still bothering me!!!

yes i hated that line. In the end i felt all the blame was put on maan for the whole situation, disregarding everything that happened around him. This whole situation around him was created by dadi, annie, dev and to a certain extent even geet.
Dev is the biggest culprit in all of this. If he saw them at the hotel, why did he keep doing things for them and attract attention towards himself. If he did not want maan and geet to know that he is there, he should have kept quiet and hidden at that time.
Somehow I feel he is playing a bigger game here, and maan is going to get trapped because of his love and respect for all the women in his family
BatameezDil thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
kay i completely agree with you...
Edited by jalparii_h2o - 14 years ago
-Saruu- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: delhigirl

DISCLAIMER:

I absolutely nloved the last episode. There were incredible performances by GC and DD. Both were fantastic in portraying their pain and emotions.
However, I still disagree with many things -
1) Maan is taking the blame for the accident but that is just the kind of a man he is. The accident did not happen because of his anger. He did leave the hotel in anger but he truly did not want geet to keep seeing dev. So he was only thinking about geet. Also when he was driving, he was very controlled and not driving in anger. The only thing was that he allowed geet to drive because she was not listening and he did indulge. Both made a mistake.
2) It is true that it was not geet's fault to ask dev for blood. Any wife will do that for her husband and considering what maan means in geet's life this was real. However, Geet should have told maan right away. She is under no obligation to either dadi or dev. The only person that she had a responsibiltiy towards truth is maan. maan's anger only got worse while she waited.
4) Throughout dev 's stay in KM, maan has not been angry with geet, but towards the situation that made dev come in the house and be infront of them. He was still thinking about geet. he clearly says that night that he cannot see geet in pain. He was only thinking that seeing dev must be painful for geet. All this time, geet is listening to dadi and doing things for dev. Even if dadi brought dev home, she should not have given any importance to dev's existence. I am afraid to say that Cvs are making her behave exactly like annie and making her look past dev's sin. Unacceptable.
5) Geet was wrong in saying that maan thinks only about himself and his anger. I disagree, he is still the only man in that house who wants to protect her from pain. However, geet was completely right in blasting him off when he said that she should have let him die. Even when maan had to choose between baby and geet, he chose geet. So he was wrong in saying that to her and she was right in telling him that he was wrong. But she should not have said that he has changed. In essence he is still the same man who thinks of her before himself.
6) Now maan wants to do more for geet. I think he will show her that he does not hate dev by asking him to stay at KM. Absolutely wrong. Geet should actually stop him from that. A man like dev cannot be forgiven for his sin towards geet until he is punished for that.
Even if dev gave blood, his sin towards geet is a crime that cannot go unpunished.
Sorry, for the long post. I thoroughly enjoyed the episode like everyone else , but this is my two sense. I do not mean to offend anyone
Kay

I agree with all points apart from 5.
How is geet like Annie? How?
Annie who thinks its ok to have sex before marriage?
Its ok to go after a guy who just used u?
Ok to buy his company just so u can make him realize his love? Which there isnt,BTW.
Would Geet ever do that?
There was so much attraction between M and G b4 wedding,they found it hard to keep hands off each other but Geet did not even let him KISS her.
And Annie,She....😡
Im not bashing ur post,Just Annies character.😊
Luv the post,great points,Apart from last sentence of 5.😊😕
.Kiran. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
I, totally agree with whatever u said. The main thing I found wrong && didn't like was when she said "aap ne ek baar bhi nahi socha k dev ko dekh kar mere upar ya beeti hogi" or something like that. This was totally wrong cuz all those days he was worried about her pain & he did tell her that he feels sorry for not doing anything about Dev. How can geet forget that && say that he didn't care about how she felt after seeing Dev?? I mean cmo'n maan didn't know about Dev's donating blood. All he knew was Dev living in outhouse &&after seeing Dev in house he felt really bad for Geet!!
This was totally wrong & unacceptable from my side. But overall episode was FANTASTIC && great job by GC&DD!

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee Thumbnail

Posted by: tellyme

2 years ago

MG FF - Devil's Den #2; Updated Last Chapter Pg 71 May 18 MG FF - Devil's Den #2; Updated Last Chapter Pg 71 May 18

LINK- THREAD 1 INDEX ************************** Chapter 31 - Below Chapter 32 Chapter 33 Chapter 34 Chapter 3 5 Chapter 36 Chapter 37 Chapter 38...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".