Shame on Judges.. SaD - Page 5

[Quote=Bollywood_mad]IN A WAY U ARE RIGHT BUT THEY WERE TELLING THE TRUTH ONLY ANU MALIK WAS QUITE HARSH IN TELLING THE TRUTH TO SANDEEP YESTERDAY

Agree with you! Judges are suppose to be impartial and not support any contestant. But at the same time Karunya is an excellent singer and Indian Idol does'nt want to losse him.

Originally posted by: ATLgal

Karunya deserves all the praises he is getting because he is a great singer and Indian Idol is to find a great singer not a good looking guy that you wanna vote for.

my dear.....
if "Indian Idol was to find a great singer", then AMEY wud not have been out from the show!!!the show is no more a talent hunt show!!

Originally posted by: coolsonu

my dear.....
if "Indian Idol was to find a great singer", then AMEY wud not have been out from the show!!!the show is no more a talent hunt show!!

agree with u.. if indian idol is a talent hunt show then judges decides the winner and program name should be judges idol or sa ra ga ma paa.. but case here is different indian idol has different rules public decides who will reach the idol place...

Originally posted by: ZHCool

i agree that karunya is good singer...

i agree that he holds a great voice..

i agree that he has extra ordinary amount of talent..

i agree that he is the future sansation...

i agree i agreee

but judges i also knows

that u dont have any right to play a compaign for a candiadate

u dont have any moral background to support one and underesstemate otheru dont have right to impose ur judgement to public..

judges

this is a game and every game have some rules..

and the rule for this game is that janta decides , junta play compaign for their idol

its not ur idol it the idol of whole india.. but i dont think so u understand the word honesty and independent views of judges.. i dont think u r playing good role of judges.. i dont think u r good judges.. and sorry i think the great singer and a great composer has not a capability to hold the place on judges chair..

have u seen the face to that poor guy whose name was sandeep.. whenever u r without reason praise karunya and underesstimate him he think that what type of judges u r , what type of game this is where every one in the show playing compaign for only one candidate........

shame shame

I dont agree with your statement on Judges where you are calling them as shame.........

Whatever comments they had given to Sandeep was very true. In all the three songs he was loosing his pitch and was slipping away from sur. None of the redentions were as good as Karunya. So Why judges has to waste their time sitting there and giving wrong judgement by Saying that Sandeep is good even though he is not good. He has no doubt good looks and a killing smile but definitely he is not a good singer........ Judges according to me were very true and very frank in their opinions. And why not? They are professionals so they will definitely expect a good talented singer to be a winner so that they dont have to work much on him. Karunya obviously is a good singer and they expect him to win so whats wrong. I dont think they are doing anything wrong in hyping Karunya. Judges are doing fantastic job of little bit of marketing to promote Karunya. So whats wrong if a talented guy is hyped and is promoted to the top. They know that Sandeep is not that good but still he receives votes. So in order to Psych Janta, they need to do it............So I dont find anything wrong in it.

Try to understand that Sandeep being not that great receives votes from his fans and is never seen in bottom two so whats wrong if Judges try to promote a good singer by hyping him a lot............................Sandeep has forgotten lyrics at times while rendering songs.....

I think Judges are doing great job of promoting a real talent Karunya...........

If you feel that judges are not being fair with Sandeep then you should feel that even Sandeep is also not doing fair by giving bad redentions of songs. ...............

If Sandeep expects good remarks and good comments from judges, then at the same time he has to sing well and make judges happy in order to received good comments. Otherwise why Judges will give un-necessary good comments.

If I was in Judges place, I would have done the same thing by hyping Karunya and promoting him to the top. I would have not expected Sandeep to win