3 IDIOTS - Sofa ho ya Bed, Romance is so dead!!

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Idiots' Tantra Mala

Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

We forgot we are Idiots who are supposed to do chamatkar and not balatkaar ...So new improved Tantra Mala includes what is defined as chamakaar and what is defined as balatkaar



Chamatkar:

1. Your POV
2. Symbolism
3. Ripping of promo, precap, episode
4. Deciphering the characters and their characterization.
5. Storyline, plot, future of the story, track or anything that a new character can bring
6. Ideas unique to Idiot Family
7. Songs, Shayari, Verses, Prose that bring newness to the thread related to the family, characters, story or in general entertainment.


Balatkaar:

1. Bashing anyone ' character, actor, member or anyone who has expressed a POV you do not agree with
2. Ripping ' anyone
3. Ignoring ' Anyone


Ikkraar 😃

Aaaal Izzz Weelll as along as we agree to disagree..
Yaar paancho oongliyan barabar nahi hoti'aur muthi mooh par thodi na maarte hain..use to fight depression, oppression, compression, suppression, impression and enjoy the session


Sanskaar:

1. The first three pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.
2. The chat thread would be the previous day's thread. So feel free to express anything and everything there.
3. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.
4. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyse the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.
5. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

6.We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.

IDIOTZ PHAMILY VM 😃


[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TE5sz3CZd4[/YOUTUBE]

Vrush's Short Story Link

Vinu Ki Nihu - Nautanki Ka Raaz - A Love Story

Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

160

Views

10.1k

Users

19

Likes

241

Frequent Posters

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Ok...i know there will be many likers of today's episode...but for me it was just ok!! Yeh sab theek tha...jab tak shaadi nahi huwyi thi.....lekin shaadi ke baad bhi...wohi gissa pita romance.....wohi eye stares, touching each other's faces....all this has been done before....so where is the romance kicked up a notch....like EMRIL style...where is the "BAM"!!??😕

AA....such a let down track. I know i have said this before, but there was so much potential in this track, and the CVs have opted for such a GHATIYA track....it sso stupid. Now he is simply blackmailing her with the threat of a public announcement of their coupling.....WOW!!

Anne...plz step up to the plate and CRUSH this bugger called Arjun!! We women need some INTEQAM...and now is the perfect time for it!!😡

------Edited to Add------

It seems to me that the CVs are skirting around all of the great possible implementation to the story and and the screenplay. It seems as if the CVs no longer that that CONVICTION in their own work like they used to....they are just so interested in feeding the masses of viewer who watch only to see Maan and some tepid romance.....

Before the CVs showed what they showed with full conviction, because they believed in their story and their presentation...and so it showed on our screens. What we see now is direct reflection of their confusion, their inability to decide on a track and deliver it fully. I feel like we are getting half-assed plots....packaged in a half-assed screenplay, delivered in a half-asses manner depending on the whim of the actor that day!!! Where is the DIRECTOR in all of this...at the end of the day, its his name on the finally delivered product....does he not care how it is received anymore??
Edited by --Nargis-- - 14 years ago
-RushTrip- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Puck PUck PUck pakkkak...!

i swear..now when did the husband ever feel...troubled to remove buttons of the shirt off of his wife

and why does a wife have to wear a shirt...when she comes out of the bathroom?

Chickens i swear!!

so...i refuse to acknowledge a tepid...chai...when i want a piping hot coffee..!!

i really am thinking of retiring from..the serial..for...leaving. is.. probably wiser than..sitting here and trying to tell whoever is listening..if anyone..that...

life after marriage...is..not...skirting..around...the skirts..

life is not washing dirty linen in public...and..a woman..who is 18 in 21st century..has the right to have sex..after marriage...or at least...some sort of closeness from her husband.... and the list if i put it up..will make..people...blush.... for..penetration is not the only way to have sex...is there??

and another 18 year old is adult enough to have sex with a man she believes she is in love with and not feel guilty about it, especially not in today's world where..things like emergency contraceptives are available... if she has made a mistake of forgetting something...like protection...in the throes of the moment..

i think...from being..close to reality..where the serial started off..now...this is not even stuff of dreams... it is leaving a sickening feeling in my stomach...

i think i wont reserve...from tomorrow...

goodbye..all..have fun..watching...Maan's lascivious eyes...for they have stopped talking to me!
Edited by -RushTrip- - 14 years ago
-honeydew- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Reserved- hope i get to write today ...!!!

kya baat hai .. poori family ek line main? ek ke baad ek .. !!!
Edited by -honeydew- - 14 years ago
LavZ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Hoyee Hoyee...aaj tho phamily ek saath😛...four genertnz...bck to bck huh?!😆
kaash Jeeju bhi aajaye....😍😉
.........EDITED........
Old Wine in a new bottle?!😕
kya kashmakash hai yeh.....kya kashmakash hai yeh!
I am confused as to wat I should write! There was a tym in da lyf of dis beautiful serial ver each n every episod said Volumnz to us.....Ver each n every one of us IDIOTS saw soo many symblisms in each n every scene....each of us saw da same thing bt interprtd it diffrntly!....ab der is nothin......If we get one episod of symbolism n den aftr 10-20 episodz v get anothr one....ek hatke episod hotha hai tho ek mei hume jhatke milthe hai.....
Teri meri taqraaro se bana dil ka yeh rishta hai,
Aaina jo main dekhu to tera chehra hi dikhta hai,
Jab se mujhe tu milli.....
Nokh Jhok is da speciality of dis couple....dey shine in dis alwas....Da sofa scene was cute.....
Da shirt scene - well we hav seen dis....bt der was a diffnz....fr a change I would lyk to see sumthin new abt it here....please! har baar kiss karthe karthe dey jst snap out of it.....can v get a bit mor of romanz?😕
even if dey do kiss hw can it affect da baby?...even if dey go a bit out of the way....wat is der to loz I cnt undrstnd....dey r marrid fr Gods sake!....ithni jijhak?!😲.....
Doc said dat gettin physical cd harm da baby....so dnt get that physical! cumon! even if nt a lip kiss....can v hav a passionate romanz rather dan da same old eye lok n snappin out of it? ven v hav got it brfr den y nt nw?hmm.......yeh 21st century hai ya 15th ke?😲chalo chaddo!!!!!!
ye meri bhool thi jo maine tujhe pyaar kiya...
na milane vaale muhabbat ka intazaar hai....
Now cumin to the 21st century couple......AA ~
Arjun is da manipulatr.....n Annie da puppet.....I likd Arjuns charctr brfr....wonder y i feel dat da essnz of dis chartr is lost sumver😕.....Luks lyk Arjuns revng is done.....trick ur enemies sister......get marrid to her secrtly......sleep wid her...leave her...threatn her abt her da same..bhai wah! wat a full proof plan.....🤢😡
Annie - Fight bck! prove dat ur MSK's sis - ur 21st century ki woman.....dnt let him play wid ur mind.....Fight....Fight...Fight! Make us proud!please!!! requst hai!!!!
CVs - please gv us bck da esscenz of da story.....please gv us bck da passionate romance btw Maaneet.....In der romanz,physical intimacy was min bt passion was max....Gv us bck our GHSP!
ek maasum dil hai aur sitam hain kitane.....
is muhabbat ke siva aur bhi gam hain kitane....
mere ishq ka imtahaan yun na lo...
tumhen hai qasam meri jaan yun na lo...
khwaab jitane bhi mainne dekhe hain....
vo mere khwaab meri yaad mujhe lauta do....
Other dan the cute nokh jokh der was nothin concrt in da episod....lyk yest da episod lookd mor a filler to me......I hav learnt one thing nw...Thanks to Nihu - Expect NOTHIN!!!
Jeeju - Where r u?!!!😕 IDIOTS need u now.....we need sum positivity...even da onz who find positivty hav lost it....can u help us please?!
Love,
Lavzz
Edited by LavZ - 14 years ago
preetgurti thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Punjab main wade wade singer hote hai aur wadiya khana shana 😉

Edited by killerkinrul - 14 years ago
Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
Daikhte hain Geet ke Punjab mein kya kya hota hai 😉 ....

Vinu aayega ke nahin, yeh sirf Nihu aur uski mommy hi bata sakti hain 😊.....

CV's ke liye gana

Kaate nahin kutte yeh din yeh raat
Kehni thi tum se ek dil ki baat

Kaate nahin kutte yeh din yeh raat
Kehni thi tum se ek dil ki baat

Lo aaj main kehti hoon ho ho ho
Kiss scene do, kiss scene do, kiss scene do

Koi aur show nahin, bas hum Geet ke hain saath
Kehni thi tum se ek dil ki baat

Koi aur show nahin, bas hum Geet ke hain saath
Kehni thi tum se ek dil ki baat

Lo aaj main kehti hoon ho ho ho
Naye romantic scene do, romantic scene do, romantic scene do

Take on Today's episode:

Left right, left right ka kya chakkar hai Bhai
Geet Maan ki shirt mein perfect kaise thi samai :)

Geet ke creatives ne AK ke shirt scene ki yaad dilai
Geet ne sherni ban kur apni shamat khudh bulai

Kya MSK kareyga uski kuch achi dhulai😉
Ya phir cut scene se aagey sirf humari imagination hi kaam aai

Todays episode was good, MSk and Annie wasn't in favor to give Arjun the contract again, but daadi ki fazol nautanki, and Geet's support made MSK to agree to hire him last time....Annie didn't liked the idea, but she couldn't said anything front of them...Cause she thought it's the last time he would be come front of her....

Sofa scene was cute, i loved the way she pulled him back and said "yeh do logo ka kya chakkar hai, abhi baby paida nahin hova hai" (waise hum kehte hain, pregnancy mein do logo ka bojh uthati hai aurat, double decker bani phirti hai lolz), Maan was funny too when he repeated her same dialogue "paida nahin hova hai", and i also liked her dialogue "aap lambe hain na, main toh choti si hoon, kahin bhi so jaongi" lolz....Anyways cute fight.....

Next morning part was so funny, yeh daadi kub seekheingi ke MSK is married now, and Geet is here to take care of him...Jub daikho muh uthaye aa jati hain...Sahi mein kabab mein haddi bani phirti hain...Waisey i didn't get it what's this left right ka chakkar, kyon banaye MSK ghan chakkar? Anyways daadi ji sensed something, but i don't think so there is anything to hide, and make the blunder...MSK already told Daadi that doc said no stress to Geet, so they can tell her, kya pata Daadi ji hi kuch help kur dein😉......Anyways both satisfied daadi with their blunder story, pur daadi ki aatma ko shanti nahin mili, she wasn't satisfied, but for their sake she zipped her mouth....

Loved it the way he asked her naughtily "toh Geet aaj kahan sogi left ya right", and she told him that she would tells him at night, and ran away from there by taking his shirt as well....

Bechara MSK always she shuts his mouth...He was asking for his shirt, and she gave him lamba chauda lecture lolz....

Shirt scene was ok, not much liked it, cause i have watched the much better shirt scene on Angad Kripa from KYPH, but it was nice attempt, cute......

Don't wanna say much about AA. Arjun ke kameenepan ki daad deyni chahiye, I seriously will punch Annie if she wouldn't stopped behaving weak....Let see who will tell MSK first, Daadi, Annie or Arjun?

Thank you creatives for such a light hearted episode...I enjoyed seriously, it was cute attempt, but it could be more better....MaanEet was good, but they should have to start acting like hubby and wife....Couple not only fights, they romance as well...And if physical relation is harmful for baby, then they can have oral sex as well......

Shirt scene reminded me Angad Kripa shirt scene, and i missed them alot...Their scene was much better yaar or maybe it was first time we saw on them that's why i think, pur it's very much copied....

Over all good episode 7/10...Hope tomorrow will bring some jhakas epi for us, specially MaanEet, hope they will forward lil bit more in their romance.....





Muniza
Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago
Kadds02 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Geet Maan ka jhagra!!!
Sofa ko leke !!! 😕
Dekhen kya gul khilte hain raat ko 😉

*********************************************

Lost interest today!! Kuch likhne ka mann nahin hai!!
Carry on guyz! I guess m off fr the day!! Will see if I can peep in later!

Take Care & G'nite

-Luvz Kads
Edited by Kkadss - 14 years ago
rickks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
Dear Creatives
"Jo Darr Gaya, Samjho Marr Gaya "
Now you decide where do you wanna stand????

The one scene that i loved today was the Sofa Fight.....Maybe it was the treatment given to it....the dialogues, the execution, the way DD and GC emoted/acted was really beautiful.....👏👏
👏👏👏

Ani : Yeh culture, sanskriti, yeh saare sabd aurat ke liye kyu bane hai??? Apko nahi lagtha humari desh ke aurat isliye pichadthi jaa rahi hai kyuki hum in shabdo ke peche bhagthe rehthe hai...Aaj ki ladkiyon ko agar wakaiye mein aage badna hai toh, in purani vicharo waali ladiyo se chutkara paana padega...nahi toh hum kabhi independent nahi ho sakte
This is what Ani says on her first day in show....Where is this Ani Now??? Why is she acting like a WUSS????Why are the CV's making her guilt ridden???Aren't they contradicting what they made her say in her first Episode...???I get the emotional Breakdown, what Arjun did has left a Void in her....but aage bado yaar....4 din se Casette/CD ek hi spot pe atki hai....Since for days Arjun has been giving her khali dhamki's, even if he means what he is saying is it not upto her to show him the door to exit....Common CV's instead of showing her guilt ridden show her tackle the situation and counter attack his ever move...Why show Ani as the Dirt beneath Arjun's shoe?

I was disappointed that logic took a back seat.but thats not new is it??? Maan was avoiding Geet, today the two fight about who will take the bed and who will take the sofa, Why??? To maintain the physical distance and after so much efforts they cant seem to keep their hands off each other.
Yahan tak ki Maan go ahead to strip her off his shirt (If that was what the CV's was trying to show). So what is the big deal about the sleeping arrangement?😕 😲
Ek hi episode mein itna Disjointedness kyu hai???


This is Not a KEKTA SHOW....or is it????I believe a show becomes Kekta only from the execution POV....Ek alag nazariya se pesh karo toh kekta khud apni scne pehchaan nahi kar poayegi......If smartly,beautifully and logically done koi bhi kharab Seq bench mark ho saktha hai😉Earlier also we have had tracks which required suspension of disbelief but execution was so good that we overlooked the logical inconsistencies. Now logic and execution both are bad...everyone is ....These are areas that can be worked upon...but why are they overlooking this aspect of the show???

After the much heated argument on last Friday, why did they not show a heart to heart Convo between the two???Why going for running around the tree romance, which by now are monotonous wit just the packaging trying to be different Geet, her struggles, Maan supporting her and galvanizing her for the challenges ahead, need to be dealt with sheer brilliance and intelligence. Coz this is her Journey....in-spite of being their love story


Nikunj has been improving in the last couple of episodes.
Piyush looks handsome which is now a trade mark for a suave Villanm he is an actor with good acting skills wonder why they end up making him look like nothing but trash???

The morning scene was pretty much a repeat of outhouse scene, Geet comin in MSK's shirt and they getting romantic Geet cornered to the wall! But it was been there done that...where is the freshness...since now they are a married couple does the CV's not know ki the romance should go up by a notch....And here we are talking about MAANEET.....the most passionate couple on Tellywood....why are the repaeting the seq, and even the execution alters leaving you feel Yaar ithna kyu repeat kar rahe hai????

Arjun why are they presenting him as a crappy Villian when they could have actually raised the level of entertainment by making him a classy one....! A man who uses woman for revenge is sickening🤢 and what are the CV's trying to show by making Ani look quiet.....Arrey this Guy was toying with her emotions, her love......Where is her raudra form????She is supposed to be the women of today and give it back to him...why show her as able naari....Kuch nahi toh 4 din se Arjun ke muh se ek hi baat sunkar yeh Pak nahi gayi...Kam se kam uske liye toh Kuch Bolti..Yaar hamesha Aurato ko Bolti Band Drja Kyu dethe hai???Is it because the Team right now has no women on board, they are making it look like this???

Get Nissar Back, he is the only person who can resurrect GHSP now....He is one of the original visionary of this show, in fact the only one left i guess.....Just get him back the show which is kinda failing to connect with the audience

The Spark, the Magic, the Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP is definitely inconsistent, and the CV's does not seem to be able to sustain it .....
Why is it always that we get 1 Brilliant episode then 3 episodes which make u wonder are they a part of the same series😕 then again 2 days of brilliance onscreen and the pattern continues.....5 days of brilliance and 1 day of Crap...or 4 days of brilliance and 2 days of inconsistent is acceptable....after that audience lose their interest.....and thats where the CV's should work....


Whenever GC comes back from Vacation he fails to emote the way he did, Maan looks totally jaded ...DD is the only other person who has been consistent right from day one and she still continues, Geet is a treat to watch.....When Arjun opens his mouth to say his lines i feel shoving the gun into his mouth and pull the trigger......😡

Yaar Maaneet Ki Shaadi Ho gayi...Kya ek sweet Simple Kiss nahi dikha sakte???Forget a Lip Lock and no way am i talking about the Papa Kiss....😡But a normal Kiss, romantic sweet sa toh dikha sakte hai, Hain Na????I am sure ithna karne mein he will not lose control of himself and end up being wild.....Maan ithna bhi kamzor nahi hai, if he could be calculative during the RTM seq just to check what she feels for him, ek harmless kiss se kya hoga????

Why cannot Maan and Geet have one adult conversation and sort out the earlier confusion. That issue is still hanging. In Maan's Convo with the Doctor, she talks about the complication and also about the ABORTION Whereas when Geet said to Maan, she came to know of all this from Doctor we know that the Abortion part was not mentioned there....So shouldn't Maan have made her sit and talk with her....ask about what did the doctor say exactly.....Shouldn't they have a more mature and deep convo and Maan more concerned?

Who is at fault???...

Is it GC and DD who express that they are uncomfortable doing cosy and intimate/Intense/Romantic and hot scenes which leaves the CV's no other choice but to present the old vine in new Bottle

Or

Is it the CV's who fail to write down new and more enthralling scenes because of which both GC & DD are tired of enacting the same old crap again & again...and thats showing on screen.


Edited by rickks - 14 years ago
lovetheserial thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
😛
CV's: Give us: One big passionate near lip kiss, a passionate touch of his fingers on her body (take it real slow 'cause nothing else is gonna come in a long time) and a lie on the bed together; its up to you where you wanna take it, but a lie on, with her body touching his and her legs nearly reaching to entwine his. Nothing else seems forthcoming anyways.
Annie, I have the confidence, will turn the tables on Arjun and this entire take of her modesty is just a ploy where she regroups to use her brain against his. And she is no small Anwesha; her personality, her name will go in the annals of K. Khandan history.
Cheers.
Edited by lovetheserial - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".