Poor judging last week..........

Page

Next Last

vickosh

@vickosh

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

I think the judges were not fair in their jugding last week. On the first day all the stars except Sushant got very poor scores compared to the stars who performed on the second day. If you see the list of scores you will see that overall three stars from the first day were in the bottom three in the judges scoring. For them to make up this ground was very hard. I dont know how Mahi and Ragini got such high scores for their performances................

Both are extremely week...............I dont understand it when Madhuri judges Ragini based on her facial expressions when her dancing is so poor. She gets so tired and immovable in the middle of the routine and her body language is very clumsy.

Mahi is also so slow and weak on her feet. I dont like it when contestants are given some endearing names like "small packet....etc." and just hate it when she giggles all the time like a little child. It gets very annoying. Savio's choreography has very slow movements to compensate for Mahi's lack of speed. Its is so obvious. I dont know why Remo cannot see this. He comments so negatively towards Rushali's choreograpy when you can see her trying so hard to make Daya move...................

I am not shocked at all that Yana got eliminated. She being a model and not so popular as others needs judges help to stay. They were very harsh towards them. Yana on her bad days is better than any other femal celebraty on this show. She is very athletic, graceful and has better body posture while dancing................ Not one of the other females come close...

Quote

Frequent Posters

112642

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

i agree ragini does get tired in the middle of the act a LOT! but she also picks it back up!!

i try to understand the scoring pattern or the reasoning behind it,and i draw a blank!

shekar will get marked the same as sushant sometimes, despite the clear difference...

i guess, its all indiviualistic.. like if a contestant improves from the previous week, marks are given for that... good concept is given marks as well,

going by what you said, judges gave low scores on Day 1, your right and sushant should have gotten 30.. madhuri and malaika gave 9 to sushant and ankita but sushant's act was sooo much better ( i am an ankita,sushant fan, ans i say this without bias)

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

TheUltimate

@TheUltimate

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

Complaining about judges is a loser's excuse. The fact of life is that everyone is biased. Judges are too. If one outperforms the one to whom the judges are biased, then judges' bias might change. Crying about will not.

Quote

raja.baja

@raja.baja

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

Judges are doing what script they are given, Do not blame the Judges please.

Quote

BIackSwan

@BIackSwan

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

u can never sideline judges of a reality show as they'r not paid to give marks and comments freely. they'r responsible for da marks they give to each contestant otherwise y would u need judges in da first place??

wt i dont get is, how can they give gud marks to shekhar who's not performin well compared to others?? i just dont get it at all. how can they give extra marks considerin his seniority?

i agree, yana got out simply cz she's not as popular as da other female contestants but she's da best female dancer in da show who can pull off any dance form unarguably

Quote

Karan

@phadukaran

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

@venture Can you not write in Red to prove your point, cuz its hurts my eyes reading all that in red thanks

Well, again, marks are given in the basis of how they performed in previous episode, and not by who does good comparatively. because then no one will get good score. Shekars' posture and body language in the form given to him came out better then others. Ragini and Mahi do get tired but their energy and presence brings the performance back on track.

Quote

Lathika

@hide

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

shooting of all the dances are on the same day!! it is been shown as two days.. hence the comparison of 1 day and 2nd day not arising.. as all the performances are judged on the same day.. they are even editing the AV's and showing, picking up some good performances for the first day , 2nd day etc

Quote

nishika

@.Nish.

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: venture

well said 👏👏👏

totally agree with u😉

Quote

prettywomen22

@prettywomen22

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

good observation vickosh.... I kind of agree to you. I too don't understand on what stand judges declare their marks. Sometimes they give high marks for the performance which was not good and low marks for the performance which was really good. Until now, I beleive Remo has been consistent in giving the right marks to most of the contestants so far. Again there are times when I felt he should have given better marks to few contestants who really deserved for their performance.

Quote

TheUltimate

@TheUltimate

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: NaDzGirl
u can never sideline judges of a reality show as they'r not paid to give marks and comments freely. they'r responsible for da marks they give to each contestant otherwise y would u need judges in da first place??

wt i dont get is, how can they give gud marks to shekhar who's not performin well compared to others?? i just dont get it at all. how can they give extra marks considerin his seniority?

i agree, yana got out simply cz she's not as popular as da other female contestants but she's da best female dancer in da show who can pull off any dance form unarguably

Very simple if you think about it. Judges' job is to provide an honest feedback from a maestro's point of view.

The judges are the ones who pretty much know dancing inside-out. If the voter is logical and his voting is solely based on the quality of dancing, he will be influenced by judges' comments.

If a voter is an emotional fool, there are chances that he has a favorite judge too. He will vote for that judge's favorite.

If a voter does not have any leaning towards a particular judge but towards a participant, the judges' comments will make him furious if they are against the one who he is supporting.

If Yana is less popular than other female contestants, it did not happen overnight. She knew it before participating in the contest.