Shaan ki badalti good luck charm?

Hi everyone,
I felt it was a major blooper in the script today when Shaan told Sunil that everything is going right because of Sam's re-entry into his life.

As Aditi pointed out in the DT, before going to his project presentation, way back in Aug, Shaan told Khanak that as long as she is with him, nothing bad will ever happen. Now to me that means Khanak is the good luck charm.

Now it's Sam?

Are the writers struggling to show how important Sam is to Shaan? They don't need to put her in the same place as Khanak. She can still be a very important friend.

Its not a blooper, its a serious blunder!!!

ya bu8t wo toda pagal hain na toh usko khud hi pata nahi hain kaun uska lucky charm hain

as u said gaayu, they r trying to show us how important sam was in his lyf....such gr8 buddies they were.....

yeah even i was surprised by that part.... but i guess wht he meant was sam was a big support for him, and that his problems had always resolved when she was there.. that sam was his good luck charm in his college days....

@ Sid
If that is the logic, Shaan is even more of an idiot than I think he is! I certainly wud not want to marry a person who wud revert back to his younger days everytime he comes across an old friend!

Basically, very bad lines being given both to Sam and Shaan. How r we supposed to like them now? Bcos Sam gets a 'hot' scene with Rahul and wears 'bold' clothes, and Shaan kisses Khanak?

I feel cheated ya...

i hated that dialogue.........oh god what was that yaar i never expected that from shaan......... sam is best friend of shaan but it doesnt mean becoz of her entry everything turns out gud in his life......how can he forget khanak who has done so much for him........really shaan is budthal he doesnt know who is important in his life.......

gods knows wats wrong with cvs,

Originally posted by: tvrasika

How r we supposed to like them now? Bcos Sam gets a 'hot' scene with Rahul and wears 'bold' clothes, and Shaan kisses Khanak?

I feel cheated ya...

@ gaayu............u said it............................bang on !!