Judges too harsh on Karu - Page 2

i dont think judges were harsh on Sonu...they over expect from him...

Originally posted by: harshmm

Hi Malathi,

I guess its ok to say that judges were a little harsh on Karu, but lets not drag Sandy and Anuj into this. They have done well this time , they improved a lot and plus they are good people, so lets just focus on judges comments on Karu.

What say?

well said 👏
lets not pull sandeep and anuj into this
this has ben both their best performances
i actually liked all equally
anuj was fab as well
and sandeep was better than ever
karunya was superb as ever

Originally posted by: malathi2100

I saw Monday's gala a few times and frankly felt that the comments were not fair.

For the first song Karu sang Anu Malik said his voice sat for the word Gum or something... You hear the song a few times and cannt even feel it... so minor not worth nit picking. He did not even loose sur AT ALL...

That in mind... Sandeep's aalap was so bad (or non-existent) in the first song... When Sandy and Anuj make so many mistakes (of course much fewer than before) and are having trouble in getting just the sur right... I think it is unfair to be so harsh on Karu when he has sung flawlessly in terms of sur.

Also Sonu saying 'mujhe dar hai ki aap chad jayenge' etc... just doesnot help either... From karu's track record... as he does not get enough votes this may just hurt him...

i agree,but when a very perfect person makes a minor microscopic mistake the judges have problems biciz they dont want to lose karunya and they want him to be alwayz 100 percent.the judges were not taking side.anuj and sandeep were only BETTER not the BEST!!!

vote for karunya as he is a diamond

of course Karunya is a jewel in a crown. Other two singers cannot even be matched to Karu. Yes, the other two were better but not B E S T........

karu kohinoor. 😛 😳 beware britishers might attack him 😉 😉 .just kidding.he is the best.

Originally posted by: harshmm

very true. Sonu is only trying by his comments to help Karu. And he actually said, don't worry, we are pulling your leg and we love you.

I agree. Sonu has always supported Karu and if he says something to him now, it wud be for his betterment. sonu is every contestant's well wisher.

plzzzzzzzzzz dont blame judjes comments

ya,we shud not blame judges.....

true the judges were judging karu at a different level but i feel in a competition, this is not really fair to do that. yet i can undersatnd their reasons, its very hard to place karu on the same level as others....even if it is only for the sake of judging. besides they did say a lot of good things but ppl rather nit pick n talk abt the few not so good things said.