3IDIOTS-Pyaar ka dusra naam ....Maan.

Page

Next Last

nandita singh

@nanditasingh

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

Index of links to the analysis done:

aditi123_78 - https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1498875&PID=34440595�

Sigma - https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1498875&TPN=23

Edited by nanditasingh - 15 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

nandita singh

@nanditasingh

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

Idiots' Tantra Mala

Chamatkar ya Balatkar'idiots ki tantra mala....

Considering that we are all idiots and we need some semblance for we have a pool of writers, analysts and observers, who contribute to increase, improve and help our understanding Geet the serial, characters, plot and other aspects and symbolism in the story. We have people who find elements like water, color and let's not forget inanimate objects like dupatta in their analysis.
So here is the tantra mala for those who don't understand so much Hindi it is a system well it is not idiot proof for it is for idiots..

Tantra

1. The first post is the index and Spoiler links

2. The second post Tantra Mala and Rota

3. The Third post is for the person opening the thread

4. The first three pages are for analysis ONLY as it gets lost in the pages later on. We have received requests for this.

5. The chat thread would be the previous day's thread. So feel free to express anything and everything there.

6. Once the reserve of spot is done within say the first hour, the thread is then open for discussion and replies.

7. Anyone who misses the boat on first three pages to analyse the episode, should send a pm to the opener to index the link so that people find it easy to read your take.

8. We want maximum people to read the analysis and appreciate the effort and time put into watching the episode several time to bring in nuances.

9. The thread will be opened in a rota system and the list will be available on the thread as well.

10. The thread will open at 9:00 pm IST

11. We have opened a Chat Club http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1495244 Please feel free to join this and discuss everything under the sun, moon, stars' anything related to the episode, doubts, different pov, should be done on the main thread let everyone get to know what you are thinking'

Rota Tantra

This week starting September 27th 2010

Monday ' Vrushali

Tuesday ' Rev

Wednesday ' Nags

Thursday ' Nandu

Friday - Dolphin

Next week starting October 4th

Monday ' Pooja

Tuesday ' Shivu

Wednesday ' Viji

Thursday ' Nihu

Friday - Nags

Week starting October 11th

Monday ' Param

Tuesday ' Sann

Wednesday ' Rev

Thursday ' Anisha

Friday ' Sann(nupsie)

Anyone wanting to open the thread please send pms to the founding members, RushTrip, Revv and Nargis

IDIOT Assignments:

Aamir Khan ... Rancho - Nargis
Kareena Kapoor ... Pia - dolphinUSA (Dol)
Madhavan ... Farhan Qureshi - RushTrip (Vrush)
Sharman Joshi ... Raju Rastogi - MaaneetDD (Rev)
Boman Irani ... Viru Sahastrabudhhe - Viji
Omi Vaidya ... Chatur Ramalingam aka 'Silencer' - mysterygurl1427 (Shivani)
Javed Jaffrey ... Ranchoddas Shamaldas Chanchad - Yasu09
Mona Singh ... Mona - blueangle13
Rahul Kumar ... Millimetre - MM - SIGMA (Pram)
Ali Fazal ... Joy - NanditaSingh
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre - Neha
Rajeev Ravindranathan ... Lead Ragging Senior - pooja83
Akhil Mishra ... Librarian Dubey - Maneetforever (Amerra)
3 IDIOT Audiance - aditi123_78 (Aditi)
Mona(Geet's) Unborn Baby - --sann-- (Nupur)
Shoaib Ahmed ... Chote - jamoshi2507 (Neha)
Meghna Bhatia ... Raju's Wife - pickle6586 (Soumya)
Amardeep Jha ... Raju's Mother - macho_muffin
Malvika Singh ... Mona's Baby - Star Struck- Anisha
Chaitali Bose ... Raju's Sister -LavZ

The Open positions are:

Parikshat Sahni ... Farhan's Father
Jayant Kripalani ... Campus Interview Panel Head
Chandrashekhar ... Airlines Ground Staff 2
Dushyant Wagh ... Centimetre
Achyut Potdar ... Machine Class Professor
Atul Tiwari ... Minister in Auditorium
Arun Bali ... Shamaldas Chanchad
Supriya Shukla ... Matron in Hospital with Pia
Farida Dadi ... Farhan's Mother
Omi ... Chatur - pondicherry boy
Pooja Goswami ... Air Hostess
Harvinder Singh ... Mr. Dhillon
Nishi Singh ... Maid at Pia's House
Dinesh Kumar ... Mona's Husband
Aakash Dabhade ... ICE Student 2
Pitobash ... Junior 1
Rakesh Sharma ... Minister at Shyamaldas' Funeral
Michael Joseph ... Exam Hall Professor
Captain A.S. Duggal ... Pilot
Dr. Praful Kulkarni ...Doctor startled by scooter in hospital
Sarvanna ... College Security Guard
Trilok Sadhwani ... ICE Student 4
R.S. Kodange ... Doctor at Airport
Mukund Bhatt ... Raju's Father
Tanveer Ahmed ... Professor in Induction Motor Class
Hitesh Tak ... Ragging Senior 2
Sitaram Sharma ... Manager at Pia's Wedding
Raghunathan ... Professor in Corridor
Vaidyanathan ... Professor Vaidyanathan
Rajendra Patwardhan ... Govind
Sanjay Sood ... Peanut Vendor at Shimla
Annapurna Kaul ... Airlines Ground Staff 1
Pandit Prayag Raj ... Panditji at Pia's Wedding
Dr. Kishor Patil ... Doctor in Ambulance with Raju
Dayal Sharma ... Caretaker at Shyamaldas' House
Shankar Sachdev ... Ambulance Driver
Dharmendra Bhurji ... Airport Cab Driver
Apul Jaisinghani ... ICE Student 3
Shailaja Dhar ... Lady at Mona's Wedding
Saurabh Agnihotri ... Housekeeping Boy at Pia's Wedding
Kumar Veer Singh ... Waiter at Mona's Wedding
Sonu ... Library Clerk
Dileep Desai ... Priest at Joy's funeral

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nandita singh

@nanditasingh

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

I will always keep falling in love with you.
For, you see, each day I love you more,
Today more than yesterday
And less than tomorrow
I wrote your name in the sand
But the waves washed it away,
Then I wrote it in the sky
But the wind blew it away,
So I wrote it in my heart and that's
Where it will stay.

i don't know the sweet poet of this lovely verse...if i did ...then i could for sure thank him/her from the bottom of my heart..coz they state exactly my feelings

if anyone thinks i've gone mad....then i'll say
'Yaaaaa! You are Right!'

Title credit : My Sweetheart Pooja🤗

will edit later..if i can find words enough to sum up all

Edited by nanditasingh - 15 years ago

Quote

--Revv--

@--Revv--

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

Love conquers all; let us all yield to love!!

Love and honor, treasures above value!!

Geet remembered what Maan promised her last night.. And she could breathe in the essence of him, his love surrounding her … She opens her eyes and there he is ……..giving him a smile filled with love!!

And he looked soooo cute when he hid from Dadi.. Gosh – MSK who never fears anyone hides from his Dadi!!

And I loved the blessings from naughty Maan!! Yup I was wrong thinking he was telling her to chill!! He was bringing smiles to her life… wow!! He knew she may be overwhelmed and what a beautiful way to divert her worries!! 😍😍😍😍

Today we saw naughty side of Maan- he got Nakul to get the women out!! And again the Sher was playing with the chuha …. Oh loved Geet's diag here!!! 😆🤣🤣

I would be chup bilkul chup about the bath tub sequence… Some things in life are meant to be only felt and this was one of them!! But I have to mention one diag – he talks about finding themselves alone even in a crowd!! 👏👏

The hospital scene!! Finally she goes to the hospital and so we will all know for sure tomorrow that she is pregnant… They are closing the open door for this issue!!!

And him not wanting to go in with her …. The look on their faces!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

And his diag in the precap – wow !!! Just left me speechless!! 😍😍

This song just summed up the epi for me!!

"Won't Stop Getting Better" by Jason Walker

When I thought it couldn't get much better
All the pieces seem to come together
And every single star aligns
Good to have a little piece of mind
It just came to be that
How did it get so easy

(chorus)
It won't stop getting better
And I'm hoping its gonna last forever
The sun won't stop getting brighter
My feet are getting lighter
I am floatin' like a feather
It won't stop getting better
It won't stop getting better
Whoa no

Its like I'm living on a silver lining
Yeah
It's like the world just won't stop smiling
As every single star alights
It's just perfect time
I still can't believe it
How did it get so easy

(chorus)

Keeps on getting sweeter
It's filling me up
And it feels so good
Yeah, feels so good

(chorus)

Edited by --Revv-- - 15 years ago

Quote

_Invincible_

@_Invincible_

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

cv's hats off to u.........

u r ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

i m 😍

maneet were at dere best today...........

epi. 's description is beyond d scope of words.............

MSK is a man to die 4............⭐️⭐️⭐️

for d very first time i will say I LOVE YOU MSK..............u truly live upto ur name

its 4 first time dat my mouth has got struck due to lack of words..........

vinu love u..............👏👏👏👏

so i m not in a mood to analyse anything................

just sit back and read all ur analysis.............

Edited by pooja83 - 15 years ago

Quote

-honeydew-

@-honeydew-

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 15 years ago

He came

He saw

He conquered !!!

Her heart ... Our Hearts ... !!!

End of Analysis.

Edited by -honeydew- - 15 years ago

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 15 years ago

For Those Who Missed it on the earlier Thread Here i am Posting it once again for all of you

🤗

A small VM from My Side to Capture the most anticipated and truly Divine and Magical Confession ever on Indian Television
with a befitting Background score

Do watch....Hope you Like It....

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6d4JgQozKhE[/YOUTUBE]

Dedicated to my idiot family.....
Nihu, Nandu, Dols, Shivu, Pu, Rev, Nags, Vrush, Ani, Muni, Nups, Jes, Imu, Uzma, Neha, Aditi...and everybody else😊
(I am still getting to know who Joined, coz i was away for a week....so please pardon me if i have missed anyone it was never intentional)......

Love Viji

Edited by rickks - 15 years ago

Quote

mysterygurl1427

@mysterygurl1427

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 15 years ago

Every where......the wind......the rain......everything......love.......love......love

i have never seen anything that portrays love so well......
today the wind was beautiful......the rain was beautiful......i felt like going out in that weather and just open my arms and embrace the wind and rain.....and let the rain drops fall on my face......i wanted to smile......and i did.......it appeared over and over again....at every moment......it did not matter that i looked crazy......nothing mattered today......because everything and everyone seemed so beautiful ......it was as if i was in heaven where everything was perfect......where i hoped and dreamt that some day there will be a man like maan.....in not only in my life....but in every girls life......tears rolled down my face as i imagined it to be real.....it felt so tru.....so real.....so different......everything was different.....life felt so perfect......everything felt to be perfect.....today i sang to my hearts content......loud and proud.....when Geet and maan looked at each other in that way....i felt as though i found the love of my life.....i felt love......i wanted to keep having the feeling.....the feeling of love.......the feeling of happiness.....i had it all today......all.....

until......
until....reality hit me........my friend told me to stop......that i was being stupid......that it was all fake....and that i was obsessed.......i got angry.....everything came crashing down at that very moment....and i felt like running in that same wind and rain to my car.....but that is not like me....i give tight answers back and today i said it....i said it all...not caring what my friend or anyone else would think.....

"Just cause i dare to dream.....and dare to fantasize..about something...does not mean that i am crazy or obsessed.....sorry if i am so expressive....sorry for being so expressive....but tell me what did i do wrong....is it wrong to dream....wrong to hope....wrong to want something great??? Don't call something or someone crazy/ obsessed without seeing why this person behaves the way they do.....i dare u to watch my show.....and i dare u to not fall in love with Maan......can u do it??"

she just stood there quietly.......couldn't say anything......i am not obsessed.....we are not obsessed.....this is not obsession.....it is anything but obsession

how easily can everything be so perfect....how easily can the world be beautiful....and its people.....and how fast like a millisecond of someone sayin something foul to u.....can bring all of those feelings crashing down....
and with this i end sayin that.....this happiness that Maaneet have....these feelings they are going through....it is so beautiful.....so real.....will it stay?? Will what they feel come crashing down when Dev's truth comes out??

@Viji- beautiful video!! i loved it!! thank u thank u 👏

Anyone noticed Geet's dupatta?? The white dress she wore today at the hospital....Geet's dupatta was colorful....her dupatta was usually always one color.....and this time it was different......

I feel the dupatta being colorful......symbolizes the happiness that has come in geet's life.....her life has once again become colorful....it is no longer bland....sad.....gloomy.......

anyone notice Maan pull geet's hand a little tryin to pull her towards himself....when he was holding her hand and asked her if she was scared to be alone with him?? it was a small jerk that he gave

u know when maan lifted his hand to geet when she had bowed down to geet blessings from dadi.....i am not sure whether he was jokingly giving her blessings as well....but if he was....u can see it this way....

Dadi does not know that geet is pregnant.....so she gave blessings to get for the engagement and a happy life with maan.....but when maan gave his blessings 😆...it was as if geet got two blessings.....one for the engagement one for the baby 😉

Edited by mysterygurl1427 - 15 years ago

Quote

@rickks

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 15 years ago

More Than Analysis and Symbolism's Today I am all in Praise for Maan Singh Khurana.....I have fallen in love over and over again with the same Guy and the Sad Part is he is not for Real.....

The Brain Behind the Creation of The Character-Maan Singh Khurana, who ever you are, i humbly Bow down in front of you.....The Man you have Created, have made us believe is the Epitome of not Just one feeling/Gesture/Emotion or word but many Put together.

Never in a Show or on the Big Screen have i seen Such Creative Excellence.I know its Just a Fictional Character but i would really want to put it this way
"Maan Singh Khurana is Lord Almighty's Most Priceless Creation ever"

Adjectives would fall short if i am to describe Maan so instead of Using adjectives fr MSK from today onwards I would use the Name to describe feelings/gestures and even adjectives.

Just as my Dear friend Pooja penned it
"Pyaar Ka Doosra Naam -Maan"

Each and every gesture.....
each and every emotion....
Each and every Feeling
Just Sums up to one name-MAAN

Love=MAAN
Selfless=MAAN
Passion=MAAN
Compassion=MAAN
Golden Heart=MAAN
Promise=MAAN

the List is endless.....You name it and you will automatically have "Maan" by the end of it....

*****************

The Creative Team
In whole specially Swati (Screenplay) and Nissar (The Best Director ever and that too with a Vision)-A standing Ovation for Giving us such a Larger than Life show and Making us believe in its realistically......
Geet truly is way ahead of all the other shows and a Perfect example of Creative Brilliance
You had Claimed Right ".Geet-Hui Sab Se Parayi is a show which is Different and Something never witnesses before on Indian TV"

The Actors
Right From GC(Maan) to Drashti(Geet) to Perneet(Meera) to Abhinav(Dev) outshone themselves today......

Gurmeet Choudhary
What do i say of Him.......Any amount of Praise would be inferior compared to the amazing Job he does as Maan Singh Khurana so i would like to be Chup...Bilkul Chup, coz i can never find the right words ever to Say how phenomenally he breathes Life into MSK

Drashti Dhami
Is Definetely the queen of Subtle Expressions and Convincing actions Minus Dialogues....I have never seen any other actress do it with so much conviction.

Perneet Chauhan
Is Fast Becoming everybody's Favorite as Meera/Myra and is doing a Fantastic Job...She has the spunk and intellect needed for the character

Last But Not Least

Abhinav Shukla
I really want to take this opurtunity to Congratulate Abhinav Shukla to enact the role of Dev so convincingly that we hate him to the core....Abhinav ho portaray Dev who is the weakest Character(Due to his actions)....But the strongest link of the story was suberb today.....In the Precap Scene where Meera tells him the truth about Geet's Present status...the way he shakes up (Dagmagana) as though the earth beneath him just slipped off was amazing.....

********************
Symbolism's Not many for me today

Coz everything said and Done by Maaneet was as clear as Crystal and needs less analyzing...But lets see😉

1)Geet seeing Maan and Dadi Not Seeing
To me the scene symbolized that Geet will never have to search for Maan....he will always be there before her eyes...she will never have to look for him....He was there for her ...and only her eyes could see him like no one did...

2)Meera Knowing the truth
Well as expected she was shocked but her immediate reaction was she turned to look at Maan and anybody could tell by looking at him that how much in love he was and that his would be fiance meant the world to him.....Meera being smart would not need a third opinion to figure this out---For me this showed that even if Dev is her friend and she is really standing by his side she will never do anything out of the way ever to hurt Maan and his happiness,and remember Meera and Dadi's first Meeting she had seen how Happy Dadi was that Maan finally Obliged to get Married and she had see how happy Dadima was for Maan....So i am sure she will try everything in her will to not hurt MAAN'S life and his future.

3)Meera Stopping Dev from stepping out of his Room
This was another scene which affirmed that Meera will always be the sole factor who would come in between Maan and Dev....she may be the catalyst paving way for the Dev-Geet confrontation but it will ultimately Meera who will make sure that Dev never comes before Maan's Happiness and his future life with Geet.

4) Maan Looking at the Baby's Pic
To me it showed that he would not hesitate one Bit to call the baby that was growing inside Geet His own.....and the smile he had showed that the baby will never bring any bitterness in his life it will only make him smile.....

I cant think of anything More....Still in Maan Land.....

Episode Rating
10/10

Best Scene
Like all others i too loved the way he bought Geet for Check up and even went on to book the entire Wad for her....But more than that i loved the way he gestures blessing her when she bows to get Dadi's Blessing...It brings a really sweet smile to her face.