Many ways of looking

soapbubble thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
After Kriya Milan last week, I was a little afraid that the serial might go a bit flat - very natural because an anti-climax is a natural progression of a climax.

But no, because barely into monday, we had the new story in place and it exploded all over us with the glory of a messy bomb. Kesar was beaten, she lost her baby, Pratigya called the cops. We were launched into the middle of a debate - one with many perspectives, many views, many opinions.

Now, I'm sitting back and watching the writers of this show bring up a huge array of perspectives and opinions - each character in this show is bringing in a different point of view, one that shows gradations in the whole range.

Pratigya - her stand is clear: this was wrong, we must complain, protest or they will go on doing htis. It is an idealistic, brave stand. Is unhappy to see K's conflict. Can see his distress but believes it is time to act, that NOT to act would be a mistake. She's seeing the larger picture.

Krishna - thinks P is right basically but he is muddled by family loyalty, upbringing, his duty as a son. He also sees P as too idealistic. He complained today that she is applying theory to practice, seeing things in black and white without concern for the greys. He is upset with her for rocking the boat. "Itna sahi karne ki ka jaroorat hai?"

Kesar - doesn't want to be abused, but scared to follow through. She is unable to shake off the habit of fear. Swayed by threats, arguments and manipulation, but as of today, still holding on to her complaint!

Ghanti Dadi - angry but unable to do anything, but going by her expressions thinks that jail is the right place for Thakurain and Shakti. Soundless, wordless but a presence.

Komal - Knows her family is wrong but angry with Pratigya, defends 'how it has always been'. Can't see why it's suddenly a big deal now. She's telling Kesar to go by her own strength, that if she relies on someone else's strength of mind, she'll be neither here nor there.

Adarsh - supports Pratigya's stance, is consoling his wife for her anguish, basically ready to see how things pan out and basically ok with whatever happens as long as his sister is ok.

Nainaji - concerned only about her daughter's happiness, safety and good name

SSaxena - believes his daughter is right, supports her because he wants to stand for what he has taught

RED - hate pratigya but now really scared of her. See P as the reason for all this. She's the outsider who doesn't know how things are run in their society. Keep talking of maryada but don't explain why it is Kesar's responsiblity to ensure their maryada. Surely the best way to maintain izzat is not to hit the woman at all?😕

Naturally each person is right in their own way, right from their point of view. I think it's commendable that the writers are bringing in such arguments in what is a daily soap. Well done, guys, for making us think, making us feel 👏👏 and showing the various ways in which people do react to such situations.
Bubble

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

52

Frequent Posters

HamiSky thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
A Relaxing post Bubble...Good read! Tahnks...
We dont get to see such situations in many other serials....even if there are some..but not such gripping performances ..unique aspect of this show....
Alwayshopeful thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Very well written post Bubble 👏.
I so agree with you. not only this soap provide entertainment but also the food for your thought...Its very interesting to see that every character has their own way of thinking and reasoning in any partcular track...its amazing to analyse how the characters evolve during the show....its a very interesting soap along with the best star cast who give mind blowing performances....Kudos to the CV's...and offcourse also to this forum..some of the posts, responses and replys are so thought provoking...all and all its a good learning experience while being entertained simultaneously😊
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Lallantop👍🏼 analysis of each character's stance on this issue. Life is more a road of greys than black and white.............so much truth to this statement. Depends on context, perception, beliefs and experiences.

Of all the characters involved in this track, the one I am enjoying the most is Ganti Dadi. Her expressions have been brilliant. That one look at KN in his bedroom that said "you rotten scumbag" and rolling her eyes at Amma's theatrics y'day, she has been spot on.😃 Everyone else has a point of view they express with words. But expressions say it so much better.👏
Love-u-all thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
@ Bubble,

U couldn't hold back. There will be no climax leading to an anticlimax which leads to another one merely to shake us up further. Your participation was minimal in that historical thread by Hope??.
Edited by SAM2U - 15 years ago
ShellJA thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Dear Bubble, Great post and analysis of the situation. Most soap super couples become stale as soon as they declare their love. But this show has always been about thought provoking ideas. I love the way this forum lights up as soon as a show is aired. What I love about this show is how well written each of the characters are and their unique dialogues. Also the way each character delivers those wonderful dialogues. To me, someone who does not hear this level of hindi in her day to day life, the language is amazingl from Aman's calm way of speaking to Sagan Singh's yelling, screaming and rambling.

Love the show!!!
Shelly
soapbubble thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: kriyaconsumesme

Very well written post Bubble 👏.

I so agree with you. not only this soap provide entertainment but also the food for your thought...Its very interesting to see that every character has their own way of thinking and reasoning in any partcular track...its amazing to analyse how the characters evolve during the show....its a very interesting soap along with the best star cast who give mind blowing performances....Kudos to the CV's...and offcourse also to this forum..some of the posts, responses and replys are so thought provoking...all and all its a good learning experience while being entertained simultaneously😊



Thank you! 🤗
Yes, that's the thing - not only do the characters speak differently with accents, dialects, vocabulary etc - so different you wonder how many writers are involved, they also have convincing points of view. 😲

Then of course, the actors are superb! 👏 I, at least, haven't seen a soap where so many characters, not just the leads, hold the potential to influence the course of the story.
Bubble

Edited by soapbubble - 15 years ago
soapbubble thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: MERARAI

Lallantop👍🏼 analysis of each character's stance on this issue. Life is more a road of greys than black and white.............so much truth to this statement. Depends on context, perception, beliefs and experiences.

Of all the characters involved in this track, the one I am enjoying the most is Ganti Dadi. Her expressions have been brilliant. That one look at KN in his bedroom that said "you rotten scumbag" and rolling her eyes at Amma's theatrics y'day, she has been spot on.😃 Everyone else has a point of view they express with words. But expressions say it so much better.👏



Thanks Mera! 😃

I know! Ghanti Dadi doesn't seem really conflicted at all! She just hates those two 😆
Bubble

soapbubble thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: SAM2U

@ Bubble,

U couldn't hold back. There will be no climax leading to an anticlimax which leads to another one merely to shake us up further. Your participation was minimal in that historical thread by Hope??.



Sam what to do? you can't shake hands with a fist and I hate arguing.
Bubble

soapbubble thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: lovtv

Dear Bubble, Great post and analysis of the situation. Most soap super couples become stale as soon as they declare their love. But this show has always been about thought provoking ideas. I love the way this forum lights up as soon as a show is aired. What I love about this show is how well written each of the characters are and their unique dialogues. Also the way each character delivers those wonderful dialogues. To me, someone who does not hear this level of hindi in her day to day life, the language is amazingl from Aman's calm way of speaking to Sagan Singh's yelling, screaming and rambling.

Love the show!!!
Shelly



Thanks Shelly! 🤗
yes, I totally love the dialogues! Sajjan Singh is more rustic and old world, Krishna is Illahabadi but more younger generation, Kesar's dialogue is slightly different. Shyam Saxena and Prats are well-spoken heartland Hindi, Aman is also well-spoken but with lots of urdu and a different style somehow - I don't know where he's supposed to be from.
And that's just the dialects!

Absolutely right about loving this level of hindi and variety. I try to learn somehting every day - Shakti Singh called Baba 'himayati' the other day - urdu for ever-supportive.
Then I looked up Alopi Mayya - a variant of the goddess Sati with a legend attached!

I have to say, this show keeps me hooked, one way or the other 😆😆
Bubble



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".