comment plz- v.touching-posted on sify

J_K_C thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
This post is in support for Farah, Sonu and Anu who according to me, have done an EXCELLENT job on Indian Idol. This post is also directed at all those ungrateful people who instead of giving credit to the judges for choosing such beautiful singers keep on insulting and abusing them for being biased, unprofessional and wat not.

Guys, thodi to insaaniyat dikhao yaar. These judges, who happen to be excellent artists and lovely human beings sat through countless auditions, came up with fantastic singers and week after week went through sensless, heart wrenching public voting results. They painstakingly trained all the contestants and always stood by their side. These contestants were like their little kids yaar, who they brought up with so much of love and care.

when Amey was voted out, the audience went berserk and fans and music lovers all across the world were sad, hurt and disgusted. Now tell me one thing. We were all deeply hurt by Amey's exit when we actually don't even know Amey personally. We have never met him, never spoken to him but still we deeply bonded with him just by watching him perform excellently week after week. Now if we were so hurt, imagine the plight of the judges who have been with Amey right from the beginning. How would have they felt when they saw one of the top contestants who rightfully deserved to be in the Top 2 unfairly being voted out. Their's a limit to anyone's patience. They acted like true professionals when they accepted Sagar's, Neha's, Monali's, Panna's, Meenal and Antara's untimely exit. They quietly accepted their defeat without making a huge fuss but Amey's exit was the final nail in the coffin. No true artist would have accepted that. Artists are extremely emotional and all their emotions and frustrations came out that day.

I DON'T BLAME THEM EVEN A BIT FOR DOING WAT THEY DID THAT DAY. THEY DID THE RIGHT THING BY WALKING OUT AND REQUESTING FOR A REMATCH.

So all those people who have been insulting the judges, please stop it for God's sake. If because of your unfair and rude comments, these judges refuse Indian Idol 3, we'll end up having fools like Ismail Darbar on the show who used to create scenes at the drop of the hat.

As far as the issue of Anuj getting symathy votes due to judges comments is concerned, his niece has ensured that his vote bank is cut down by half by her comments in the last show. So don't worry about that.

Lets all give a huge applause to Farah, Sonu and Anu for doing such an awesome job. HATS OFF TO THE JUDGES!!
Posted By : Jatin On : 03/17/2006 &n bsp;

Created

Last reply

Replies

67

Views

3.9k

Users

20

Frequent Posters

J_K_C thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: achhi_anil

HEY THANKS DUDE.nice post

say something more :) give ur opinion...

achhi_anil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
my opinion is the same,thats why i said thank u 😉 ,or else i wud have bashed u 😃 .
J_K_C thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: achhi_anil

my opinion is the same,thats why i said thank u 😉 ,or else i wud have bashed u 😃 .

ok ... thanx...keep supporting Amey!

varmap thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
Thanks for the post...we should not insult the judges..even they are humans..they are also sensitive ...my only worry is what if this is just an eye-wash...what if it has been staged by sony to garner more votes & increase TRP's...
Edited by varmap - 19 years ago
maira_ak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

i m so happy about the fact that sensible ppl r there 2 support our judges . thr judges hud never b biased i believe that 2. but they r also humans and can not tolerate after a certain limit and let me tell u if the did not reat on others exit it is only b'coz amey and karu were the best singers and they were gettind votes but now it was the limit and i know had i ben there then anuj wud not have ben alive
karunya_forever thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
WELL,I AGREE that it was a nice thing to do.but the people who are saying there shouldnt be a re-match they are equally correct in their place
shajjo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Very well said. All along someone or the other is being blamed for the elimantion of favorite contenders. Sonu has said from the start that he saw Amey in the top 2 slot and inspite of proving his talent when amey was voted out, it was a very obvious reaction from the judges. Sonu has said again and again that when he sees these boys/girls perform so well he feels very proud. I am sure all these judges hand picked these contestants and feel a stong bond with them. Except the only area where i dont really agree is bringing anuj back instead of a girl. But let bygones be bygones. We cant sit and sulk over things that have happened. We can raise our voice instead against them so they dont happen in the future.
Give the poor judges some slack and remember NO ONE is perfect!!!! (this does not apply to the contestants 😆 )
Sunitha.V thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

True... I've never felt they've been unfair. They have called a spade a spade unlike in shows like SAREGAMAPA where the mentors just kept promoting their own and did not even make an effort to save the best.

pragatimanoj thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Sorry, i dont agree with you. if they thought that Amey was to be in the top 2 then why go through the entire drama of eliminating 10 contestants. they should have just not let Amey compete in the competition. if he is being voted out then accept the result. It is not that Amey is not an undiscovered talent. Amey was discovered long ago SaReGaMa, but no one music director saw it fit to hir him as a playbacksinger and he was a chorous singer! It is not that he was not surrounded by music directors and other artists. Sonu Nigam himself has said that he has shook hands with amey when he was a chorous singer. If sonu nigam was so confident of amey's singing then why did he not recommend him to other directors. Whatever the judges did that day was "natak" and if they do not like what the public decided they can very well resign.
cheers
pragati

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".