Edited
well i am surprised...or rather i shud say shocked! when i planned to write this topic i actually never meant to critisize or flatter any actor over here...it was just another thought or a strong feeling i wished to share with my co members of this forum...and intrestingly at that tym i was too tired to post anything so thought of catching a nap first and then coming to write it...BUT i think my topic is a hit even before i worded it! ppl saying that s2 had nothing sensible in it DESPITE the fact that when s2 was on air they used to CLAIM that they have stopped watching the show ON TV AND ON INTERNET...the million dollar question here arises is that when they didnt see the season 2 how can they claim that those two months lacked sensibility??? 😕
No offense to u, but the very idea of creating a sensational heading and leaving it reserved does cause agitation, however, I wanted to write on this topic, and yes I have not watched Season 2 until Nupur came, there were 3 to 4 scenes that I watched on YT namely..
Barsi scene
Mayank breaking down in the hospital
Bin tere song
The scene after dia comes and Mayank realises Nupur may be alive
There is nothing for me claim and for u to believe,, the TRPs say it all...anyways ?I was genuinely not interested in this show. ok I'll leave it at that..
Based on the updates i'll have my say.
as for the topic guys i dont think there is any need to write this topic anymore.what i meant to say was that season 2 track was one of the most mature track of mjht till date.the reason was that for the first time mjht handled relationships from a heavier side....from the view of the pain of a husband left alone due to the untimely death of his wife...the trauma of a frnd who is allegedly responsible for the death of his frnd's wife...the loss of a sister who lost everything in her lyf and unfortunately the source destiny chose to cause all this pain was her BELOVED! and the way monaya and arjun played their parts during these two months was really TERRIFIC.the scene wherein gunjan informs mayank of nupur's death...i think arnaya were at their BEST! the bin tere song...samrat gunjan and mayank crying remembering nupur...each emotion potrayed by monaya and arjun was just so perfect. following that mohit's part of ssc...i think no sg fan is ever gonna forget his performance in that avatar. Really in my view s2 proved what gr8 actors monaya and arjun are coz its easy to just do simple romance or comedy but subtle emotions are something at which not every actor can have command but monaya and arjun were surely an exception.
I agree that the track was quite heart rending - on paper- however unfortunately the same could not be translated on screen, thanks to various reason.
I found Arjun wonderful in the scenes where he was missing his wife intensely, besides that ..except as a background actor he dint have much of a role did he?
so, the track had everything except logic, why were mayank and gunjan balming samrat and treating him like a killer. Where is the maturity is showing Samrat as an alcholic who suddenly leaves his "looking for death" ways because Gunjan came back.
If i remember reading right ( excuse me for not watching it ..but its not my cup of tea) ..dint Samrat kiss gunjan forcefully, try to win her over as a sardarjee and stuff...
that was not very mature..and why were the professors trustees and counsellors acting in play.//
seriously logic is not something I look for in MJHT
Edited by myownarea - 14 years ago