Atul is the best, VOTE for Atul

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

coolsam

@coolsam

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc
😳Glad you won't be attacking Farah merely because she expresses her opinions as a judge which is her right by the way. 😊

well, that is not my way 😆 and look who is talking 😆😆😆

Quote

Ankit

@ankit_nyc

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: coolsam
First of all thank you for your reply. and 2nd thing is calling a biased person biased is not bashing. Bashing is not at all appreciated in this post and India-forums will also not tolerate that. That I can say for sure. So no worries there. And third thing is, if you haven't noticed, I am addressing Farah as Farah mam. And discussion forums are meant to discus the related topic in a clean and respectful way.
Well abt the biased part, let me remind that this topic is not on how Farah mam is biased . But this thread is how Atul is a well deserving candidate and the only thing we all wish that the deserving candidate should win. Besides, Farah being biased was just one part of discussion and which is true.

When Atul gave his ariel performance, everybody including Sandeep sir, Terrence, Geeta mam, Remo sir, all the audition gave standing ovation to Atul. But Farah mam did not even get up. Infact she critisized of Atul being too daredevil. And Jai shouldn't have tried this act on Atul. But what I feel is- leave that part of being daredevil. If any kid has given dare devil performance, she must show her concern towards it but at the end at least she can be honest abt how really good the performance was. And she was not being honest that time. Thats what I felt. But for Vaishnavi's performance, as far as I remember, she did not receive standing ovation fromSandeep sir, Terrence, Geeta mam, Remo sir(the day when Atul had got standing ovation from everybody). But still Farah mam gave Best Performance Of The Day award to Vaishnavi. The reason she said that being a girl she has attempted such prop and we should encourage her. But what abt Atul? Is he not her kid like? I like Vaishnavi, too. But that day Atul was far better than Vaishnavi.

I respect Farah mam a lot. And I do not expect such biased attitude towards kids from her. This of course is my opinion...

😕 ummm there is a reason as to why Farah has been chosen to be a judge and no one from the forum has been chosen to be a judge.........😕 so let's leave the technical judging to her, the audience has its chance to vote for the best every week as well........and if the audience didn't agree with Farah mam the results every week would have been different........so let's say your argument is indeed correct and Farah is indeed biased, how do you explain the audience voting then? If Atul was so much better like you said every week then other contestants, how did he only top the voting 1 week and Jeetu topped it numerous times? 😕 The audience and Farah both can't be biased, can they and that too only against Atul and no one else? 😕

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

coolsam

@coolsam

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😕 ummm there is a reason as to why Farah has been chosen to be a judge and no one from the forum has been chosen to be a judge.........😕 so let's leave the technical judging to her, the audience has its chance to vote for the best every week as well........and if the audience didn't agree with Farah mam the results every week would have been different........so let's say your argument is indeed correct and Farah is indeed biased, how do you explain the audience voting then? If Atul was so much better like you said every week then other contestants, how did he only top the voting 1 week and Jeetu topped it numerous times? 😕 The audience and Farah both can't be biased, can they and that too only against Atul and no one else? 😕

In that case Vaishnavi should have topped in voting next week coz the week before she got the Best performance of the Day award from farah mam. But that was not the case. Manoj topped in voting the next week.

Let me tell you my friend that the person who grabs most votes is not always because of his/her talent but because of the audience and its in our hand that we as a audience choose the right one. Many reality tv shows in the past have shown that.

Besides whoever wins in the end I am glad. The result of this contest is not gonna affect the lives of these talented kids. They have whole life ahead waiting for them to succeed. But I would be happy if Atul wins.

Quote

baijubavra

@baijubavra

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: coolsam
First of all thank you for your reply. and 2nd thing is calling a biased person biased is not bashing. Bashing is not at all appreciated in this post and India-forums will also not tolerate that. That I can say for sure. So no worries there. And third thing is, if you haven't noticed, I am addressing Farah as Farah mam. And discussion forums are meant to discus the related topic in a clean and respectful way.
Well abt the biased part, let me remind that this topic is not on how Farah mam is biased . But this thread is how Atul is a well deserving candidate and the only thing we all wish that the deserving candidate should win. Besides, Farah being biased was just one part of discussion and which is true.

When Atul gave his ariel performance, everybody including Sandeep sir, Terrence, Geeta mam, Remo sir, all the audition gave standing ovation to Atul. But Farah mam did not even get up. Infact she critisized of Atul being too daredevil. And Jai shouldn't have tried this act on Atul. But what I feel is- leave that part of being daredevil. If any kid has given dare devil performance, she must show her concern towards it but at the end at least she can be honest abt how really good the performance was. And she was not being honest that time. Thats what I felt. But for Vaishnavi's performance, as far as I remember, she did not receive standing ovation fromSandeep sir, Terrence, Geeta mam, Remo sir(the day when Atul had got standing ovation from everybody). But still Farah mam gave Best Performance Of The Day award to Vaishnavi. The reason she said that being a girl she has attempted such prop and we should encourage her. But what abt Atul? Is he not her kid like? I like Vaishnavi, too. But that day Atul was far better than Vaishnavi.

I respect Farah mam a lot. And I do not expect such biased attitude towards kids from her. This of course is my opinion...

Here is your original post
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
"

please vote for Atul! He is the Best.

He has got that flair of dancing, clear moves, very nice.. And the difficulty level of stunts he has showed through his performances, nobody has attemptedsuch in the show..

He has been forgotten a lot of times by Farah even though his performances were par excellence. Do you remember guys when Geeta, Remo and Terrence were the guests in the show and after Atul's dare devil performance, everybody just gave him a standing ovation except Farah. Nobody got such a grand response for any other performance that day. But still Farah mamselected Vaishnavi's one for 'Best performance of the Day'. Just don't know on which basis these judges promote/praise the contestants. A lot of time I have seen favoritism by Farah in the show for Jeetumoni and Vaishnavi. I do not expect such response from Farah mam. For God's sake this is kid's show... At least be fair here...

I know that all the kids are good but Atul is the Best. So please vote for Atul.

Atul is the right candidate to win this contest."

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here are some points that I want to make

1. I think you are talking about Farha more than Atul here. There is a whole paragraph about Farha's judging which was titled as an appreciation thread for Atul. You have used some negative words (Big sized ones) which make your thread a Farha bashing thread.Merely addressing someone as Mam or Sir does not allow one to use negative words like FAIR/unfair , favoritism etc.

2. Farha is entitled to her opinions and it does not have to match other judges (e.g. Sandip, G,T and R) . Just like you are entitled to your opinions on when to give someone standing ovation without being called Biased towards a contestant. If all the judges have the same opinions then they would not need 2 judges, one will be enough!

3. I also felt that some of the acts in DIDLM are way too dangerous and adult themed and if I appreciate those acts then it may encourage others to push the envelope even further. May be that is the reason why she did not like those acts as much ! Afterall she is a mom and a respectable member of the Indian Film industry who likes to keep a balance in entertainment and responsibility!

4. Your last point to vote for Atul is good ! Let's do that without bashing any one here ! 👏

Edited by baijubavra - 15 years ago