Discussion of the Week: Mercy Killing - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.4k

Users

28

Frequent Posters

-Happy4Ever- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#21
Tulsi is getting too much on my nerves now.

Why can't she confide anything in her husband.

Mercy killing can be acceptable if Mihir takes that decision rather than Tulsi.
sanjana22sanju thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: vinny_rams

specifically as per the story there is no chance of Savita to survive...but then Nandini's case was even worse as she was not even in consciousness...still for the sake of story they did not remove the life support for her.

Considering savita's case as a seperate story not linking with Kyunki serial..then keeping in mind of her age and the complaint mercy killing might not be a wrong idea.

very well said.... ekta does watever she wants.... she waits for a lady who is in coma for more than 2 or 3 years..... now she makes a typical bahu kill her own mother in law without even informing any of her family..... not even her son....i feel ekta just plans everything to show us tulsi crying..........

rose82 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#23

Do you really want to see Savita dying in this way? no...its too bad😭so much suffering is not good🤢

Do you think mercy killing should be legalised? Should it be called an easy way out ? Or can it be a decent end to someone who is suffering?.maybe...i think so.b'coz after so much of suffering...i dont think the person who is half dead wud like to live.its only more of torture.so maybe it shd be legalised.n i think it has recently been legalised in holland or somewhr else😕

Do you think Tulsi has done the right thing by hiding stud from the family? thts the most stupidest thing to do🤢.it amounts to no sense at all.since everyone in the family has a right to pay their last respects.n also she is not the sole decision maker.savita is after all mihir's mother...n he shd be deciding wht to do.

What do you think will Mihir's reaction be when he finds out what has happened?maybe faint😕..its too much to take for..i think.

Feel free to add points which i have missed out in my wuestions.ok sweetooooooo...i love u sweetooooo😉😆

Will post my views soon.ok...will be waiting😃

Cheers!haiiiiiiiiii😕..when did u start drinking sweetoo???😕😉😆

-Eisha

Lady In Pink thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#24

Do you really want to see Savita dying in this way?

No. No matter how much iv hated her, i dont want to see her dying at all. Especially not like this. I mean, being killed by her own bahu?Ekta is probably trying to potray Tulsi's character as of that of a serial killer😕?Starting of as such a strong character, i dont know wht will b left of it if Ekta goes ahead with this mercy killing track. I have always been a dire hard Smriti/Tulsi fan, but this time even im against wht the character is doin.

Do you think mercy killing should be legalised? Should it be called an easy way out ? Or can it be a decent end to someone who is suffering?.

Hmm...i can write pages on this, esp. becaue iv recently written a 800 word essay on Euthanasia.There are 2 sides of the debate really, each side has its own strong points. I feel it depends from person to person.It may seem human to end a persons suffering by pulling a plug, but if we think about it, the fact that God has kept us alive, then we realize that there must be something good to it. Every cloud has a silver lining. I don't thing mercy killing shud b legalized, ppl might misuse it

Do you think Tulsi has done the right thing by hiding stud from the family?

NO

Now this is where even fans like me can't deny that she is wrong. No doubt about the fact that she loves Savita a lot, but she must realize that she isn't the only one in the family. If there is someone who deserves to know about Savitas condition it is Mihir, along with the rest of the family. Hiding stuff will just make things worse. No1 will believe her after Savita is dead😭

What do you think will Mihir's reaction be when he finds out what has happened?

I can only imagine what a son would feel when he comes back to see his mother being killed by his wife.He will obvoiusly be angry at Tulsi. Upset too...but all that is justified i would say. Eventually he will forgive Tulsi n they will reunite....same old track. EKTAAAAAA😡

-Eisha

Lady In Pink thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: rose82

Feel free to add points which i have missed out in my wuestions.ok sweetooooooo...i love u sweetooooo😉😆

Hainnn? 😕AHEMMM...aww....luv u too😳

Will post my views soon.ok...will be waiting😃

Ur wait is over😉

Cheers!haiiiiiiiiii😕..when did u start drinking sweetoo???😕😉😆

Deepa dii😆.....bhool gayii....ap hi ne tou mujhe apni pehli drink di thi😉😆....lolzzz.....i dont drink .😛 BIg mistake...next time wont write cheers....kkhush😃😆

-Eisha

guddusoni thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#26
No. I dont want to see savita dying this way.. but i guess ekta has no other idea. Ekta shudnt have tulsi kill her mother. but i gues to give a twist to a tale .. she wanted it this way. There is no other character, stronger than tulsi , who can kill savita. If we look at a postive way, Tulsi is doing a favor for savita , by freeing her frm this pain , this very cruel pain. But Tulsi shud kill her after everyone gets informed abt it and not by hiding it. About mercy killing shud be leagilsed, it shud be legalised in a way that people cant take adavntage of it. If a person who is suffering frm this pain, and wants to end itz life then i guess he / she shud let the doctor know abt it and then only he/ she can be killed. orelse people will take adavntge of this mercy killing. Nope. Tulsi havent done right thing by hiding it frm her family. Atleast mihir shud ave known abt it.. She knows if she hides something, she getz blamed for it which is truly fair. If Mihir gets to know abt this. he would surely be mad and crazie abt this.. and mite tell tulsi to leave shantiniketan. He wouldnt forgive tulsi for sure.
--Pinky-- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#27
Do you really want to see Savita dying in this way?
No never, she could have gotten cancer, or even a heart attack after hearing Meera and Mandira. What Ekta has shown is really cruel.

Do you think mercy killing should be legalised? Should it be called an easy way out ? Or can it be a decent end to someone who is suffering?.
It can be in very extreme situations and only if the whole family agree. Tulsi alone should not be allowed to take the decision of ending Savitas life, it should be the decision of the family as a whole.

Do you think Tulsi has done the right thing by hiding stud from the family?
No. What happened is very serious and the whole family should be informed immediately. Savita even said she would like to see Mihir. I would like Savita to meet the whole family before dying.

What do you think will Mihir's reaction be when he finds out what has happened?
I am sure Mihir would be very hurt and angry. Whatever he does to Tulsi would be fully justified.

Edited by pinkykhan - 19 years ago
bubbly23 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Immie

Do you really want to see Savita dying in this way?

:::No not realy.I dont like like Savitha very much but she is the only one.can tell family about Meera..also she is Mother.........

Do you think mercy killing should be legalised? Should it be called an easy way out ? Or can it be a decent end to someone who is suffering?.
::: I dont know Mercy killing is a good thing or bad ,but giving moksha to a suffering soul is a good thing........but it dosent mean mercy killing is a legalised....

Do you think Tulsi has done the right thing by hiding stud from the family?

::: thats a BBiGGGGGGG mistake she has done...even savitha reqest or not to inform the Family she shouldnt hid it from family at least she call Mihir or karan must inform.........



What do you think will Mihir's reaction be when he finds out what has happened?
::: Do u mean Killing savitha or Meera's truth....

ok killing savitha.. she is Mihir 's mother if some one kill ur Mother even u love that person more than ur life how could we decide it..one sidfe ur mother other side killer ur own life,love Tulsi......I think he 'll understand Tulsi but it will take time 20 years......
Meera's truth maiby they wont know truth b4 dat Savitha will die..I 'm not sure..........


BYE.THAT ALL.........



Immie i agree with u , its 100% correct, wht will tulsi tell the family members when they return, its the family to take the decision, and always she has discussed with at least 1 person b4 taking any steps , she shld wait till mihir comes back.
pires thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#29
nopes i don't think savita should die like that. she may be rude but its pitiful to see her in that position and upon that i want meera to be exposed, n bear in mind only savita can do that. if she dies kyunki will not that good to watch. afterall i hate meera she deserves to be punish as well as mandira

i don't agree with mercy killing everone has a chance to live
Immie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: bubbly23



Immie i agree with u , its 100% correct, wht will tulsi tell the family members when they return, its the family to take the decision, and always she has discussed with at least 1 person b4 taking any steps , she shld wait till mihir comes back.

Thanx bubbly23

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".