Simi's threshold limit - Page 2

Originally posted by: Laila2009

Bee5, Family friend, tragically not relative, but a family friend that would claim he was a distant relative. I personally never met him but he was a close friend to my uncle, father and mother. My father would joke and say that he remembered the days when he and my uncles would sit with the late Dr. Reza by the "ganda nala" while he would recite his poems.

Can you imagine what he could have done with the show Karol Bagh? You would not have any of this kabootar babootar dialogue but really deep and expressive lines that you would remember today.

See Bee, the line would have had more meaning if it was said by a character that genuinely cared. Just throwing that line there is meaningless in light of Simi's earlier behavior - it has no logic.

I totally agree with you though, even the worst dialogue can have life breathed into it by a talented actor but tragically I feel that this line could have had more meaning a) if it made sense in the overall state of affairs and b) had more meat to it.

I believe many are no longer concerned at the inconsistency with the storyline as long as they receive lines like this and get to see Simi-Abhi scenes but for me there is A LOT of unfinishined business and until the writers resolve these, I am not going to get excited or appreciate these one off sentences.

Laila,
You are definitely right! If Dr. Reza had written 12/24 KB, the scenario would not be like this AT ALL. He would not have made Simi blurt out that line in the park way in the beginning 'magar pyaar toh nahin karte naa' to Abhi and neither would Abhi had called Simi to say "I love you" the very same night where he so thoughtfully had declined anything is there between them and they can stay friends.

I also agree with you about the inconsistency in the storyline and Simi's now-Hot-now-Cold behavior. Actually it is more of Cold-Cold behavior. Her "Warm" behaviour flew outta window the moment she comes to Abhi's home in the night to inform him that she had accepted Nakul's roka and I think that was the very same day when Simi had the roka done with Abhi in the morning (or was it mid-morning!). That way it was a TOTAL hollow dialogue.

The timing she poured the dialogue was not right''Many instances say during the park or even when Abhi begged her to get her life before she had this great idea of marrying nakul was the time it was needed

Her heart says whatever she likes at the expense of Abhi"s life !!!

Originally posted by: bee5

Morsel? Which morsel, Laila. Where was the morsel of concern or love in that scene from Simi. Yes, there was a dialogue from her. It was a hollow dialogue with no meaning.

There was one another scene. Abhi holding Mili's hand and calmly telling her never to repeat this (leaving the house) again. Even here, there was no concern. Abhi just tells a dialogue calmly. Nothing in his eyes or expression.

In this same episode want to see some concern, go watch Manit Joura's expression when Vicky looks at Neetu. He has pain in his eyes. This I would call a morsel bcos it was a bit scene. But Manit really shined in that bit scene in bringing out the pain

Bee5 agree with you on the part where Simi is concerned and the dialogue delivery or the lack of it!...Simi's past comes in her way for this dialogue....😕

Now for Abhi in all sincerity if you are fighting with 6 goons in all likelihood and rescued at the end by your wifey and then dragged in deeper and deeper in the crime scene of a palace looking for HER sister and then have to travel in a public trasportation in Delhi (assuming that because no other vehicle was shown or mentioned)?/or worse walked from the south of Delhi al....l the way to the center of Delhi bleeding..about to faint..... and instead ending up in a hospital greeted by all the family members in a family room😲?/,,,,without the moron doctor who BTW is still missing?/ and your only AID is a small generic band-aid ?/any one in his shoes(not that we want them) would act without any feelings or passion in their acting!!!😆😆

Vicky was in fact an admirable and a FIRST RATE be on and the tears and the feel in his acting was superb.Great job Manji/Vicky😛