Watch

TEAM

Dance India Dance Lil Masters Forum Thumbnail

Dance India Dance Lil Masters India Forums

Khushboo will remain in DID?

Page

Next Last

Jess.

@Jess.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

Okay so in today's episode we see that Khusbhoo has dislocated her elbow (please correct me if im wrong). And from the comments of the judges and Mithun da, it seems as if they will allow her to stay in the competition.

I think in DID Season 1, Paulson was disqualified because of an injury which did not permit him to dance (like in Khushboo's case--Doctor advised her not to dance for at least a month).

Is this fair?

I would love to hear from everyone on this matter. I know that Khushboo is a good dancer, i like her too. But is it right to allow her to stay on the competition without performing for a month? Is this fair to the other contestants who will have to perform twice every week (3 for the contestants who have to perform twice).

Quote

Created

15years

Last reply

15years

Replies

Views

Users

Likes

Frequent Posters

Swag Master From Doncaster

@DesiGirl_

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Well their is abit of fair and unfairness in this. But Khusbhoo is litle, so i guess they will. I hope she recovers fast. Hopefully she gets all better! Poor girl, i feel really bad for her. She kept smiling though, which is what i loved!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Jess.

@Jess.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: SweetDesi09
Well their is abit of fair and unfairness in this. But Khusbhoo is litle, so i guess they will. I hope she recovers fast. Hopefully she gets all better! Poor girl, i feel really bad for her. She kept smiling though, which is what i loved!

Fair for Khushboo and Amrita

Unfair for all the other contestants.

But still, Poor girl...suffering from an injury in the middle of a competition!

But when looking at this from the "competition" perspective, its not fair at all.

Quote

Elephunk

@Elephunk

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

I don't think its fair, the rules should be same for everyone. Like Jess said when paulson got hurt, he was told to leave the show. Also, its not fair to other skippers for amrita to receive another contestant.

Quote

dramebaaz

@dramebaaz

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Its mithunda the bengali babu's liking for amrita and nothing can be done about it 😆

Quote

-Sush-

@-Sush-

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Jess.
Okay so in today's episode we see that Khusbhoo has dislocated her elbow (please correct me if im wrong). And from the comments of the judges and Mithun da, it seems as if they will allow her to stay in the competition.

I think in DID Season 1, Paulson was disqualified because of an injury which did not permit him to dance (like in Khushboo's case--Doctor advised her not to dance for at least a month).

Is this fair?

I would love to hear from everyone on this matter. I know that Khushboo is a good dancer, i like her too. But is it right to allow her to stay on the competition without performing for a month? Is this fair to the other contestants who will have to perform twice every week (3 for the contestants who have to perform twice).

Good Topic, Jess.

I think it is not fair to keep Khushboo in...plain and simple. All other kids are fighting to stay in the competition doing things that some times exposes their weakness. Why does she get a free pass? What is the reason?

If a player gets injured in the game...they don't go to the next round. Why does everyone else have to fight to stay...while one kid get immunity from being voted out?

This also goes against how a similar case washandled before (remember Mangesh?). This inconsistency and making the rules as they go takes away from my faith in their ability to do anything by the rules.

Quote

Swag Master From Doncaster

@DesiGirl_

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: MsUniverse

Good Topic, Jess.

I think it is not fair to keep Khushboo in...plain and simple. All other kids are fighting to stay in the competition doing things that some times exposes their weakness. Why does she get a free pass? What is the reason?

If a player gets injured in the game...they don't go to the next round. Why does everyone else have to fight to stay...while one kid get immunity from being voted out?

This also goes against how a similar case washandled before (remember Mangesh?). This inconsistency and making the rules as they go takes away from my faith in their ability to do anything by the rules.

What if she she gets better near fianle time (hopefully she recovers before that)

Then it wopuld not be fair to let her in for others. I feel abd for her and i want her to reach finals, but in a FAIR WAY, i don't want this to be unfair to others. If she gets to the final with full fairness then okay, but with an excuse like injury, then no. I feel it can be unfiar. Hopefully they think this true AGAIN considering the other contestants and not JUST kHushboo herself.

Quote

-Sush-

@-Sush-

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: SweetDesi09

What if she she gets better near fianle time (hopefully she recovers before that)

Then it wopuld not be fair to let her in for others. I feel abd for her and i want her to reach finals, but in a FAIR WAY, i don't want this to be unfair to others. If she gets to the final with full fairness then okay, but with an excuse like injury, then no. I feel it can be unfiar. Hopefully they think this true AGAIN considering the other contestants and not JUST kHushboo herself.

Well, I am not suggesting that the injury is an excuse....I have no reason to think that it is, but just as the injury is real...the consequences of the injury are too.

Edited by MsUniverse - 15 years ago

Quote

gilmores

@gilmores

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 15 years ago

Khushboo is a wonderful dancer and I would love to see her still in the competition, but from the competition's POV, it's highly unfair for her to still be part of the competition and essentially get a free pass for a month--pretty much into the top 5..

The other contestants are working very hard, preparing atleast 2 dances a week, fighting to stay on, and it's very unfair to them and the other skippers also that Khushboo gets to stay..

In DID, Paulson was disqualified for his injury, and so was Mangesh after a few weeks and I don't think it should be different for Khushboo because she's a little girl..

Maybe they can give her a direct entry into the next DIDLM?

Edited by chocolover89 - 15 years ago