Judges Bottom two Opinion

Judges Bottom two Opinion

Anu Malik:

Yashraj

Arpita

Sunidhi Chauhan:

Yashraj

Tia

I was happy when Judges gave their opinion on Bottom 2. It showed that they appreciate the Real Talent.

I would like to applaud Sunidhi Chauhan for bringing out Tia's name. 👏👏

What do you guys say about that? Was that a good idea to ask Judges or not?

I dont like arpita's singing...she screams and shouts a lot while singing forcing me to lower the volume of my television set

Yup it was a good idea. The contestants should know where they stand.

Sunidhi's choice is more palatable than Anu's.

But based on last gala, which is what it should have been ( I am old-fashioned)...YASHRAJ and NAUSHAD

Don't get me wrong...love Naushad...but truth is truth.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

Sunidhi's choice is more palatable than Anu's.

But based on last gala, which is what it should have been ( I am old-fashioned)...YASHRAJ and NAUSHAD

Don't get me wrong...love Naushad...but truth is truth.

Originally posted by: pakeezah

Im glad judges dont go by last performances, but on the whole. Otherwise Yashraj

was told in first gala or before,his was top performance by Salim and he might have

ended up indian idol which seems unacceptable to all judges and junta now.

Originally posted by: ZoobiDoobi

i don't think its based on previous week gaalas anymore.

its about overall singing now.

If its overall singing, shouldn't be vague...there should be a proper rating system based on cumulative marks...or else subjectivity creeps in, other factors creep in...music gets spoiled. 😕

I have problem with what Sunidhi said, was her judgement based on last gala or was it based on overall performances, if it was based on last gala round I dont agree with Sunidhi. Also I think it should not be on overall performance basis anyway or else whats the need of having performance every week.

i had same bottom 2 as sunidii

Currently, it should be Tia, but I disagree with the fact that Tia was named as the weakest, when it was Yashraj, because at least Tia was trying, there was no signs of improvement from him.